7 ms·
I'm definitely in the minority of commenters on these FLoC threads. I hate that 3rd party cookies exist, and support FLoC if it would hasten the demise of 3rd p
by xnx 6y ago
I'm definitely in the minority of commenters on these FLoC threads. I hate that 3rd party cookies exist, and support FLoC if it would hasten the demise of 3rd party cookies. It seems like many consider the alternative to FLoC to be an anonymous web where content can be accessed without login. The migration of content into walled gardens like Instagram seems more likely to me.
- livre 6y agoThe idea that FLoC is a more privacy-friendly alternative to third-party cookies is deeply flawed, please read [this](https://github.com/WICG/floc/issues/100 https://github.com/WICG/floc/issues/100).
- xnx 6y agoThanks. Good thread. Sounds like FloC is definitely more anonymous than third party cookies that are already in use today. There might are some hypothetical situations with FLoC where some information might be able to be inferred given sufficient data, but this is not trivial/direct like it is today.
- z77dj3kl 6y agoNo, that attack is trivial and direct, that's the problem.
- livre 6y agoI have my doubts about the "more anonymous" part, mainly because 3p cookies are constrained to a single browser on a single device and can be easily erased or blocked, but your browsing habits that will land you on a certain cohort will remain the same across devices so you could technically be tracked cross-device even if you don't sync your browsing history or cookies (if I am reading right the way FLoC works). Quick edit: you are certainly right that it will be less direct and more effort than cookies.
- ljm 6y agoNot to mention that this only really makes it more difficult for businesses who haven't already infected the web with things like social media buttons, widgets, or analytics scripts. Neither Facebook nor Google require third party cookies to function, and I doubt FLoC would make any difference when they can already slurp up so much data that is voluntarily provided by other people without your consent (your address book, for example). Google even goes one step further by connecting your Google account directly to the browser, but there's also a reason why your Facebook login will never expire unless you force it to. This whole thing feels like paying lip-service to privacy to keep people distracted from the reality that a cadre of 90s/00s tech giants have essentially usurped the web. Most people on the internet use a web browser developed by a search engine company that evolved into a faceless advertising giant, after all.
- manquer 6y agoFacebook ads and Google ads do not need third party cookies ? How are they serving contextual ads if they don't know what you are doing on different websites if the myriad of trackers they offer to content websites do not track you by third party cookies ?
- cratermoon 6y agothere are several ways. ETags for one, another is to have all the various sites that use an ad network to send the relevant visitor fingerprint data to a central broker that correlates the information and attempts to determine that entity A and entity B are really the same person because a bunch of attributes match.
- GeekyBear 6y ago> Sounds like FloC is definitely more anonymous than third party cookies that are already in use today. Not at all. My browser deletes cookies from any website (by default) as soon as I close the last tab for a given open site. If the browser itself starts tracking me, my privacy is reduced, not enhanced.
- Thorrez 6y agoI would think that whenever the "clear cookies" command is given to a browser, it also clears the FloC ids. Is that not the case?
- freebuju 6y agoYou just might be right. If you clear the history, the FLoC machine will have to calculate the cohort ID afresh. There are other use cases for this as this form of identification can be manipulated. Don't want to see cat ads anymore, google more dog memes next week.
- mpol 6y agoThird party cookies are already on the way out, allthough it is going very slowly. But if that is already happening, I see no reason to replace it with something that is going to stay and is only slightly better. Being patient is easier and better, it will be a question of a few years I suppose, instead of, I don't know, forever? :)
- xnx 6y agoContent providers want third party cookies. Users have no idea what third party cookies are. Any deprecation of third party cookies will have to come from the user-agent (Safari and Chrome being the only ones that matter).
- glsdfgkjsklfj 6y agoYes. And it is exactly what is happening just fine. Thank you very much.
- amluto 6y agoContent providers don’t. Advertising networks do. If the whole industry moved to content-based advertising, the content providers would be just fine.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoYes even the advertisers don't care. It's the networks themselves that build value worth big data that keep the myth alive that tracking is necessary for advertising.
- glsdfgkjsklfj 6y agoThis! All the clueless/guerrilla marketing(?) people defending FLoC/(faux de-)CentralizedIDs as an either-or choice for getting rid of 3rd party cookies are disingenuously or maliciously trying to steer the discussion to the wrong direction. None of that is a requirement to get rid of 3rd party cookie! just like Microsoft Silverlight was not a requirement to get rid of Adobe Flash, no matter how much microsoft employees wanted you to believe that.
- monkeybutton 6y agoOne of the contenders for replacing 3rd party cookies is The Trade Desk's Unified ID 2.0, which if I understand correctly, would require users to login in everywhere and be tracked in exchange for free content. But it's going to compete with other companies like Google and Facebook for managing users' online identities.
- SimeVidas 6y agoWhat’s wrong with just showing normal ads like we had for over 100 years? Is tracking really needed to prevent walled gardens?
- gopi 6y agoCPM price for targeted ads is lot more than untargeted ads. So likely the publishers will increase the number of ads per page to maintain the same eCPM yield. Also the ads will optimize for top of the funnel (clicks) than bottom (conversion). So we will start to see aggressive & intrusive ads. (remember the "punch the monkey" ads from the early 2000s?)
- SimeVidas 6y agoBut does the money go to the publisher? I’ve read somewhere that most of it (like 90%) goes to the ad tech middlemen. If the ad does not track, there is no ad tech, so more money goes to the publisher.
- coldpie 6y ago> CPM price for targeted ads is lot more than untargeted ads. Only because they're viewed. If we can get everyone to install an ad blocker, that price will plummet, and business models that aren't based on abusing users will be allowed to succeed.
- Google234 6y agoIf that happens many many websites won’t be able to operate for free like they do now.
- syntactic-sugar 6y agoI'm still not convinced that's a bad thing. Does this not ensure profitable sites will be around because they provide enough value to their users to charge a fee, everything else will be stuff like passion projects. I really just feel that 1. Advertising is manipulative and evil in its' modern form, and 2. Targeting further multiplies its' ability to do evil. I'm not convinced that what we receive in exchange for empowering 1 and 2 is in any way worth it.
- NotPractical 6y agoI think it's probably naive to assume that, if FLoC was implemented, advertisers would just stop using their existing tracking technologies, which allow for better tracking than FLoC offers. I imagine most would continue to use these, plus FLoC.
- xnx 6y agoAdvertisers will not have the option to use third party cookies when they are disabled by default in Chrome (what Google is working toward).
- oh_sigh 6y agoBut the existing tracking technologies will be going away. 3rd party cookies soon enough will be blocked by default on the major browsers.
- sixothree 6y agoWhen 3rd party cookies are gone, we won't need floc either!
- danShumway 6y ago> if it would hasten the demise of 3rd party cookies Will FLoC speed this up? As far as I know, Firefox, Chrome, and Safari are already largely publicly committed to phasing out 3rd party cookies over the next couple years. I guess FLoC might move that deadline up a bit? But I suspect some critics of FLoC are looking at the proposal as a compromise that we don't need to make. The thinking is, at the point where we have public statements from every single major browser, including Chrome and Edge, that 3rd party cookies are going to get phased out, why do we need to throw the advertising industry a bone? We won this particular fight, 3rd party cookies are going out the door. Now (the thinking is) we just need to make sure that counter-proposals like FLoC and FPS[0] don't reverse the gains we've made. I'm not completely sure how to characterize Google's recent proposals, but an arguably reasonable take that I've seen online is that Google somehow got peer-pressured into making a very public commitment to remove 3rd-party cookies, that they no longer feel they can back down from that commitment, and that a lot of their recent proposals seem to be attempts to find some way to get out of that deal. First Party Sets in particular are just a very conveniently timed proposal. I suspect this take is at least a little simplistic, but if it is at all accurate then now is a very good time to increase pressure on Google, not decrease it. So I think we might be in a situation where the onus is on people proposing compromise to prove that compromises will make a difference, because I don't take it for granted at this point that FLoC's acceptance or rejection will change anything about how 3rd party cookies are handled in the future. [0]: https://github.com/privacycg/first-party-sets https://github.com/privacycg/first-party-sets
- jefftk 6y ago> Will FLoC speed this up? If you look back at Chrome's original announcement about phasing out third-party cookies, they are explicit about replacements like FLoC being how it happens: "After initial dialogue with the web community, we are confident that with continued iteration and feedback, privacy-preserving and open-standard mechanisms like the Privacy Sandbox can sustain a healthy, ad-supported web in a way that will render third-party cookies obsolete. Once these approaches have addressed the needs of users, publishers, and advertisers, and we have developed the tools to mitigate workarounds, we plan to phase out support for third-party cookies in Chrome. Our intention is to do this within two years." -- https://blog.chromium.org/2020/01/building-more-private-web-path-towards.html https://blog.chromium.org/2020/01/building-more-private-web-... (Disclosure: I work on ads at Google, speaking only for myself)
- thowaway0417 6y agoWhy do you prefer empowering Google even more to walled garden model? Walled gardens are good, at least in that there are several of them. This means the Web as seen by the average consumer is still somewhat decentralized.
- vbezhenar 6y agoI'm minority as well, as I think that targeted ads are important for the Internet. First of all, I think that ads in the Internet are important, it's a driving force. Without ads there will be no Internet with lots of "free" resources, everything valuable will be paywalled which is a problem for poor people and nuisance for the rest. That's already an issue for many information websites because of abundant adblock usage and those websites are paywalling their articles. If ad is not targeted, you'll get terrible click rate for niche ads. So your advertisement budget will cost more and some businesses just won't work, as you won't be able to attract enough customers for reasonable budget. Another issue is that advertisement budgets are paid by customers and inefficient advertisement lead to higher costs of the end product. It's basically like TV where ads cost a lot and small players just can't afford it. And that's because those ads can't be targeted. Because of mentioned issues, I think that targeted ads are needed for the Internet, they're making world a better place in the end. Google clearly tries to find a balance between privacy and ads targeting. And that's a good thing. May be FLOC is not perfect, although I'm not sure if it could be implemented in a significantly better way. But just disregarding targeted ads for me sounds like a wrong solution. What should be done is regulation of advertisement platforms which should be prohibited by law to track individual users and just use anonymized information, voluntarily provided by the user agent. And those who don't like FLOC idea, probably will be able to use browser extensions to modify its behaviour.
- salawat 6y ago>I'm minority as well, as I think that targeted ads are important for the Internet. Citation required. Not one Ad was required for the Internet to be useful. Hell, the WWW started as a bunch of hobbyists sharing info about what they liked. Google's killer product their search index. Not Ads. I don't need to pay anyone for me to host something aside from the domain name, and a connection to an ISP. I just have to want to host it. The rest of the world at some point decided the Net MUST be monetized. Cookies came soon after, then JS, then all the familiar trappings of the web as a monetized medium. Note; it becomes relevant for scaling or platforming to be able to be paid, but evven then, there are other ways to do that besides selling everyone else's privacy, comings and goings, etc. Once you add money to something, you lose anonymity and safety from surveillance. No one would care one iota about what went on in Cyberspce if there wasn't a buck to be made. I miss those days so horribly. Information shared and organized for it's own sake...
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"It seems like many consider the alternative to FLoC to be an anonymous web where content can be accessed without login." I consider the alternative to FLoC as no FLoC. I consider the alternative to 3rd party cookies as no cookies. I can read HN just fine without 3rd party cookies. Or FLoC. Developers, paid from advertising budgets, may be eager to comment and share their opinions on these matters but, let's be honest, they themselves are making such comments via a website (HN) that has no requirement for 3rd party cookies. What is good for the goose is good for the gander.^1 If cookies must be enabled to make a purchase or login, then I will enable cookies and accept a cookie, but only from that website and only for that purpose. However the requirement for cookies in these specific situations^2 has been taken as license for "modern" browser authors to make "cookies enabled" a default setting. This has been abused to no end. 1. I am commenting as an end user. I do not rely on the existence of online advertising to make a living. 2. It seems to me that the real problem here, the one which we should be trying to solve, is that web developers have no available solution for "shopping carts" and logins other than to use cookies. (Maybe the web was not designed for commerce.) Instead, Google is proposing a "solution" that makes business better for Google and its customers (advertisers, not end users), while making business more difficult for any company hoping to gain insight into end user browsing habits, except Google of course. "... an anonymous web where content can be accessed without login." It is always interesting how comenters make the jump from one company's software (e.g., Google Chrome) or website (e.g., Instagram) to "the web". The web is more than a handful of "tech" company monopolies that rely on advertising to exist. It is a medium, not a set of commercialised content. I starting using the web before Google or Facebook existed. Before user contributed content was usurped by "tech" companies to sell online advertising services. Today, I still get nearly 100% of content from the web without ever logging in to any website. Without Javascript, and without cookies. If one takes comments like the parent at face value, then this should be impossible.
- driverdan 6y agoYou can block 3rd party cookies today. In my experience it breaks less than 1% of sites and those that break can be replaced with other sites.
- foobiter 6y agoif you hate 3rd party cookies you hate floc too. It’s the same concept, except google controls this one.
- nulbyte 6y ago> It seems like many consider the alternative to FLoC to be an anonymous web where content can be accessed without login. How do you arrive at this conclusion? Authentication does not depend on third party cookies. Third party cookies are used to track visitors across multiple sites, independent of authentication to the first party site. I haven't seen suggestion elsewhere that third party cookies are about anything else.
- cratermoon 6y agoYou: Here's a cute picture of my cat, I'll post it on Instagram for my friends Instagram: cool! We're showing this to all your friends. BTW it costs us money to do this but don't worry, we don't charge you, we just show some ads to your friends. You: Hey, my kitten is really popular, a lot of people are liking it. Instagram: High five! You're popular. We ended up making a lot more money from selling ads than it cost us to show it! Thanks! You: wait, that was my cat picture, where's my cut? Instagram:
- freyir 6y agoYour “cut” is having a place to store, view, and share your cat photos online. The web only has two business models: users pay for a service or advertisers pay for a service. I’m all in favor of paying for services, but it turns out most people prefer ads to breaking out their wallet.
- foerbert 6y agoThis always gets said, and I don't exactly think it's untrue, but it carries this strong implication that the problem is that people are too cheap to pay. And I'm not sure that's entirely true. My own pet theory is that - payment method and model issues aside - the largest contributor is the uncomfortable questions it makes us ask ourselves. When you pay for something, you ask yourself if whatever you are buying is actually worth the price. And a lot (most?) of what people seem to do on the web these days is feed their dopamine as much novelty as they can, as quickly as possible. I don't know how much value people are expecting to get out of their browsing activities. Do they even think it's actually worth the time, if they stop and think about it? Asking them to pay for it is forcing them to confront this issue. No wonder nobody pays.
- cratermoon 6y agoThe social media services like us to think the users (people with the pictures of kittens) don't add any value individually. The let us believe that it's the network effect, plus their infrastructure, that is the value, and because those wouldn't exist without the service, that is what generates revenue. But of course individual users add value. Without people sharing their kitten pictures, there'd be no network, no content, worth selling ads around. For ad-supported social media, we're all just unpaid labor and we're told that labor has no value anyway. Of course, by selling that position, they've also convinced the end user that the service is not worth paying for. But when there's nothing the end user wants to pay for, and ad revenue drying up, social media services will have to pivot to make money elsewhere. The end result, not surprisingly, will result in a mixed model of subscription and ad revenue supporting content that the service has, in some way, paid for. Sound familiar? Of course, the end user will still not be paid for the labor contributed, but then the less the ad revenue depends on the user-generated "free" content, the closer the value of that labor tends to zero.
- roody15 6y agoAnonymous web makes sense. The very idea that we need an ad profile that follows us as we traverse the web is ridiculous. Contextual advertising works. Visit a popular website covering PC hardware .. and advertisers can pay to put ads to parts, chips, cases, etc. Visit a website that covers hiking trails and companies can purchase ads for camping gear, travel lodging, etc. The very notion that it should be normal for an ad profile to be built around everything I do on the web is frankly dystopian and depressing.
- jrm4 6y agoAnd even that's a second order thing. Even if Patreon (or hey, onlyfans) aren't the dominant model now, I'm fine with breaking nearly any invisible system of content payment in favor of visible ones just to see what happens.
- hakfoo 6y agoAt this point, I think it's become a "too big to fail" argument for the industry. We have several near-trillion-dollar companies that basically have no viable business model other than doubling down on targeted advertising. If third-party cookies get demonized or GDPR'd to death, they need to pivot to SOMETHING else that still fits into the same profiling paradigm. I suspect it's not about results or innovation anymore, it's about being a moat. Only a trillion-dollar company with huge scale and scope can possibly build and maintain "high quality" profiles, so it's a great way to spread FUD against any competing, potentially actually privacy-first, ad-tech upstarts. I'm sort of waiting for the "Emperor has no clothes" moment. We see the occasional "Brand stops advertising for 6 months and sales stay on trend" story, or the "our best conversions come from real content and relevant direct ads" story. We have the fact that ad spend grows and yet publishers starve, implying the middlemen are taking an ever-larger chunk of value out of the ecosystem in exchange for their services. It's gonna be ugly when the dots are joined.
- bopbeepboop 6y agoI believe ads work — but I’ve seen little evidence anything beyond contextual ads work. But yeah, show someone on a blog about new GPUs an ad to buy a GPU and there’s an uptick. Turns out some of those people do want to buy GPUs. Showing me an ad for GPUs on the YouTube page for cat videos because I visited that blog previously is weird. Like a friend going, “so looking at these cats reminds me — do you want my friend Dave’s GPU?”