8 ms·
Sid Meier: More Than Just Civilization
- waynesonfire 6y agocheck out "war in the east 2" just came out, i've been having fun learning the mechanics.
- ojbyrne 6y agoI’m curious what this has to do with Sid Meier.
- waynesonfire 6y agoyou must be new here
- op03 6y ago> what happens next? I want to see civ games where social media dynamics enter the picture. Echo chambers, polarisation, pandering, where different unit types cops, military, city workers, journos, scientists etc start chasing Likes and Followers causing all kinds of side effects. And then the player is given various tools to keep things from collapsing...
- 29athrowaway 6y agoI guess he could make a dedicated game titled Internet Ad Tycoon.
- mhh__ 6y agoThat sounds like a Democracy game rather than Civ
- yxhuvud 6y agoYes, or kinda like VictoriaII.
- Iv 6y agoThe plan I have had in my drawers for about 3 years now is that I want to make a civilization game but where the focus is on keeping your own civ together. Civilizations fell more often because of internal dissensions than because of enemy attacks. Tech and actions would all be about finding things that make two cultures a bit closer, two groups work together.
- op03 6y agoGood idea really. Did you work out what type of actions? Made me think of Gregory Batesons schismogenesis work. According to his theory the divisions are sort of almost a given within groups, but they don't lead to schism/conflict/collapse when society produces Rituals. Would be really cool to see games exploring or capable of producing rituals as a route...no idea how that would work...
- Iv 6y agoActually I have a list of actions but I am not sure which one should be kind of automated and which one should be player controlled. At first, I was mostly interested in the spread of ideas and behaviors. The Player would be in the implicit role of a guiding deity, able to invest in new ideas/behaviors and in reordering priority of one tribe. But then, there is a big list of actions that could also be in the player's control: - Create roads/trades to facilitate exchanges of goods, with the indirect goal of also exchanging ideas - Create trade nexus, for the same goal, and drain a whole area into a common culutural pool - Promote one or several languages, to please/facilitate collaboration within tribes - Promote religions - Have sports events - Have culturual events - Have several type of "diplomats" (priests, doctors, clerks, ambassadors, police officers) with selectabletraits: language, religion, ideas. - Decide to militarize some territories or not with selected troops. - Create research facilities One idea behind research is that as you go, you discover ideas that, once spread, can help your entity grow without breaking up and with less efficiency loss. There would be a lot of overlap with the Civ tech tree but with less emphasis on military tech. My hope is that if done right, this should give the impression to the player that wars are just a huge waste of time and resources.
- bob1029 6y agoPerhaps we should stop adding new mechanics to civilization, and go back to refine a few really good ones. Civ6 with all of the DLC turned on is absolutely oppressive with the number of choices you have to make beyond turn 100. It turns off all but the most dedicated players. Most of my friends went back to Civ5. If you really don't want to be bothered with all the decision making, you can always play Venice. Makes it easy to bring in more outsiders. In my experience, the most fun I have ever had in civilization is struggling with simple barbarian mechanics in early game while all of my equally-casual friends encounter the same difficulties. The player who got the island by themselves usually wins the science victory, but I don't mind the win conditions. It's more about the journey.
- toast0 6y agoI would love for a Civilization (or Beyond Earth) to get simultaneous mode multiplayer that works better. It's too easy to be fiddling around with something and accidentally delay the turn, or somehow trigger a resync, and I lack the patience to play sequential turns with humans.
- dave_sullivan 6y agoI've been playing with making an economy simulator. People in the economy get jobs, rent apartments, have free time, can start businesses, etc. Prices change based on supply and demand. Cool. But it's not clear to me what the player should be doing because buildings are placed by the NPCs and then they make their own decisions according to self interest. What is the player doing except watching? Setting laws maybe, but it doesn't feel very fun to play yet.
- Jarwain 6y agoMy first thoughts are: Add some sort of story or goals. Encourage business starting, innovation trying to get more futuristic or get to space or something? But to Achieve these goals, the player has to pass the right laws, manage their economy, ensure sufficient funding & taxes, etc. The core game loop being passing laws and seeing how it impacts behavior, then repeat to achieve a goal Could be an interesting colony sim or something
- dave_sullivan 6y agoThank you, perhaps setting laws or policies and then seeing what happens isn't a bad game loop. Goals could work too. I will hack on it a bit today and see what comes out :)
- swilliamsio 6y agoA game of study for comparison might be Victoria 2. It's a grand strategy set in the Victorian period and has a decent economic simulator that the player can influence in a fair few different ways. A few different ways a player can effect their nation's economy include: unlocking technologies, conquering territory for resources, expanding a nations sphere of influence for resources and markets, electing parties with different economic policies (planned economy vs laissez faire), playing with taxes/tariffs, encouraging certain industries, etc. The economic simulation isn't super deep, but it is deep enough to be engaging and fulfilling to a player who likes these sorts of spreadsheet simulator games.
- 6y ago
- roschdal 6y agohttps://github.com/freeciv/freeciv-web https://github.com/freeciv/freeciv-web
- blux 6y agoSid Meier's Memoir! describes all of this and more, I can recommend it if you liked this article. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/50489373-sid-meier-s-memoir https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/50489373-sid-meier-s-mem...
- martey 6y agoThe article is a review of the memoir - not only is it linked in the first paragraph, but the article even states near its end that "there's of course a lot more than the above anecdotes in the book."
- ricardo81 6y agoPirates! was superb. I've never visited the Caribbean yet, but I'll be hearing the sound effects from this game when I do. If only those war wounds didn't stop you playing... and the crew wanting to mutiny or divide the plunder. It truly was the golden era of games, for me, as a kid. Remember thinking how the incremental improvements in hardware would make games more life like, and when that day would come. Wonder if kids now think the same?
- wodenokoto 6y agoI loved that game as a kid. Is there a spiritual sequel?
- ricardo81 6y agoThere's a Pirates! Gold version I bought a few years back. Same game, graphics/sounds revamped
- shmerl 6y agoThere is also Sid Meier’s Pirates! which is a newer redesign from 2004. https://www.gog.com/game/sid_meiers_pirates https://www.gog.com/game/sid_meiers_pirates
- ekianjo 6y agoKing of Seas is kind of like Pirates with some overarching story on top of it.
- frequent 6y agoSame here. My brothers and me could name all the Caribbean islands, we tried to sail to Europe from Bermuda and I remember my Dad sinking a half our galleons in the span of minutes we let him play on our Commodore64. Thanks for the memories :)
- stefs 6y agoi played it as a kid with several lack of understanding in general but also of the english language. i: "papa, was heisst 'cutthroat'" (dad, what does 'cutthroat' mean?) dad: "das heisst halsabschneider" (it's cutthroat) i: "und 'swashbuckler'" (and swashbuckler?) dad: "???" first time in my life that my father wasn't able to answer a question.
- optimalsolver 6y ago>More Than Just Civilization Well yeah, there's Alpha Centauri, too.
- sbacic 6y agoI'm surprised to see Alpha Centauri mentioned only once. It was a real gem and truly ahead of its time with some of its mechanics. The storytelling (something Civilization never really bothered with) was also something special.
- mercer 6y agoI played Civ 2 for many hours, but after Alpha Centauri I could never get back to the Civ series. Been meaning to check it out again, but my experience with Civ 3 and 4 just wasn't as enjoyable after having played AC.
- chongli 6y agoI agree. SMAC is the reason I’m doing a philosophy minor in university. The game is so incredibly interesting and varied. There’s no other game that lets you experiment with so many different utopian or dystopian philosophies and witness your choices interacting with other ideological societies.
- iso1631 6y agoI remember playing the Americans in Civ 3, all was going well, I was nice and peacful, but then got to the later stage and oil appeared. I had a fairly large empire, but no oil. Without oil a lot of the later units aren't available, so invasion it was. So realistic.
- ValentineC 6y ago> The storytelling (something Civilization never really bothered with) was also something special. The quotes in the SMAC tech tree were some marvellous pieces of original work as well. Civilization, keeping with its theme, had to use quotes from history.
- 6y ago
- steamboiler 6y agoTangential, but here goes. I enjoy miniature wargaming. Sid Meier's 'Gettysburg' is one of my all-time favourite computer wargames. Thanks for creating it!
- Marazan 6y agoYes, truly one of the best computer wargame ever made. So many very, very clever decisions went into its design.
- Waterluvian 6y agoThis post says Sid Meier didn't take part in Magic: The Gathering (1997) but Wikipedia lists him as the game designer. Anyone know the answer? Also that game was incredible and it's shocking they haven't made anything like it since. Card game RPGs are very hot.
- darrenoc 6y agoI'm not sure if he designed the game as such, but it's widely reported that it was Sids last project before his departure from Microprose. It's still a cult classic among MTG fans for the novel RPG aspects.
- ValentineC 6y ago> This post says Sid Meier didn't take part in Magic: The Gathering (1997) but Wikipedia lists him as the game designer. That particular claim seems to require a citation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic:_The_Gathering_(1997_video_game)#Development https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic:_The_Gathering_(1997_vid... Looks like this was the revision that added it: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Magic:_The_Gathering_(1997_video_game)&diff=140460907&oldid=140385194 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Magic:_The_Gather...
- ekianjo 6y agoAccording to the book, at the time he was in between Microprose and the new company they were establishing and working like a contractor to help the team at Microprose to finish Magic the Gathering - so while he has had a role in directing the project, he appeared to be not deeply interested in it because it was a licensed game, and it seems he was mainly making sure it ships in a reasonable state.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoSid Meier's Colonization , without knowing it, was in all likelyhood the first iteration of a Factorio-like game
- ekianjo 6y agoDespite the name, it was not created by Sid Meier, as pointed out in the article.
- the_lonely_road 6y agoSo many hours of my life gone trying to build the 50 city states of the union before declaring independence in Colonization. Such an amazingly fun game, though it encouraged slaughtering the natives so not likely to get much good press in the modern era.
- ekianjo 6y agoIf you played as the French, you actually benefited from working with the natives (additional bonuses) if I remember correctly, which was to mimic the French approach in the New World (also well depicted in the Last of the Mohicans).
- skocznymroczny 6y agoFrench had a lower threat level generation amongst natives (you can encroach into their territories more without generating hostilities). But as far as I remember, when you declared independence, the natives always ally themselves with the royal forces, so it makes sense to get rid of them before (especially if you've been supplying them with horses and muskets).
- ekianjo 6y ago> the natives always ally themselves with the royal forces Did they? I don't remember that part in details anymore (even though I played Colonization again just 4-5 years ago).
- the_lonely_road 6y agoI always played as the Spanish (who gain twice the gold from slaughtering a native village) because in order to fit 50 colonies on the map of the US you had to take up all of the land, and most of it was already occupied by native villages. It was impossible to defend most of the inner villages so the only available option was removal, hence picking the Spanish to gain double gold since I was clearing the land anyway. I never was able to get all 50 cities built in time and still try from time to time.
- a_d 6y agoOne of my favorite games of all time is Railroad Tycoon 2: Platinum Edition. While Sid Meier didn’t directly make it, but he spawned the franchise with RRT-1. I found a pirated version selling on the street-side in the capital city of India. (Later on, when I had a job, I did buy a proper copy - which was much harder to get than the pirated copy). Many sid Meier games have a remarkable sense of “time and place” - and Railroad Tycoon (imho) takes it to the next level. You really feel you are in early 1818, on the east coast of USA, getting your “little startup” off the ground. Even the blues and bluegrass music is designed to transport you there. The game captures a sense of adventure - that almost isn’t supposed to be the case in a rail road sim - but all the gameplay mechanics aside, this game captures an amazing sense of adventure ... and education. You learn a lot after exploring the continents, tackling terrains of continents, learning about cities, gaining a sense of scale and the thrill of making ideas come to life... it’s really cool how a game (a piece of software) can capture all this! Upon repeat playing, I have come to admire the graphic design, sound design and interaction design (“the UI”) so much more. There are small but significant - even beautiful, decisions made that make the game fun to play and good to look at eg Train cars will change appearance through different eras.. A part of HN is entrepreneurship driven - I think those folks will also get an immense kick out of beating JP Morgan and Cornelius Vanderbilt. The campaign is the thing to play — travel the globe and connect places! Make economy happen. Game also allows simple surprises like being able to buy businesses outright - that you have merely connected (and made to prosper) - shows you clearly how far monopoly can go :). I guess today it will be called a “full stack” railroad company. I have dismissed my own love of the game to - “I am just nostalgic” — but I played it again recently, and I have happy to report that it remains as engaging as ever! It’s available here: https://www.gog.com/game/railroad_tycoon_2 https://www.gog.com/game/railroad_tycoon_2 You can play on macOS using parallels. A bunch of videos come up on Google and they can quickly give a glimpse of the gameplay - although I will suggest diving it without the trailer (https://www.google.com/search?q=railroad+tycoon+2 https://www.google.com/search?q=railroad+tycoon+2) The game is classified as a business sim - its not. It’s a railroad sim - the amount of details (eg every engine has a real world counter part) about railroads makes it a railroad game and not a business game...
- bernardand 6y agoMaybe the players job can be to disrupt the economy. A game of sabotage.
- pvsukale3 6y agoI really like Sid Meir's Railroad Tycoon. I have tons of memories in summer fighting with my brother over computer time to play this game. I used to play a pirated copy back in highschool (Did not have money to buy the game, certainly didn't have a credit/debit card to do online transaction, downloaded it in an Internet cafe and brought it back on pendrive to play on home PC). Recently I remembered that I used to play this game a lot. Now that I have a job and can pay for stuff online I bought a copy for myself on steam.
- iso1631 6y agoI remember to play it on my Dad's laptop on the weekend I had to type 5-1-2. Railroad tycoon supported CGA graphics and no mouse was needed -- Civilisation had to wait until we had a colour 286 at home. In my mind, nothing really has come close to replacing the original RT - not RT2 or later, not A-Train, not TTD
- hasmanean 6y agoYes, even though RT2 had better graphics, it didn’t capture the simplistic feel of the original.