The approval of a patent registration request should work like this: The issuer provides a public description of the problem the patent solves and a secret des

The approval of a patent registration request should work like this: The issuer provides a public description of the problem the patent solves and a secret description of the solution. They pay $10k in advance to request a patent registration. The patent institution then publishes the public problem description. External challengers can submit additional solutions for $100. After some time (e.g. a month) submission closes and independent judges need to identify the solution proposed by the patent issuer out of all submitted solutions. If they succeed, the patent will be registered. Otherwise, the submitter of the identified solution gets a split of the patent registration fee (e.g. $2k) and registration is denied. The institution manages hundreds of possible judges, only a few are selected randomly by a trusted computer. If a selected judge correctly identifies the solution of the patent, they will get a bonus (more than challengers would get, e.g. $3k). Non-selected judges can submit challenging solutions. This should be robust against bribery and prevent low effort bullshit patents!? If a company wants to bribe judges, they need to identify the selected judges, otherwise they help not-selected judges to submit challenging solutions. This can be made very hard. Also, the solution of the patent should solve a hard problem (i.e. a problem that is hard to find solutions for). Otherwise, challengers can easily come up with solutions of equivalent quality. If the problem is "A mechanism to visually indicate progress", it should not be too hard to come up with the progress bar.