3 ms·
The whole debate is about whether you believe in transcendence and what you consider the mind to be. Not transcendence in the Physics/Metaphysics sense but rat
by ThomPete 15y ago
The whole debate is about whether you believe in transcendence and what you consider the mind to be.
Not transcendence in the Physics/Metaphysics sense but rather in the (at least to our knowledge) fact that dumb matter transcended into aware matter at one point.
I.e. life happened through transcendence from "dumb" matter into aware matter. Pattern recognizing feedback loops with memory that can reflect on our own existence.
I do not have the knowledge to determine the feasibility of the various methods but I do believe that the mind isn't a thing as such but rather a system that simulate a reality, the reality that we experience from our vantage point.
So to me the question is not as much whether we can transcend from one physical form to another but rather how we will connect with more and more external computation that again will mold our internal computation maybe even take over some parts. At least the IO can be replaced (eyes, ears etc.)
But if that can be replaced then what's to stop other areas? Nothing dictates that as far as we know right now.
Somehow the argument reminds me of the Searles (misguided) Chinese Room argument.
The fact is that we don't know whether it's possible. So why not just let those who think it is, work on a solution.