3 ms·
"Would you be willing to entertain that maybe they died because most people found those platforms to be simply weaker product offerings?" No. I mean hahahahah
by Brian_K_White 6y ago
"Would you be willing to entertain that maybe they died because most people found those platforms to be simply weaker product offerings?"
No.
I mean hahahahahah HELL NO not even close.
WebOS was great.
The only thing that made Android win was the brute force of Google, and the fact that Android was open source and WebOS was not (somehow, despite being Linux), and mismanagement by Palm.
"Weaker product offerings" isn't really an applicable idea for new entire ecosystems. He who can put up the most cash and marketing and special deals can create a new ecosystem from scratch that is by definition and necessity far weaker than others that have already existed for years, and still win by plain force.
When the iPhone came out, it had no 3rd party apps at all, while Palm and Windows devices existed for years. Particularly PalmOS had a massive rich diverse mature ecosystem of 3rd party apps.
I had a full screen, color, touch, grid icon home screen of 3rd party apps, internet connected, smartphone... In 2000, SEVEN YEARS before the first iPhone came out. I had a web browser, an ssh client, even a vnc client, Audible.com audio book player app, .. And every random app for every big and little purpose I coukdbthink of, from db apps to odd little things like a netmask calculator and resistor color code decoder, irc client, book reader, integrated contacts db phone dialer... Just like today, except better, no app store, and so no app store saying I can't have an app I want but Google or Apple doesn't. All this in 2000. 7 years before the "revolutionary" iPhone.
And even after the iPhone came out, not only were it's offerings weaker, they didn't exist at all. No 3rd party apps allowed at first.
Apple won because they are Apple. The phone hardware was a technical and design marvel, and Apple could afford to create a whole new world from scratch to displace an existing mature rich one thanks to plain money and size from years of iPod sales.
Google didn't have a stunning new device that blew away anything that came before, but they did have the money and the ability to make deals with carriers, and the open source angle. (I don't mean that consumers cared about that, I mean that letting everyone and their dog make a phone for free was an effective way to match Apple's deep with a Google wide.)
Android frankly sucked balls compared to WebOS for quite a while, both the os itself and the "offerings". But, Google. Palm. Come on.
I would agree that in the contest between Windows phone and either Android or IOS, MS had the size and resources to compete, and failed because they failed, not because there was no possible contest once someone that big decides to get in your game.
- kristopolous 6y agoClearly you're not like most people. Until people can really understand what I said above, and clearly they still can't, this kind of stuff will always happen The biggest players in the industry released failed handheld platforms for 20 years before Android. That theory does not explain the failure of all the other prior attempts by other monopolies
- zentiggr 6y agoHad Palm's management not had a series of stroke-like horrible decisions, I can imagine a present where the PalmOS 5.0 clusterfuck and just-barely-good-enough Treos gave way to WebOS devices that could have recovered the company, and the iPhone would have had to compete against _that_ potentially much more solid platform. All these years later, I still wish I could have sat in on those meetings and told Palm management just how badly they were screwing themselves.
- rchaud 6y agoI bought the HP Touchpad w/ WebOS. It was laughably bad. Maybe PalmOS had apps, but WebOS came with pretty much nothing, meaning that for entertainment you went to the web browser. And that was very slow and laggy. You could only load one tab at a time. A few months later, an unofficial Android ROM was created, and it was a huge upgrade, even though it was only Android 2.2.