3 ms·
That's fair enough. I was meaning nitpickers about logical fallacies specifically, not stuff like grammar or minor details of an experiment. That said, is peer
by mike_hearn 6y ago
That's fair enough. I was meaning nitpickers about logical fallacies specifically, not stuff like grammar or minor details of an experiment.
That said, is peer review really the place to dunk on a study because the whole goal is pointless? The work is done by that point, it's too late. It's the granting bodies that should be getting peer reviewed in that regard, but one of the root causes of the malaise in research is that the granting bodies appear to be entirely blind buyers. They care about dispersing money, not what they get out of the spending. If they didn't spend the money they'd be fired, so that's understandable. The core problem IMHO is the huge level of state funding of research. The buck stops at politicians but they are in no position to evaluate the quality of academic studies.
- exmadscientist 6y agoI was actually thinking of grant applications when I wrote that. And it's not even politicians, it's grant committees too. For the usual reasons, they'd rather fund study #13 from a researcher than anything that is the slightest bit uncomfortable to them.