5 ms·
The copyright industry is worth billions and billions of dollars. Their lobbying power is insane. Plus they have the USA on their side pushing their intellectua
by matheusmoreira 6y ago
The copyright industry is worth billions and billions of dollars. Their lobbying power is insane. Plus they have the USA on their side pushing their intellectual property laws on every country on Earth via trade agreements. Seriously doubt we're gonna beat them at this game.
Our best bet is to create technology they cannot block. Make it impossible for them to enforce their ridiculous laws. Decentralized, anonymous networks that everyone can use to communicate. If we can send arbitrary data to each other freely and without fear of consequences, their little data monopolies and regulations won't matter.
The idea is to increase the government tyranny necessary to enforce laws we don't agree with. We'll eventually find their limits.
- cortesoft 6y agoI want to agree with you, but I worry about the long term effect of this. If we don't fight the laws and just use technology to prevent enforcement, they are going to continue to push for more and more draconian laws to enforce their copyright... they will point to these technological bypasses and say "they are breaking the law! We must stop them"... and if the tech can't be stopped without outlawing general purpose computing, they might outlaw general purpose computing before they admit defeat. Yes, develop technology that is censorship resistant, but we ALSO need to fight for more sane copyright rules.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoYou're absolutely right. I always support any effort to fight these laws. I just don't think they're likely to succeed. > we ALSO need to fight for more sane copyright rules I don't think there will ever be "sane" copyright rules. Copyright itself is insane. It was sane before computers existed. Back then you had to be a major industry player in order to infringe copyright at scale. You had to own things like printing presses. Now copying data is trivial. All software has access to a memcpy function. All you need to do to copy files is hold down Ctrl + V until your hard drive is completely filled with copies. It's trivial to send these copies to anyone over the internet or sneakernet. Copyright is insane and utterly incompatible with the era of information and computers. I hope it's abolished within my lifetime. > and if the tech can't be stopped without outlawing general purpose computing, they might outlaw general purpose computing before they admit defeat This is a given in my opinion. The copyright battle is really a battle for computing freedom. It's our computers, if we want to copy data it's our choice and nobody cares about some made up copyright monopoly. The computer obeys us. The only way they can possibly enforce copyright is by making it so computers obey them instead. This will destroy free software and free computing as we know it today. I'd rather the entire copyright industry goes bankrupt than lose that. It's not just copyright either. Governments the world over have an obvious interest in controlling computers because of cryptography. It used to be a military tool and because of computers it became democratized, widely available and used by every citizen. Cryptography can defeat governments, militaries, judges... It's subversive technology. They think it's too powerful for mere citizens to have access to.
- alexvoda 6y agoI completely agree with you. However, on the point of copyrights opposition of free software, even though I agree with you, you will find the most surprising of people disagreeing. I, holding the opinion that all copyright is obsolete, once foolishly tried to debate RMS at a conference. For some free software advocates, copyright is essential to the existence of copyleft and copyleft is essential for free software.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoIt's not surprising that Stallman disagrees. He depends on copyright. The entire free software movement he started depends on copyright. The GPL depends on copyright. Like all copyrighted works, free software suffers from the exact same infringement problems. People violate licenses every day. Nobody is gonna go to court over it. The best people can hope for is for some organization dedicated to GPL enforcement to do it for them. Resources are scarce so they're only gonna enforce the GPL strategically for important projects and against important violators. I don't agree with Stallman on this subject. He depends on copyright but at the same time condemns the hardware features designed by the copyright industry to enforce copyright. I feel like I can't believe in both at the same time.
- foerbert 6y agoI probably lean more towards your side of things (or even just outright agree with you), though I can see how RMS's position isn't inherently inconsistent. There's a difference between the legal construct of copyright and the technical enforcement measures foisted on buyers or computing hardware. Wanting to rely on the legal construct while avoiding the later strikes me as excessively idealistic... but we're talking about RMS here. It's not exactly analogous, but it seems somewhat similar to supporting enforceable stop signs and being against using a camera to do so.
- jfim 6y agoThey're not irreconcilable positions though. One can support authors having rights over the distribution of their works, while believing at the same time that the different DRM technologies are an overreach.
- StavrosK 6y agoStop watching movies and listening to music. Well, technically, stop paying for movies and music. You have to be okay with big-budget productions not existing any more, though.
- oscargrouch 6y agoI think capitalism will find its way over organic forms of financing things, even complex and expensive ones. We will go through this crysis phase where the old ways dont work anymore, and the old pals with their expensive lawyers and lobbies will harass and squeeze everybody in their way. We already have forms of doing this right now of course, but the old, centralized, man-in-the-middle-who-steal-all-the-value, pyramidal, egotistical way are still coexisting with the new ways. What needs to die is a way of life that is in the end burning and eating all of our planet resources like there's no tomorrow. The internet revolution is here to stay and it can change our way of life for the better or for the worse, if we just let them impose their monopoly in a insane global level. If this happens instead, it will be pretty hard to get out of it as this new class of rulers will have power never seen before.
- thomastjeffery 6y ago> Our best bet is to create technology they cannot block. Make it impossible for them to enforce their ridiculous laws. That won't do anything about the second and third order effects like DRM, not being able to choose your TV or game console's OS, etc. What we really need is for the proletariat to stop putting up with this shit and take some power back from the borgois monopolists.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoAnyone can get a compiler and develop free software. Unfortunately hardware takes way more knowledge to design and manufacture. The future of free computing will never be secure until we can make chips at home just like we can make software at home.
- praptak 6y agoThis will only create a niche platform for a handful of geeks. Technology does not solve social problems. Consumer boycott does not solve social problems. Political action does.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoI agree we can't win at paying politicians but the technical battle will always be hit and miss. I think we need a political campaign to remove power from the hands of the government and putting it back on the market.
- question11 6y agoSupport a pirate party https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirate_Party https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirate_Party