2 ms·
Minus the culturally specific terminology like 'angel', those motifs can be found in every mythology and every religion. There's nothing particularly Christian
by krapp 6y ago
Minus the culturally specific terminology like 'angel', those motifs can be found in every mythology and every religion. There's nothing particularly Christian or Catholic about them, it's basically the Hero's Journey.
- olivierestsage 6y agoI guess there are two discussions to be had here. The first is whether, in light of the author's explicit statements that he means the work to be Christian, we are still authorized as readers to abstract his text into a general idea of "the Hero's Journey." The second is whether there is anything distinctively Christian at all about LotR, when considered on its own terms. I would say that LotR objectively differs from the Hero's Journey in that it insists on mercy and the principled refusal of worldly power as its most central ideas.