2 ms·
> This just isn’t true, it is only a contradiction if the type of housing remains constant, which it does in zero-development, extreme-construction-cost market
by vkou 6y ago
>
This just isn’t true, it is only a contradiction if the type of housing remains constant, which it does in zero-development, extreme-construction-cost markets like San Francisco where public policy forbids the modification of (almost) any housing to increase density.
If the housing supply rises, this puts downward pressure on home prices, which means they stop being a good investment.
Consider a hypothetical where no new housing was built for a decade, and existing housing is wildly overpriced. If your thesis is correct, then someone buying on the last day of the building moratorium is not making a good investment, because prices will either drop, or stagnate right after they bought.
- bluGill 6y agoOnly true if the house was over valued. Otherwise the house should more or less pace inflation, but you get to live there.
- vkou 6y agoThe house is obviously overvalued in dollars, compared to that same house to a world where construction was happening. Unless you mean to tell me that the cost of housing is the same regardless of whether or not construction is happening... (Which would be a truly odd claim.)
- bluGill 6y agoErr, yes, compared to a world where construction was happening.
- vkou 6y agoSo what you're saying is that housing can only be one of 'available to people', or 'a good investment'. The thing with good investments in that in a world of low interest rates, prices for them get inflated, as mountains of cash are trying to find some place to go.
- bluGill 6y agoNo, because a house as an investment is a hedge on inflation and a place to live rent free once it is paid for. As such the return on investment calculation is different than other investments.