7 ms·
The biggest news IMO is that there's only a single winner. There was a lot of pressure to make Commercial Crew a sole contact to Boeing, and it now appears th
by bryanlarsen 6y ago
The biggest news IMO is that there's only a single winner. There was a lot of pressure to make Commercial Crew a sole contact to Boeing, and it now appears that Boeing is going to deliver Starliner two years later than SpaceX delivered Crew Dragon. So going with two winners saved NASA's bacon. It's surprising to see them only choose a single winner here. Yes SpaceX may be considered a safe bet, but ten years ago it was Boeing who was considered the safe bet. Things change over years.
- kitsunesoba 6y agoIt's risky to select just a single winner, but I can't help but think this is the appropriate response to Boeing's pressure. It sends a clear message that the typical "old space" tactics will no longer be tolerated and that if these companies want to remain in the game, it will need to be by way of their competitive merit.
- runawaybottle 6y agoTo add to this point, I think we’re seeing a clear recognition that space travel and infrastructure is shifting out of the Defense sector and into the private sector.
- greesil 6y agoOnly because of Elon and team, and a huge brick of money that NASA gave them.
- CydeWeys 6y agoThose huge bricks of money aren't going anywhere. SpaceX (or anyone else) aren't flying missions for the government for free!
- briffle 6y agoWhich doesn't seem as large, when you calculate it out in number of shuttle launches you could do with that cash.
- kitsunesoba 6y agoOr compare it to how much has been spent on SLS, which has yet to net any return aside from keeping people employed (which probably could've been accomplished on a much smaller budget).
- dralley 6y agoYes, but it needs to be said that the "huge brick of money" was half of what NASA gave Boeing (which is itself just a tiny proportion of Boeing's profit). And look where we are.
- mlindner 6y agoNASA's budget hasn't increased though. So everything that's changed dramatically is because of knock-on effects of SpaceX's activities and the private funding it has.
- Robotbeat 6y agoYes, a big bet by NASA that has paid off beyond just about anyone’s imagination. SpaceX is a massive vindication of NASA and the commercial contracting approach. The US had been falling behind Russia and then China in launch capacity (even becoming reliant on Russian engines as well as Europe on commercial launch, but last year, SpaceX on Falcon 9 alone launched more mass to orbit than the rest of the world combined. Almost everything NASA builds is built by contractors. Private companies like Boeing or Lockheed usually get most of it. But just by taking a chance with SpaceX during commercial cargo, NASA saved them and brought American space launch capacity to a level that dominates the world. And Starship brings it to another entire level. To get a lunar Starship to the surface and back to orbit will require about half a dozen Starship launch, each about 100-150 tons IMLEO each. A single one of these missions is about the same launch capacity as all successful Apollo lunar surface missions combined. Which makes sense when you see lunar Starship side by side with the Apollo LM: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/mslpce/starship_hls_vs_apollo_lm_to_scale/ https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/mslpce/starsh... It finally feels like we’re where we ought to be in the 21st Century with respect to Spaceflight.
- sneak 6y agoI think for at least a generation or two, most of the defense sector is the private sector, no? Or did you mean something else? This will still be a NASA mission, with NASA astronauts with their standard US military ranks, et c.
- runawaybottle 6y agoDefense is not the private sector. It is a sanctified institution politically where we must always fund it, similar to social security and Medicare. It’s a blank check we write every year, no questions asked. Certain private sector industries wish to join this club. Green energy has the makings of it. Education is obviously one of them. You get the picture.
- perl4ever 6y agoI believe 40-50% of the defense budget is simply the salaries and benefits of the people who are in the military. People often talk as though all the money was spent on high tech weapons and vehicles, but if you're going to have people, they have to make a living. Even if they just all sat at desks.
- robertlagrant 6y agoAgreed. Having spent some time in the UK equivalent, what they do primarily is training, not hardware procurement. Although they do spend a tidy sum on hardware too, of course!
- perl4ever 6y agoMilitary personnel + operations and maintenance, not including procurement, is more like 65% of the US budget.
- Daho0n 6y agoSpaceX couldn't offer the prices they do without state aid. Their prices are held down by overpriced military contract launches. So much so that several space agencies ( EU, Russian, etc.) have said that SpaceX are not competing as a private company but as a state sponsored company. This is not the move from state to private launches but the merger of Defense contractor's and NASA's budgets. SpaceX is being used to prop up US launches against foreign competitors. That's not moving out of Defense but keeping it close to heart by throwing money at them.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoBoeing wasn't part of this competition. They didn't make the top three in the first selection round.
- skissane 6y agoBoeing's bid was eliminated in the first selection round because it failed to properly address NASA's stated requirements. Maybe that's the arrogance of thinking you don't need to offer what the customer is asking for, you know what's good for them better than they do? Maybe, Boeing forgot that their bid was addressed to NASA not Congress, they put stuff in there like launching on SLS which certain people in Congress would like, and thought that would be enough to overcome the fact they'd ignored some of NASA's stated requirements. A former senior NASA manager, Doug Loverro, is under criminal investigation, accused of illegally trying to help Boeing resubmit its bid to make it actually conform with the requirements.
- nexuist 6y agoIs it actually a criminal investigation? Surely this is a civil matter with no chance of jail time right?
- skissane 6y agoYes it is a criminal investigation: https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/14/21369377/nasa-doug-loverro-human-spaceflight-criminal-probe-boeing-wsj https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/14/21369377/nasa-doug-loverr... A lot of matters which might only be civil if they occurred between two private companies are criminal when the government is a party to the transaction. And that's true whether the wrong is being committed by a company or by a government official or by both.
- InTheArena 6y agoIn fact, Gerstenmaier was kicked out of NASA because he tried to slide inside information to Boeing to try and make their bid more competitive. Ironically enough, he now works for SpaceX.
- zlsa 6y agoThis is probably largely due to NASA's Congress-specified HLS budget not being enough to support two companies.
- aerophilic 6y agoI am also surprised, and somewhat heartened by this decision. They are basically saying they are committed to going to the moon... they aren’t going to “give it up”. However, they are implicitly saying it is not going to be a place they are going to spend a ton of cash. This is no longer a job shop, but instead a steps to making real progress.
- simonh 6y agoThe basic ability to get people to and from the ISS was a critical capability, so it was sensible to want redundant options as long as it was affordable. The moon is IMHO more of a nice to have. If this option doesn't pan out fine, try something else. I feel bad for the Dynetics lander though, I thought that was a really interesting design but relied on expendable launchers.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoI was also a big fan of Dynetics. It sounds like they primarily lost out due to cost -- SpaceX was the only proposal that could fit within the budget Congress gave NASA. https://twitter.com/wapodavenport/status/1383125840184115203 https://twitter.com/wapodavenport/status/1383125840184115203
- jandrese 6y agoI wonder if for the first time in history one of these space programs can deliver on the original budget? That would be a serious coup for SpaceX.
- vkou 6y agoFocusing on the budget is doing the wrong thing. 1. Ambitious space programs require solving unknown unknowns. You can't accurately budget for that. 2. Well, yes, you can budget for that by adding a large fudge factor to the cost of your program. 3. Which will mean that your program will not get funded. NASA generally does a good job of being in the ballpark of its budget for its ambitious goals. Which, ever since Apollo, have been its unmanned programs. The manned space shuttle, and the ISS, as well as all the hoop-a-la around getting people to the ISS are on the other hand not particularly ambitious, and are also a bottomless money pit (Ballpark cost of ISS was ~160 billion dollars. The ballpark cost of a rover mission to Mars is less than 3 billion dollars.)
- ncallaway 6y ago> hoop-a-la around getting people to the ISS are on the other hand not particularly ambitious, and are also a bottomless money pit While this was at one time true, I don't think it's fair to say anymore, given that the Commercial Crew contracts issued were fixed price contracts, and have been delivered by SpaceX on that fixed price contract.
- NotSammyHagar 6y agoAlthough there must be almost completely different training between the Boeing capsule and the spacex one, ultimately they had a good sync point to connection to the space station's "international format docking port". An arbitrary astronaut could ride in either, or at least without that much trouble. But LEO to the moon is going to be so different, and the landers were different. I'm sure there'd be no 'standard controller" so you could put lander from company A with transport to company B. I worry more about spaceX's ability to land starship on the moon. Not because they won't get it right eventually in texas, but the moon isn't smooth. I know they will have a plan to deal with that, but getting a few ton lander with 4 legs to not tip over and handle tilted land is vastly easier than a long and spindly and heavy starship - how will they handle that?
- skissane 6y ago> I worry more about spaceX's ability to land starship on the moon. I'm sure they will land it on the moon multiple times before they put any people on it. (And the other choices like National Team or Dynetics would have done the same.) What's amazing is that Apollo 11 landed on the Moon with humans on it the first time. And the Space Shuttle had astronauts on-board its maiden flight. People took risks with human spaceflight back then that they don't any more. Computers are so much more advanced now, you don't need astronauts to fly things. Even the Space Shuttle, technically could have been fully automated, but NASA had a culture of wanting to put a human in control. And a few deadly disasters have changed the attitude around risking astronauts’ lives to become more risk-averse.
- throwaway6734 6y ago>What's amazing is that Apollo 11 landed on the Moon with humans on it the first time. In no small part due to Neil Armstrong's ability to act under pressure.
- kiba 6y agoSomehow I am picturing only 1-3 tests for other competitors. SpaceX can do this because their launch platform is so cheap.
- 6y ago
- williesleg 6y agoSpaceX rocks! Elon is the man! He knows how to get things done. Boeing is so compromised, like General Electric and General Motors. Anything GE/Boeing/GM is destined for China.
- rtsil 6y agoThe reason is that NASA doesn't even have the budget to afford a single winner, and SpaceX agreed to update its payment schedule to make the contract work.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoThat normally isn't a show stopper. For example on commercial crew, Congress asked NASA to do Commercial Crew but didn't give them enough money to do it. Being forced to make an impossible choice, NASA awarded the contract, and the schedule shifted right until the money was available. I expect Congress expected them to do the same thing here, but then SpaceX forced the issue by coming in under the skimpy budget Congress gave. This forced NASA's hand, giving them almost no choice but to award the contract to SpaceX. Congress will be furious, both because they didn't award two contracts and because their golf course buddies didn't get the contract. But NASA played the hand that was dealt.
- rbanffy 6y agoThis is also a good way for NASA to tell Congress that, if they want business as usual, it’ll have to be budget as usual. It’s not nice the military get all the funding for their stupid toys.
- rst 6y agoWhich is... slightly baffling. Blue Origin doesn't have much of a track record actually getting stuff into orbit, but with Bezos's backing, you'd think the one thing they would have is flexibility on the payment schedule...
- nickik 6y agoBO might have that, but the other companies, LM and NG didn't. Even for Bezos its a tall order to spend billions for the LM and NG systems. I think he would rather spend that money on BO to develop whatever he wants to develop next. I don't think you want to be a commercial costumer of LM and NG, that doesn't sound fun.
- 6y ago
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoTen years ago Boeing was already riding a string of mismanaged and failed contracts. They can't accomplish anything dependably since the MD merger.
- elihu 6y agoIt sounds like NASA just didn't have the budget to fund two projects, and were only able to fund SpaceX's proposal because it was so much cheaper than the others.