7 ms·
The delineation of this argument is what made me switch to Linux. On Windows, things that should have been getting easy were getting harder for me: software man
by smoldesu 6y ago
The delineation of this argument is what made me switch to Linux. On Windows, things that should have been getting easy were getting harder for me: software management was getting worse, updates were getting worse, and everything that should "just work", just wouldn't. My experience on MacOS was just as bad, with all of the 32-bit apps I used gone in the wind. Now the 64-bit apps are up on the chopping block, and I had to look for other options.
The learning curve for Linux was larger than Windows or MacOS, but I only learned the truth. By cutting away abstraction, I can actually understand what my system is doing, and be a better citizen of my operating system. Linux is arranged masterfully, and makes the Windows filesystem look like a joke in comparison. It's also faster than any of the Macs I own, with the freedom to plug in a modern Nvidia GPU and play whatever games I want.
- eliasbagley 6y agoI would love to to use Linix as my daily driver, but keep needing to go back to Windows for Ableton and gaming.
- smoldesu 6y agoI switched to Bitwig, which has a native version for Linux. The workflow is very similar to Ableton Live, with a little bit of extra configuration. As for gaming, it's a case-by-case situation, but Valve Proton is good enough for 80% of the games I like.
- eliasbagley 6y agoYeah I've heard that Bitwig could be a good solution, and is made by the original developers of Ableton. But what about 3rd party plugins? As far as I understand, most of these won't work on Linux either.
- enriquto 6y agoYou are spot on. And now, try OpenBSD. It's the next step in removing useless abstractions.
- bopbeepboop 6y agoWhat are the BSD options these days?
- fordsmith 6y agoI'm an avid Linux user, completely unfamiliar with BSD. Could you shed some light on how it further removes abstractions? I don't mind trying it out by booting it from a usb
- enriquto 6y ago> Could you shed some light on how it further removes abstractions? By not running hundreds of useless programs, I guess. If you launch htop inside OpenBSD, it'll fill half of your terminal, and the rest is empty. The easiest way to try it is to install it on a virtual machine. You'll see that not much is needed to get to a point to launch firefox from an xterm.
- anthk 6y agoTop itself is enough, you don´t need htop.
- enriquto 6y agoTotally agree. But I'm somewhat used to silly things about htop, like selecting a process to kill using the arrow keys, or a default refresh rate of less than 1 second.
- secondcoming 6y agoI find htop's ability to view the tree structure of a process quite useful. Name your threads!
- horlux 6y agobut that's the case for some linux distros too, e.g void
- deleted 6y ago
- dbolgheroni 6y agoI don't know if you are talking about Linux the kernel, Linux the entire distro, Linux the filesystem (out of tens of supported filesystems), but "arranged masterfully" is big statement. From 2 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26821298 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26821298
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bestinterest 6y agoI wish wish wish I could move over to Linux but its font rendering situation is terrible [1] I've tried Manjaro and Ubuntu to no avail. I have no idea what causes it or if people on Linux are not as sensitive to it or its a specific hardware setup which causes terrible fonts but once you read Windows fonts stuff looks so much better to me. Apparently its a hot debated topic but its so obvious to some it seems. [1] https://pandasauce.org/post/linux-fonts/ https://pandasauce.org/post/linux-fonts/
- christophilus 6y agoI have a 4K and 5k display, and I find it as pleasant as my 2019 MacBook. I’m not sure if it’s because I’m not sensitive to it, or what. (I’m using Fedora with Gnome 40.)
- ahartmetz 6y agoFreeType and slight hinting + subpixel antialiasing looks great to me, really... Windows has strong pixel-fitting and at the same time softer outlines. That is after using the ClearType tuner to tweak it to my liking. I'm not particularly fond of that look. You talk about hardware. The gamma of your screen makes a difference - antialiasing relies on it. The ClearType tuner has a page or three about that. I guess on Linux you better set your display gamma to the standard value, there is no good reason (except visual impairment or something) to set it to anything else anyway. By the way, font rendering in Chrome for Linux used to be really awful (no subpixel AA or something). It was fixed a few years ago - it looks like any other app now. I omitted some detail that you can easily find in your favorite search engine.
- riskable 6y agoHah: I am very particular about fonts myself but what bugs me most isn't sub-pixel hinting (which is "good enough" with the latest freetype IMHO) it's the size of fonts. Windows is so far off the mark on 99% of computers and it drives me crazy! Repeat after me: 72pt is one inch tall! 72pt is one inch tall! 72pt is one inch tall! The "point" scale of fonts is actually a precise, real-world measurement like inches, millimeters, etc. Fonts may differ in how much space each glyph takes up but in general they should at least be close to the correct size. Test it: Open up a word processor and load some reasonably normal font (e.g. Arial) and make some text that's 72pt. Then hold a ruler up to your screen: Is it about 1 inch tall? How far off the mark is it? If you're using a modern, high-DPI display it's probably waaaaay TF off, haha. Even with regular displays it'll be off and there's actually no way to fix it because you can't tell Windows the precise DPI of your display! It tries to guess based on the DDC data given by your display but then averages the X/Y together to scale fonts. So if your X DPI is higher than your Y DPI it'll always get it wrong. Always! Macs cheat in this area by always having displays of a fixed DPI. For the longest time all Apple displays were precisely 96 dpi (with perfectly square pixels) but recently changed it to 220-ish and made adjustments in their font rendering engine to match. I have no idea how they're handling non-Apple displays these days. Linux, on the other hand does it right (at least X11 and KDE do) in that it scales fonts very accurately based on the DPI presented by your display via the DDC protocol (or if your monitor doesn't provide that you can set both X and Y DPI manually). Gnome and GTK applications have the same problem as Windows though in that they only take one DPI setting and if the DDC protocol gives separate X/Y values it'll just average them and the results can be... Ridiculous. You don't really notice the weirdly-stretched fonts until you open a KDE application side-by-side with a GTK one.
- grawprog 6y agoI love Linux based operating systems and I've used them pretty much exclusively for at least a decade now, and I agree with a lot of your post, but >By cutting away abstraction, I don't think I agree with this take. You haven't cut away abstraction, you've changed to a different kind of abstraction. Linux's 'everything is a file' abstraction is just that, an abstraction. >Linux is arranged masterfully, and makes the Windows filesystem look like a joke in comparison It's arranged more simply and straightforward, masterfully though, I dunno... Every flavour of Linux uses a different layout for its root directories, stores configs in different places and generally is not consistent from distro to distro. User configs are also scattered in random places at times. They could be in .config they could be in .local they could be in .$APP_NAME they could be in the app's directory, they could be in /usr/ somewhere. Maybe in a couple different places at once. Who knows? It's a mystery until you track it down. Dependencies and libraries are a huge pain to deal with, especially when you start mixing and matching distro provided libraries with custom built ones. I'm not trying to disagree with your post or anything. I love the way Linux lets you have control over your computer and doesn't try to stop you. But, it's definitely got some issues. I've only touched on a few related to your comment itself.
- mikepurvis 6y agoThere's also a lot of sub-ecosystem issues which are more prominent on Linux, like the long-standing surprise that NPM doesn't have a global rc file in /etc: https://github.com/npm/npm/issues/533 https://github.com/npm/npm/issues/533 The argument from the maintainer is reasonable that distros can just patch it, but realistically, everyone wants a newer version of things than what their distros ship—a similar tug-of-war ends up happening in the Python world, where distros like Ubuntu and Debian ship patched versions of pip/setuptools, and then users are encouraged to self-upgrade those tools to the upstream versions. Anyway, this kind of thing isn't necessarily anyone's fault, but it is just a pretty different experience from Mac or Windows where you tend to have things be more self contained, like "here's where my Python installation lives because it's the path I put in the box when I ran setup.exe."
- smoldesu 6y ago
- matheusmoreira 6y agoLinux is also stable. The binary interface isn't going to change. It's possible to write Linux software that you can boot directly into and it will never stop working or do anything you don't want it to do.
- RedShift1 6y agoBecause there's a BDFL at the top. Linus understands that the whole point of a kernel is having a stable binary interface to run programs on, anytime somebody wants to break userspace he goes on a rant and rejects the idea, rightfully so. Many other projects do not follow this way of thinking or don't have a BDFL. They break API's because... someone felt like it? Every once in a while I dig into the changelogs or migration guides of projects (sometimes they don't even have a migration guide which is just awful) and you'll see things like changed names of functions, swapped argument orders or even complete removal of functions. But why? We don't know and my guess is it usually boils down to someone "feeling like it".
- matheusmoreira 6y agoYeah. I suppose without Linus's leadership Linux just wouldn't be the same project anymore. The world has come to trust him because he makes good decisions. We depend on his core values such as "don't break userspace". I wonder what it's gonna be like in the future... > They break API's because... someone felt like it? I empathize with them. Designing software is essentially philosophy. The interfaces reflect the developer's current understanding of the world. When this understanding improves, people are tempted to update software because they feel like the software is wrong and unelegant when it doesn't match what's in their minds. It takes a really good engineer to reject this impulse and take responsibility for interfaces people came up with in the 90s.
- dzolob 6y agoI have been having a terrible time staying away from conda in windows, but the ridiculous amount of time and spent trying to install some python modules using pip is just not worth it. I’d be lost without wsl.
- tigershark 6y ago>> The learning curve for Linux was larger than Windows or MacOS, but I only learned the truth. By cutting away abstraction, I can actually understand what my system is doing, and be a better citizen of my operating system. Linux is arranged masterfully, and makes the Windows filesystem look like a joke in comparison. What windows filesystem (FAT, FAT32, exFAT, NTFS) look like a joke and compared to which Linux filesystem? Ext2? Ext3? Ext4? ReiserFS? ZFS? It’s pretty clear that you never used Linux in the 90’s from your comment. And the main problem with Linux at the time had nothing to do with the filesystem but mainly with the immaturity of the complete system. I am very curious to understand what great truth you understood by using Linux. Would you kindly teach me this great knowledge and illuminating experience that I somehow missed?
- smoldesu 6y ago> What windows filesystem (FAT, FAT32, exFAT, NTFS) look like a joke and compared to which Linux filesystem? I was referring more to the layout of the root directory (oftentimes referred to as "the filesystem", but now that you bring it up I also hate the Windows filesystems. FAT32 needs to go out to the pasture, and it wouldn't even exist if exFAT support was so broken on lower-end systems. NTFS is fine, but pathetically bare-bones. I'm a BTRFS evangelist, but even ext3 makes NTFS look old by comparison. > It’s pretty clear that you never used Linux in the 90’s from your comment. This is true. > And the main problem with Linux at the time had nothing to do with the filesystem but mainly with the immaturity of the complete system. "at the time" meaning 2018 or the 90s? Maybe 30 years ago Linux was immature, but now it's the benchmark of maturity. Very few *nix systems have share it's pedigree. > I am very curious to understand what great truth you understood by using Linux. Would you kindly teach me this great knowledge and illuminating experience that I somehow missed? Nope, probably not. If using Linux wasn't an enlightening experience because you last used it in the 90s or because you have an FAT fetish, I can't really help you.
- grishka 6y ago> My experience on MacOS was just as bad, with all of the 32-bit apps I used gone in the wind. Were you forced to update to Catalina? I'm still on Mojave right now. My 32-bit apps still work, happily unaware of the fact that they're no longer supposed to.