5 ms·
>China and its axis ally Russia, clearly bump up against the West because our political systems are fundamentally opposite, democratic vs autocratic. This is a
by whatshisface 6y ago
>China and its axis ally Russia, clearly bump up against the West because our political systems are fundamentally opposite, democratic vs autocratic.
This is a speck of misapprehension that slipped in to your otherwise great writeup. Governments don't naturally conflict because they have different forms and they don't make automatic friends when they are similar. The US is presently allied with many autocracies. Middle-aged Europe was uniformly feudal, and constantly at war. Pre-WWII America was strictly isolationist and despite being a democracy had a fairly sized pro-Hitler element. Governments conflict when they have something to conflict over.
- riazrizvi 6y agoWell thank you. Yes I should learn to tighten up my comments, too many points. It’s a whole new discussion here that we could get into.
- buran77 6y agoThe real reason superpowers clash is that they all want to be the dominant but there's only room for one at the top. The political or economic systems are absolutely irrelevant here. All that matters is what needs to be done to stay the dominant superpower. The closer the race, the lower they're all going to sink. US leadership fundamentally doesn't care about human rights abuses in China more than Chinese leadership cares about abuses against black people in the US. They don't care about bringing democracy in a country when their next move is to make sure "the right" leader is appointed. They don't care about freedom of speech when they can block it as needed under any pretense. And they don't care about any of the principles they advocate if those principles get in their way, they will all happily ally with someone embodying the exact thing they're fighting against if it server their interest of maintaining or growing their power. And getting to the point addressed above, they care about the image of the company they forced to introduce backdoors only as far as they can be punished by the bigger power, or if they can't sell it as fighting the terrorists (or scare word of the day). Case in point, Sweden and Ericsson wouldn't get away with it because their sphere of influence is a stone's throw away and the US would crucify them. China and Russia can mostly get away with it because their influence extends far enough that they have enough of a "friendly audience" for which they can sell a story. The US can get away with it everywhere else because even if Cisco is backdoored through and through, the US is the dominant superpower and is able to pressure allies to "see things" their way, and they can also sell everything as "the fight against ...". Superpowers see advancing their interests by any means as a matter of survival and this takes precedence over anything else. They'll do what needs to be done and deal with the fallout after. And if you live long enough to move through these different regimes you start seeing the pattern immediately, only thing that changes is the "feel good" story the people are served with.
- lenkite 6y agoI prefer the "feel good" story of the US - ruled via democracy rather than the "feel good" story of China - ruled via an unelected communist bureaucracy. I suppose if you take a world-wide poll, most folks would agree with me.
- anchpop 6y agoThat is definitely true, but I think there’s an effect where citizens of a democracy are less likely to be willing to go to war against another democracy. It would be easy for americans to justify war against china, because americans value democracy and can say “we’re liberating them from their oppressive government”. (And some segments of the chinese population are very oppressed, so it wouldn’t be wrong.) But it seems less likely that a democratic government would oppress a majority of its population than an autocracy world, so that justification is harder to make
- whatshisface 6y ago>I think there’s an effect where citizens of a democracy are less likely to be willing to go to war against another democracy. It's difficult to disentangle that from the unpopularity of war. Since democratic regimes are harder to get to do things, because you have to convince more than one person, the null hypothesis would be that autocratic regimes have a higher propensity for belligerence, especially in societies predating the invention of propaganda.
- inglor_cz 6y agoFrom what I read about Nazi Germany, going into all-out war with other powers was very unpopular in 1939. Ordinary Germans supported Anschluss of Austria or Sudetenland, but did not want to risk another big war for Poland of all things. But in a totalitarian regime, consent of the governed did not matter much. Expressions of pacifism would land you in a concentration camp really quick. Democracies care a little more about what the average Joe thinks, even though they are far from perfect in this regard and consent can be sorta-kinda manufactured.
- riazrizvi 6y agoDemocracies are less likely to fight because during diplomatic talks they can draw on their domestic values that are rules on ‘how to collaborate without giving up autonomy’. Autocratic cultures most fundamental rule is ‘who is charge’ and then establishing the hierarchy of where everyone else fits. So you are always more likely to end up in stalemate or conflict when an autocracy is one of the negotiating parties because of a higher likelihood they might want to force the issue that they are in charge.