4 ms·
According to this survey of economists, the consensus seems to be "rent control is bad". https://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/rent-control/ https://www.igmchicago
by gruez 6y ago
According to this survey of economists, the consensus seems to be "rent control is bad". https://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/rent-control/ https://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/rent-control/
- stuaxo 6y agoAm I cynical to assume "igmchicago" follows the Chicago school of economics and thus to assume a certain take on things ?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Ericson2314 6y agoMaybe read https://jwmason.org/slackwire/considerations-on-rent-control/ https://jwmason.org/slackwire/considerations-on-rent-control... a bit, basically history is repeating itself with the economic consensus on the minimum wage. Also see this comment https://jwmason.org/slackwire/considerations-on-rent-control/#comment-13300 https://jwmason.org/slackwire/considerations-on-rent-control... and the author's response. One can argue that it's less that the theory is "wrong" but that that the theory doesn't match reality: the housing and employment markets are deeply flawed in hard-to-fix ways. Maybe we want to fix these markets, but if we want to intervene at that scale, we might as well be open to other non-market strategies at managing those resources too. In the mean time, rent control is "easy" with empirically demonstrated benefits.
- JamesBarney 6y agoAll the papers jw mason quotes say the theory matches reality. Basically that rent controls strong enough to make a difference reduce housing quantity and quality.
- Ericson2314 6y agoWell, these are better models fine-tuned to the actual situation. That's great I was referring to the the econ-101-style reasoning that the mainstream has used when engaging with public to say the minimum wage or rent control is bad.
- JamesBarney 6y agoEcon 101 style reasoning doesn't tell us whether the minimum wage or rent control is bad. Only that it's inefficient. It also tells us it will reduce the quantity and quality of jobs and rentals. But whether or not that's the right choice is going to depend on a lot of things theory can't tell us like how elastic the market is or what we value.
- Ericson2314 6y agoDo agree that "inefficiency" and "reductiontion of the quantity and quality of jobs and rentals" from the econ 101 model is not true in the real world? Yes people can value many different things, and I fully support that, but I think before we get to those subjective things it's better to get into the objective parts,
- Ericson2314 6y agoSee also https://phenomenalworld.org/sources/political-sun https://phenomenalworld.org/sources/political-sun which links to a few things including J.W. Mason piece. If doubting the mainstream economic consensus still seems a bit edgy, consider that much of it is still bound up in the supply-side scarcity-based thinking this forum loves to disdain. In this case, the lack of the urban growth we could have dwarfs other sins.
- wahern 6y agoThe data shows that rent control regulations can slightly decrease the number of rental units. If that's all there was, then rental control is clearly bad. However, rent control is fundamentally about providing stability and security for existing tenants. I've yet to see any study try to account for that, perhaps because it's very difficult to quantify. But without accounting for this benefit then empirical studies can only ever show the downsides. There exist the same stability and security concerns with property taxes. Oddly, few economists seem to seriously promote Georgist land value taxes, notwithstanding lay enthusiasm. Probably because they intuitively understand that it's politically untenable, regardless of how economically efficient it is, to tax people out of their homes just because the world around them has changed. And indeed, if you look at every example in the United States where LVTs have been attempted, you see that LVT rules and their administration invariably succumbed, often almost immediately, to myriad exceptions and loopholes in the face of political pressure, especially from residential property owners. Is it impossible to avoid rental controls in large, high-demand cities, or impossible to institute rigorous LVTs? I don't think so. But it's much more difficult in some political-economic contexts than in others. Many things need to align to make it tenable, not the least of which is the capacity to deal with the disruption for existing residents and ensuring that the security and stability needs for future such residents can be met in other ways. Don't forget that for an economist you can solve problems by, for example, packing housing insecure people into box cars and shipping them off to the desert where you've built beautiful bungalows for them to live out the rest of their lives, so long as the cost of those bungalows is less than the efficiencies unleashed by opening up the market for people of more means. Or maybe less cynically, give them monthly stipends that they could (and hopefully would) use to relocate. But suffice it to say, such solutions are often, to varying extents, contrary to normative economics--i.e. what we're fundamentally trying to achieve or are capable of achieving socially. To my mind, the question of whether rental control is bad or good seems misplaced and impossible to answer without more context. And rent control policies can always be tailored to the local situation. Loosely speaking, pretty much the entirety of the U.S. is already subject to some kind of rental control in the sense that there are almost always laws, for example, that provide tenants the benefit of long notice periods before eviction, or which nullify directly or indirectly damages for early lease termination. These impose real costs that get baked into rents, but the benefits to tenants are generally considered worthwhile.