3 ms·
"The same reason you can’t put software you want on a Xbox/PlayStation/Switch." Stop using this argument, its daft and convinces noone. Furstly, which law or
by ClumsyPilot 6y ago
"The same reason you can’t put software you want on a Xbox/PlayStation/Switch."
Stop using this argument, its daft and convinces noone.
Furstly, which law or court case actually establishes that those business practices are right and proper?
Secondly, which law or court case establishes that smartphones can be equated with game consoles? There is a huge body of law that governs mobile connectivity, spectrum, emergency services, etc. that has no bearing on a gaming device.
- ben_w 6y agoI believe the principal is that everything which is not banned is legal. This probably has a funky Latin translation, but I don’t know as I’m not a lawyer.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoJohn has gone to the pub, a random person gave him $5,000 and said he can keep half if he transfers the rest to Bob. Later it turned out it was drug money. The question in court will not be "is money laundering illegal" or "is taking money from random people illegal". The question in court will be "does this amount to money laundering, or is john just an idiot and it was not his responsibility to know". Similarly, here we are discussing not "is market manipulation illegal", but "does the activity carried out by Apple amount to market manipulation" Comparing Apple to game consoles is basically: "stop selling drugs" - "John does it too, and he is not in jail, so it's fine." That argument only works if John has been to court and a judge has ruled that he is innocent. That's case law - it established that previously, in similar circumstances, a court has rules that this was / wasn't a crime.
- dredmorbius 6y agoMens rea.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoStrict liability, duty of care and ignorantia juris non excusat.
- dredmorbius 6y agoRight. Mens rea ("guilty mind") itself is not a uniformly applied principle. But it's the name of the concept you were attempting to address above. See also actus reus ("guilty act"). And note that in tort liability (as opposed to criminal liability) other standards may apply. "Strict liabilty" is more typically applied in civil law, though there are (I learned responding here) some applications in criminal law as well. In the latter case it seems to be similar to my understanding of prima facie violation. That is, the fact of a thing is a violation of law, regardless of intent.
- throwaway2048 6y agoAntitrust law is a civil matter, not a criminal one.
- dredmorbius 6y agoFalse. https://www.justice.gov/atr/speech/criminal-enforcement-antitrust-laws-us-model https://www.justice.gov/atr/speech/criminal-enforcement-anti...
- kabdib 6y ago>>"The same reason you can’t put software you want on a Xbox/PlayStation/Switch." > Stop using this argument, its daft and convinces noone. Letting anyone put any software they wanted on an Xbox/Playstation/Switch would diminish the platform's value by eroding security and trust. For instance, compare online cheating ecosystems between those three platforms and the PC (where you can run any software you want). The PC is a much, much worse platform in terms of cheaters, scammers and account hijacks. I have no problem with people running whatever they want on the hardware they purchase, but extending that to "I should also be allowed to be trusted when I do this" does not logically follow. In other words, feel free to reflash your Xbox, but don't expect to be able to play games or connect to your Xbox Live account from that hardware after your jailbreak.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoThat is totally irrelevant. This about not allowing competing browsers as a blanket policy. If this was trully about security, Apple can do as many security audits as they want. They can even charge for them. They can require affidavit, security officers, insurance policy, indemnity, etc. But they dont because this is not about security, it is about controling the market
- bun_at_work 6y agoControlling what market? The browser market? A large part of Apple's brand, at this point, is security from snooping, personal privacy, etc etc. It makes sense to control the browser on the iPhone for privacy than it does to seek to eliminate browser competitors. Safari isn't a crucial part of their revenue, devices with the security promise are. Furthermore, the browser seems to be the key space where use privacy is violated from, via cookies and other tracking software. If Apple want's to say they have a pro-privacy device, controlling the browser makes sense for that goal. It just doesn't make business sense for Apple to be attempting to control the browser market. Maybe you mean they are controlling some other market through the browser, though.
- anfilt 6y ago