4 ms·
The solution to this is to tweak rent control. For example, introducing sticky prices and incentivizing leases to end in the same week can do wonders to help pe
by sudosysgen 6y ago
The solution to this is to tweak rent control. For example, introducing sticky prices and incentivizing leases to end in the same week can do wonders to help people move affordably.
I don't see that from the perspective of a new resident it must necessarily be worse with than without rent control. The scenario that would make the difference in overall supply would be if the old resident had to move out against their will, and obviously that's what we're trying to avoid.
You really do have to incentivize some construction, though. Getting the ball rolling by buying some unzoned land and building good quality public housing on it can also be good.
- eru 6y agoNo need for the public housing: the hard part is to get anyone (public or private) permission to build. The building is relatively easy business.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThat may very well be the case. That being said, some promoters may decide to neglect some classes of housing or hold out for more profitable ventures even when you fix zoning. So public housing may or may not be needed still, that's going to depend on what happens.
- eru 6y agoIn earlier times, when it was easier to get permits for building, the common charge was that building cheap housing was more profitable than building decent yet alone luxury housing. Yes, we want developers to go and seek profit. Build, build and build, until the market price for housing is roughly in line again with actual construction costs. If luxury housing is most profitable, that's fine: those rich folks don't just pop into existence, they leave some slightly lower market housing behind when they move. (And then someone else moves to that, etc, down the chain.) The total amount of housing is more important to affordability at the low end than the type of housing.
- JAlexoid 6y agoThat's easily debunked... Let's take NYC as an example - there are many people moving to NYC daily and many are high income people(finance and tech). Where do you think they are going to rent? Are they going to get that $2000 1910s railroad apartment with noise from the subway or... are they going to go for a $4000 apartment in a complex with a gym and a pool? These gentrifying inflows of people have little to no effect on availability of lower cost housing. New housing complexes prevent neighborhood gentrification, by siphoning off the gentry into new buildings.
- stuaxo 6y agoThat hasn't worked out well for ordinary renters in the UK. Under Thatcher "right to buy" council houses (public housing) was brought in, in the 80s - at the same time, councils pretty much stopped building to replace the housing stock that was taken. Rents have increased massively above inflation, and waiting lists have soared to over 20 years in some cases for the council houses that are left. Meanwhile, developers build large amounts of "luxury flats" which are sold to foreign investors who often keep them empty. https://londonist.com/london/housing/how-many-vacant-empty-homes-london https://londonist.com/london/housing/how-many-vacant-empty-h... According to the above article 22,000 empty homes in London, but it wouldn't surprise me if there were many more.
- eru 6y agoThe UK is actually a good example _for_ what I said: it's really hard to build in London and the wider UK. See eg https://www.economist.com/britain/2017/02/11/britains-delusions-about-the-green-belt-cause-untold-misery https://www.economist.com/britain/2017/02/11/britains-delusi... or https://www.economist.com/leaders/2017/08/03/how-to-solve-britains-housing-crisis https://www.economist.com/leaders/2017/08/03/how-to-solve-br... About the empty homes: they could start by abolishing the empty-home and single-occupier discounts for council tax. (If you want to go further, instead of just abolishing those discounts, replace them with extra tax charges for unoccupied property.) And then jack up the council tax by a lot. The council tax is unpopular, but actually virtually free for renters, its economic burden falls almost completely on landlords. (You can perhaps see that easier with a simple thought experiment: imagine there was a cut in council tax, rents on new leases would go up almost immediately, until the total cost to the renter is the same as before. Of course, a thought experiment is not a prove. Just an illustration.) Even better than the council tax would be a land value tax. But they could make slight tweaks to the council tax to get closer. If those 'evil foreigners' paid lots of taxes on their empty flats, no one would need to mind: We can build up high enough, if there are enough permits, to afford a few empty homes. Especially if the foreign owners of those empty homes were to finance our government expenditures with their generous tax payments.
- JAlexoid 6y agoI used to live in London... and the fact that Tower Hamlets council tax was LOWER than slightly farther out of the city centre is ridiculous. The luxury flats had no effect on supply - because it wasn't nearly enough. Getting government approvals is hard and then you have low council taxes in London. And closer to the city centre - the lower the council taxes! Let alone - 22k is literally a drop in the bucket. It wouldn't make a damn difference in a city of 10mil!