8 ms·
> The list goes on. I'm happy that it's being suggested, I'm just worried how it took so long to get here. Because this is a Gish Gallop of weak individual rea
by kortilla 6y ago
> The list goes on. I'm happy that it's being suggested, I'm just worried how it took so long to get here.
Because this is a Gish Gallop of weak individual reasons batched together to make it seem like a stronger obvious argument when it’s not.
> How can Google own the entire ads market and still be allowed to compete in it?
They don’t. Amazon and Facebook both make a fortune from ads. You need to be more specific.
> How can Amazon be allowed to sell competing products in their own marketplace, when they own the actual marketplace?
Go to a store, this is what Walmart, Albertsons/Safeway, Costco, etc have been doing for longer than any of the FAANGs have existed.
> How is Apple allowed to disallow any other web browsers on their mobile devices? We already went through this with Microsoft in the past but suddenly it's different?
The same reason you can’t put software you want on a Xbox/PlayStation/Switch.
> Why is Google allowed to rank their own products in front of more general results?
Because it’s their algorithm to do with what they want. If they want to erode public trust by using it to advertise their products, that’s their choice. Other things they adjust the algorithm to do: filter malware, filter porn (by default), filter unreliable sites, etc. You’re going to have a really hard time defining what’s “fair” for a black box algorithm to do.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- echelon 6y ago> > How can Google own the entire ads market and still be allowed to compete in it? > They don’t. Amazon and Facebook both make a fortune from ads. Yes, but they own search ads and a large percentage of web ads (though the non-siloed web is becoming less and less relevant each year), and they do everything in their power to put people into their ad funnel. They control 50% of the mobile OS, 70%+ of the browser monoculture, and nearly 100% of search. They can order sites according to which ones use AdSense or AMP, neuter ad blocking (especially of AdSense), and collect behavior across the web even when website owners don't want it. They're fucking up an entire set of technologies to further their goals. That's not monopolistic. That's horrific. I don't think we even have a term to describe this yet, it's so bad. We're all getting Big Teched.
- darawk 6y ago> Yes, but they own search ads and a large percentage of web ads (though the non-siloed web is becoming less and less relevant each year), and they do everything in their power to put people into their ad funnel. You can call any company as a monopoly if you define its market narrowly enough. The hard question is making a good argument for your choice of market. Google is absolutely a monopoly in search advertising. But is search advertising the right market to consider? Google would argue the appropriate market is advertising as a whole, where they are clearly not a monopoly. The ultimate question at hand is whether and to what extent consumers are being harmed by anti-competitive practices. I think in Google's case that's a hard case to make. It might be a bit easier for e.g. Facebook or Amazon, though.
- warkdarrior 6y agoStarbucks has a monopoly on coffee at Starbucks locations.
- Spivak 6y agoWhich sounds like a crazy comparison but you’ve got people on HN saying that stores should be forced to carry products they don’t want to. It’s completely unfair that Starbucks is taking away consumer choice by not selling Dunkin’ Donuts coffee.
- echelon 6y agoApple has a monopoly on Starbucks in your car, in your home, in your place of work... They take their blood money.
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago"The same reason you can’t put software you want on a Xbox/PlayStation/Switch." Stop using this argument, its daft and convinces noone. Furstly, which law or court case actually establishes that those business practices are right and proper? Secondly, which law or court case establishes that smartphones can be equated with game consoles? There is a huge body of law that governs mobile connectivity, spectrum, emergency services, etc. that has no bearing on a gaming device.
- ben_w 6y agoI believe the principal is that everything which is not banned is legal. This probably has a funky Latin translation, but I don’t know as I’m not a lawyer.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoJohn has gone to the pub, a random person gave him $5,000 and said he can keep half if he transfers the rest to Bob. Later it turned out it was drug money. The question in court will not be "is money laundering illegal" or "is taking money from random people illegal". The question in court will be "does this amount to money laundering, or is john just an idiot and it was not his responsibility to know". Similarly, here we are discussing not "is market manipulation illegal", but "does the activity carried out by Apple amount to market manipulation" Comparing Apple to game consoles is basically: "stop selling drugs" - "John does it too, and he is not in jail, so it's fine." That argument only works if John has been to court and a judge has ruled that he is innocent. That's case law - it established that previously, in similar circumstances, a court has rules that this was / wasn't a crime.
- dredmorbius 6y agoMens rea.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoStrict liability, duty of care and ignorantia juris non excusat.
- ben_w 6y ago> You’re going to have a really hard time defining what’s “fair” for a black box algorithm to do. To which the two biggest counter-arguments are: 1. “So don’t allow black box algorithms” 2. “This is why the search engine company should be separate from the company which owns all the other products”
- kortilla 6y agoPeople use Google because the algorithm is a black box that is constantly updated to keep away black hat SEO crap. An open web page ranking algorithm is useless in an adversarial environment. There is no current signal that can’t be trivially gained that doesn’t effectively require mass user surveillance (to see “what’s really popular”). > 2. “This is why the search engine company should be separate from the company which owns all the other products” This doesn’t solve the problem. They can still alter top listings to push things for “preferred partners and truths”.
- neolog 6y ago> An open web page ranking algorithm is useless in an adversarial environment. Anybody with Search experience confirm or deny this claim?
- random314 6y agoI have experience, and this is trivially true. Search engines can only look at proxies for relevance , as General AI hasn't been achieved yet. Proxies can always be gamed.
- telmo 6y ago> black hat SEO crap Pretty redundant if you ask me: black hat, SEO and crap.
- sigg3 6y agoCrap is not redundant. It's more popular than ever! /s
- echelon 6y ago> > How is Apple allowed to disallow any other web browsers on their mobile devices? We already went through this with Microsoft in the past but suddenly it's different? > The same reason you can’t put software you want on a Xbox/PlayStation/Switch. The iPhone is a general purpose computer, not a gaming toy. You do finances, email, chat, dating, games, spreadsheets, GPS navigation, photos, video - your entire life, all one one device. For half of Americans, this is the only computer they own. For half of Americans, Apple controls what software you can use, and it extorts a 30% cut. That's mafia behavior. Gamers can choose between Xbox, PlayStation, Switch, PC, Steam, Epic, and dozens of other platforms. There's lots of choice, and this is just one industry with a very narrow impact on consumers' lives. Mobile computer (aka smartphone) users get to choose between Apple and Android for the entirety of everything they do, and both of these companies try to butt into everything. They even want to control banking and payments. The App Stores aren't given to us benevolently out of the good will of a loving Apple and Google. They're means of exerting control and extracting profit in a monopolistic fashion. They both need to die.
- ben_w 6y ago> You do finances, email, chat, dating, games, spreadsheets, GPS navigation > For half of Americans, Apple controls what software you can use, and it extorts a 30% cut. 30% (or even 15%) of $0 is $0. Apple gets nothing from me for my finance apps, my email client, my chat apps, my spreadsheet apps, or my GPS apps, because they are free. I can’t comment about dating apps as I’m not using any. Complaining that Apple charges for gaming, however, is weird given you choose to reject them as gaming devices.
- andiareso 6y agoThe argument was "general purpose computer" which would include games. It's not exclusively a gaming device
- Spooky23 6y agoIs the PlayStation store also evil?
- Cullinet 6y agothis paper is more specific https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3500919 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3500919 I first seriously discussed how Google is a systematic internaliser with my cofounder in 2003. The next year Google together with a consortium of major publishers abandoned and wrote off a $350MM initiative to enable trading in traditional and print media and the Advertising Age piece even reported specifics why they were disbanding which read close enough to what we began doing since 1996. The reasons involve a lot of micro market theory and since there's a involved corporate history that's about as much as I can say other than it looked very clear to us that Google merely found that the traditional media had managed to stitch up their markets in similar ways without any theoretical appreciation for their actions. definition : https://www.gbm.hsbc.com/financial-regulation/mifid/si https://www.gbm.hsbc.com/financial-regulation/mifid/si
- bogidon 6y ago> If they want to erode public trust by using it to advertise their products, that’s their choice Companies are people too!
- BugWatch 6y agoIn that case, some "people" should be dismembered and/killed.
- foobar33333 6y ago>The same reason you can’t put software you want on a Xbox/PlayStation/Switch. What reason is this? As far as I'm concerned you should be allowed to install whatever you want on game consoles as well.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Terretta 6y agoAs the boundaries of hardware, firmware, and “software defined” blur, I disagree with forcing manufacturers to implement and enable some arbitrary magical line between proprietary hardware and open software. The whole thing can be IP; the whole thing can be a product. I’m just fine with saying this thing is an appliance that does what it does, including only accepting paired cartridges (gate-kept apps). Consumers buy toasters instead of open grills for valid reasons, same for mobile devices. Forcing the toaster maker to support open grilling is over-regulation, the opposite of letting markets decide. If consumers don’t want a no muss no fuss appliance, they can buy something else.
- timoth3y 6y ago> Go to a store, this is what Walmart, Albertsons/Safeway, Costco, etc have been doing for longer than any of the FAANGs have existed. This one is substantively different. Amazon claims it is a market and not a store, and is therefore not legally responsible for things like the quality of products sold there or how they are represented. They claim that both buyers and sellers are their customers, unlike an actual store where only the buyers are the customers. So when Amazon decides to set up its own logistics company, no problem. When they use private market data to place their own products into their market, that's a different matter.
- wahern 6y ago> Amazon claims it is a market and not a store, and is therefore not legally responsible for things like the quality of products sold there or how they are represented. Amazon claims this, but at least in California they still face product liability: https://www.natlawreview.com/article/california-court-appeal-finds-amazon-not-shielded-liability-defective-product-sold https://www.natlawreview.com/article/california-court-appeal... While on its face the outcome doesn't seem surprising to me, this may nonetheless turn out to be a very important national precedent as California was, IIRC, the first jurisdiction to both clearly establish strict product liability for manufacturers and also extend that liability to intermediate sellers in the distribution chain.
- timoth3y 6y agoI agree. I don't think Amazon can continue this kind of legal equivocation much longer. The claim to be "a neutral market" when questions of consumer protections arise and "just one web store among many" when questions of improper use of their market ownership arise. The California decision makes a lot of sense. Looking at their business model with their ownership of the customer relationships, control of the payment methods, and the co-mingling of inventory, it's hard to claim that Amazon is just matching buyers and sellers. I'm not really in the "break-up big tech" camp. We already have the laws needed to make companies play fair, we just need to enforce them. That said, the whole Amazon Basics model is kind of questionable. I could see that being split off and forced to operate without access to private market data or preferential placement in the marketplace.
- _the_inflator 6y agoI side with you. Ben Evans shares a lot of good arguments here: https://www.ben-evans.com/benedictevans/2019/12/amazons-market-share19 https://www.ben-evans.com/benedictevans/2019/12/amazons-mark... When people say they got a solution to “the problem” for me this sounds every time like they not even started to understand anything they are talking about. FAANG is a sui generics case. And looking at Amazon’s service, I believe they do a lot of things right that others do not. And that’s part of “the problem”.
- twiddlebits 6y agoGoogle owns 97% of the mobile search ads market. I think he probably meant search ads in general.