7 ms·
About half is used for jewelry because gold is shiny pebbles. About 10% is used for electronics. Mining Bitcoin consumes 5X as much energy as gold, btw, per un
by arcticbull 6y ago
About half is used for jewelry because gold is shiny pebbles. About 10% is used for electronics.
Mining Bitcoin consumes 5X as much energy as gold, btw, per unit value extracted. It also requires mining gold to produce the circuit boards used for mining Bitcoin - given the popularity of the ENIG immersion gold plating process for PCB contacts.
The secondary issue is that of course each Bitcoin transaction generates 100g of e-waste which cannot be recycled and just gets buried. E-waste has a few grams of metals, but is mostly plastic and FR4 (epoxy filled fiberglass). Plastic and FR4 cannot be recycled. What little of the e-waste can be recycled is shipped to third-world countries where poor people dig through piles of scrap and dunk it in toxic chemicals.
The only meaningful way to move forward is to reduce consumption, especially consumption which achieves nothing, like literally wiring up a power plant to compute hashes of random data instead of attaching it to the grid to do useful things.
What a disaster.
- CTDOCodebases 6y agoThe miners don’t compute hashes of random data. They confirm transactions. If you don’t think that a technology that allows you to store value in a tamper free digital ledger is useful it’s hard to argue the usefulness of PoW crypto currencies to begin with.
- tsss 6y agoIt does so with the same efficiency as a Rube Goldberg machine moves a marble from one place to another.
- CTDOCodebases 6y agoEfficient or secure. Take your pick.
- salawat 6y agoI"ll hire a few guys with guns, plus auditors. Their ability to maintain no sense of humor beats out your wonky crypto scheme in both regards. Your issue is you don't like the rules that come with the auditors. Those rules have a purpose, and that purpose is tied with sovereign diplomatic interrelation of civic bodies the world over. Many of whom are expressing great concern over the very thing PoW hastens. So no, it isn't either or. It's stop jeopardizing the planet in the long term so you can do whatever you're doing now. I don't care that you're doing it, and we can talk civily about the warts of the financial system so it can be tuned to meet your use case better and cone to a compromise; but PoW has the worst set of dysfunctional societal incentives I've seen in my life.
- gruez 6y ago>I"ll hire a few guys with guns A few guys with guns can be beaten by several other guys with guns. >plus auditors https://www.wsj.com/articles/wirecard-scandal-puts-spotlight-on-auditor-ernst-young-11593286933 https://www.wsj.com/articles/wirecard-scandal-puts-spotlight...
- arcticbull 6y agoHow's that Tether transparency report looking :) ahh, here it is. [1] [1] https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2021.02.17_-_settlement_agreement_-_execution_version.b-t_signed-c2_oag_signed.pdf https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2021.02.17_-_settlemen...
- UncleMeat 6y agoWhat if we had 1000x the power being used to confirm transactions? 1,000,000x the power? At some point we aren't achieving anything. The is made worse by the fact that there are alternatives to produce trustworthy ledgers that don't involve destroying the planet.
- Siira 6y agoYes, alternatives that work for rich, powerful people.
- knorthfield 6y agoThese people buying power stations aren't rich? One of the issues with crypto currency is that we're replacing one elite with another. As John Oliver says Cryptocurrency is everything you don't understand about finance combined with everything you don't understand about computers. That new, even eliter, elite is probably no more moral or ethical than the old. It's not like cryptocurrency is more accessible. Maybe it will become so but I still have to fork out a lot of money to buy Bitcoin. It's just the fees get paid to different people. Not entirely sure how it's better. It is different though, I'll give you that.
- jessaustin 6y agoBitcoin is like any other infinitely divisible asset. You can buy as much or as little as you want.
- berdario 6y agoThe nonce used as input of the mining hash function IS random (or rather, arbitrary). Comments like the above are a sad demonstration of the fact that, while Bitcoin was originally an interesting technical project... Discussion of it has now been completely taken over by shills that try to dismiss/refute/hide all of the problems with Bitcoin (or the cryptoasset du jour) to safeguard their bet
- Siira 6y agoYou’re just deflecting. Your argument is as invalid as “mutations are random so evolution is false.” Randomness in an algorithm does not mean the algorithm is non-converging.
- berdario 6y agoI never said anything about converging or not. My GP's post simply points out that having repeated computations with arbitrary input is wasteful. "Your argument is as invalid as..." ROTFL Wake me up when Bitcoin moves to a PoS consensus (Btw, I recommend whoever is reading to also steer clear of PoS coins... If you want to invest, look elsewhere)
- throwaway271818 6y agoWhere did you get the 100g of e-waste figure from btw? Is that, roughly speaking, the e-waste mass of storage/txn * total number of nodes?
- arcticbull 6y agoDigiconomist [1]. I should have linked it up top, my bad. Looks like they, in turn used this reference [2]. [1] https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/ https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/ [2] https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(19)30087-X https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(19)30087-X
- throwaway271818 6y agoAh, but they’re calculating e-waste in the form of specialized mining hardware (ASIC) that, at present, goes obsolete every few years. The e-waste generated this way is not an intrinsic cost of handling a transaction, since the hardware could hypothetically be reused or recycled. It seems unwise to think of it as an irreducible cost per txn, rather than a dynamic figure that would likely improve over time (especially if the carbon externality were appropriately taxed)
- ta988 6y agoBut is it recycled? From what I understand it cannot be reused as a device, it has to be reprocessed to extract metals and such. So the value is pretty low and losses are high.
- celticninja 6y agoThis is a better index and not run by someone with an axe to grind https://cbeci.org/ https://cbeci.org/
- arcticbull 6y agoThe number you link is 43% higher.
- roenxi 6y agoThere is a really easy solution for this disaster - a trusted party could run a big relational database that was basically a non-inflating currency and really cheap to run. Except that isn't going to work, because governments are untrustworthy and as history shows will sooner rather than later debase their currency. All people are looking for here is a safe way to store value over time. If governments would let people keep reliable records without bringing in the inflation tax or changing the rules, things like gold and bitcoin wouldn't be anywhere near as interesting. But they are interesting, because it is normally policy to block anyone who tries to store (small-time) wealth for more than a couple of years.
- malka 6y ago"a trusted party" does not exist at scale.
- o-__-o 6y agoIncluding with Bitcoin, since 51% ownership of hash rate is simply a function of who has the most pooled resources (read: money)
- webinvest 6y agoOne such trusted party does exist. It’s a non-profit and it’s called the Stellar Development Foundation. It’s cryptocurrency, the Stellar Lumens (XLM) is trusted well enough to be in the top 15 cryptocurrencies by marketcap. It has years of history to look back at. It doesn’t have a inflation rate (0% inflation rate now + occasional coin-burns). It uses orders of magnitude less electricity than bitcoin because it uses distributed databases instead of ASICS, transactions are sent and received in a few seconds (near-instant), and transaction fees are less than 1 cent (just high enough to disincentivized spamming the network). Compared to Bitcoin’s $250 tx fee and Ethereum’s $30 tx fee, XLM’s tx fees are very cheap. Finally you can buy XLM on most exchanges since it’s been around so long.
- minikites 6y agoIs this a press release?
- CTDOCodebases 6y agoOnce the gold is extracted how much energy is spent to transport it, turn it into jewellery and store/protect it throughout its lifetime?
- AustinDev 6y agoGold mining btc mining isn’t the best comparison. For your 5X number. You’ve still got to ship and store the gold which undoubtedly has additional environmental costs.