3 ms·
Suppose you had a choice between living in country A or country B. Country A bans encryption but allows assault rifles. Country B bans assault rifles but allows
by skissane 6y ago
Suppose you had a choice between living in country A or country B. Country A bans encryption but allows assault rifles. Country B bans assault rifles but allows encryption. Which would you choose?
I think it is obvious that country B is the better choice than country A. A lot of people (including myself) have zero interest in the hobby of recreational assault rifle ownership. But banning encryption has the potential to cause massive harm, both economic, and in terms of freedom of speech and freedom of thought. If the government wants to control what you say and think, taking away your freedom to communicate out of the government's hearing is a great first step. By contrast, taking away the freedom to own assault rifles has far less impact – I don't have that freedom in the country in which I live, and I don't even notice it, because I have no interest in owning one. But I definitely would notice if the government tried to ban encryption.
- arrosenberg 6y agoI think a large number of Americans would take the opposite view.
- reedjosh 6y agoBut note how the encryption ban comes about after the firearm ban in the country of discussion. Firearms rights (at least in the US) were intended as protection from tyrannical governments more so than even self protection. Though I acknowledge that today the US government is too powerful for citizens with firearms to prevent any tyranny.
- u801e 6y ago> Firearms rights (at least in the US) were intended as protection from tyrannical governments more so than even self protection. The same argument could also apply to encryption. That is, it can offer you protection from a tyrannical government in addition to protecting your information from criminals.
- reedjosh 6y agoI do agree with you. I'm just pointing out that both are intended as rights of a sovereign individual to protect oneself from both other individuals and government.
- saurik 6y agoThis is a weird choice to present the reader, as it can only tell you which freedom is more critical, not whether they are of similar form (and, FWIW, they are at least so clearly related that the United States regulates encryption largely as part of arms regulations and treaties).
- skissane 6y agoEncryption seems directly related to freedom of speech, freedom of thought, and privacy rights, in a way which gun ownership issues are not. Encryption directly protects your freedom of thought by making it possible to communicate your thoughts to others without the government being aware of them, hence making it difficult for the government to punish you for sharing those thoughts if it disapproves of them. Owning a gun doesn't directly protect your freedom of thought. Maybe you could argue that a gun can indirectly protect your freedom of thought, since if the government tries to restrict your freedom of thought, you can respond by violently overthrowing the government using your gun. However, in practice, that is very unlikely to work – an attempt to use your gun to violently overthrow the government is far more likely to result in your own death (or spending the rest of your life in prison) than in any actual change in the government or its behaviour. Even if you had a million fellow citizens with their own guns supporting you, you'd still struggle to win against the tanks, fighter jets, bombers, drones, missiles, etc, of a modern military.
- jcrites 6y agoIt may seem like a minor detail but there's a very substantial functional difference between "rifles" and "assault rifles": assault rifles can fire as fully-automatic "machine guns". There is no such thing as "recreational assault rifle ownership". I posted in detail about this in another comment [1], but "assault rifles" are machine guns and are highly regulated in the United States. You can't buy or own one without a special federal permit from the ATF which has a high bar to get. You also can't buy any gun under normal circumstances without an FBI background check. What everybody is talking about when they say "assault rifle" are actually just "rifles", which function the same way as other hunting rifles and handguns, merely having a different form-factor. AR-15s (ArmaLite Rifles) for example are just normal rifles, not assault rifles. There are many variants, but plenty of AR-15s will fire the same 9mm ammunition that handguns fire. (Caliber has nothing to do with the classification; that's just an example.) I'm not even sure that individual people can legally possess machine guns in the US. From what I recall you essentially need to form a corporation and apply for it to become a firearms dealer, and get approved; and then the corporation may buy and possess them. The ATF probably tracks every legally sold and owned machine gun in the US. There is very limited "recreational" use of machine guns: you can go to Las Vegas and pay to fire a machine gun that's mounted to the ground, and whose firing angle is limited. That's about the extent to which any normal person (civilian) will ever legally interact with a machine gun or assault rifle in the USA. For those who want to use informed language to have a precise discussion, please use the term "rifle" if that's what you mean, and avoid using the FUD term "assault rifle" (unless that's what you mean), usage of which has been polluted by poor journalists and opinion-providers that use sloppy language (and an expired law that skissane points out below). [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26826847 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26826847
- skissane 6y agoWhen people say "assault rifle" in the US context, they often mean rifles to which the former "Federal Assault Weapons Ban" applied [0]. That is a semiautomatic rifle having certain features–which is not what is called an "assault rifle" in military or policing contexts (the later are automatic weapons). You can disagree with calling semi-automatic rifles "assault rifles", but they are rifles that fall under the legal definition of "assault weapon" that existed in the US from 1994 to 2004 (and which some US politicians would like to reinstate), so calling them "assault rifles" does have a legitimate basis. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Assault_Weapons_Ban https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Assault_Weapons_Ban