4 ms·
Let's imagine hypothetically that sad, negative posts get more engagement by whatever metric Facebook uses, and Facebook was paying no attention to sentiments a
by emodendroket 6y ago
Let's imagine hypothetically that sad, negative posts get more engagement by whatever metric Facebook uses, and Facebook was paying no attention to sentiments at all and ending up putting more sad posts on feeds. Would that have been unethical? I can't really see what would be so different.
- alfl 6y agoIs it unethical to create an automated system that maximizes global unhappiness for profit?
- erik_seaberg 6y agoWhen a movie makes the audience sad, it wins Oscars, we don't censor it. Why should the rules be different for Facebook?
- pizza 6y agoIt's hard to get a lot of positive reinforcement by interacting with like-minded others at scale through a movie. Facebook's original stated intent was to study contagion of emotion, which seems to me to suggest a multiplayer, interactive effect.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tobr 6y agoThat is a banal comparison. When a film makes you sad, you are aware of what is going on. If you are unusually sensitive to these types of emotions, you can read about the film ahead of time to see if you might want to avoid it.
- emodendroket 6y agoDo you typically go read a synopsis of the entire plot of a film, including any surprise developments, before watching it?
- tobr 6y agoNo?
- emodendroket 6y agoOk. Then what you’re saying doesn’t make sense.
- tobr 6y agoWhy?
- emodendroket 6y agoBecause films’ promotions may deliberately conceal information about tragic events in the story to achieve maximum impact and nobody thinks that is unethical.
- tobr 6y agoThis feels a lot like talking to Eliza. Your replies very vaguely connect to what’s being discussed in this thread, but there’s just no substance or coherency to the argument.
- emodendroket 6y ago"When a film makes you sad you are aware of what's going on" is your claim, but I don't see how that applies to something like, say, Terminator 2, whose entire goal, according to Cameron, was "making the audience cry for the Terminator," yet was not promoted as a sad film. It's hard to come up with a principled difference here.
- emodendroket 6y agoWell, if so the problem goes a bit deeper than Facebook.
- tobr 6y agoYes, that would be deeply unethical. And to make matters worse, I believe that’s a fairly accurate description of how Facebook works.
- emodendroket 6y agoSo how could someone ethically run social media of any stripe?
- tobr 6y agoI don’t understand how this question can follow. Are you suggesting that social media simply must optimize for engagement and not pay attention to negative consequences?
- emodendroket 6y agoWhat does that mean? Like, we want the Facebook mods to delete anything that's too depressing? Sounds more dystopian rather than less... and I thought we were supposed to be worried about "duck syndrome" where everyone appears to be having great lives, making you feel bad, because you don't see the negatives (like a duck paddling underwater, see?).
- bryan_w 6y agoExactly, we have no idea if HN is supressing positive stories in an experiment or not. Twitter, reddit, FB, tictok all sort content by magic and could be trying to make you sad.