6 ms·
"Banning encryption" is such a dumb premise. If I lived in some future, hellish Europe, I'd simply mail USB drives with GPG keys on them to the people I love. C
by smoldesu 6y ago
"Banning encryption" is such a dumb premise. If I lived in some future, hellish Europe, I'd simply mail USB drives with GPG keys on them to the people I love. Costs $15 if you buy the drives in bulk. After that, chat away using PGP encrypted messages. Good luck, EU.
- geek_at 6y agothe problem is not that you won't be able to use encryption (software), it's that if the police suspect you of anything and you have encrypted data that you're not willing to unlock you'll be punished by full extend of the law. But I think that could lead to better encryption software with plausible deniability like Veracrypt has
- intricatedetail 6y agoThis already is a law in the UK. It is 5 years for not disclosing password.
- beckman466 6y agowow that is scary.
- atat7024 6y ago"Politics doesn't affect me" is unfortunately not true these days.
- oarsinsync 6y agoWhere “these days” is “the last two decades”, as far as RIPA goes.
- luxuryballs 6y agodang so that means 5 years for forgetting your password too
- CameronNemo 6y agoCut to LE carrying around encrypted thumb drives to plant as evidence.
- colejohnson66 6y agoDoesn’t even need to be encrypted; It could just be random data. Sufficient encryption is indistinguishable from random noise.
- fastball 6y agoDamn thank god for the 1st amendment.
- gerdesj 6y agoThe Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 - https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2000/23/contents https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2000/23/contents It's a bit of a beast.
- Tenoke 6y ago>But I think that could lead to better encryption software with plausible deniability like Veracrypt has That works for encrypted drives and whatnot but it doesn't look especially applicable for any real-time communication.
- SCHiM 6y agoExcept it is. IS used facebook for a lot of their communication. Imagine a code like: "Ten camels drink from the water at $some oasis". Meaning: "Attack $city at 10 AM tomorrow" Or "Meet at $place at 10 tomorrow". This has been documented extensively. All was perfectly legible by whoever can read conversations on facebook, but the meaning is lost.
- Tenoke 6y agoOkay, yes sure but it does seem limiting.
- akira2501 6y ago> it's that if the police suspect you of anything and you have encrypted data So, back to steganography, then?
- mullingitover 6y agoOne time pads are pretty great. Unbreakable with brute force attacks, indistinguishable from random numbers so you have plausible deniability about whether you're actually storing encrypted data.
- candiodari 6y agoAre they unbreakable by the technique actually used by the average EU country though ? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law Generally it goes like this 1) you get a notice either from a judge or the police to provide unspecified assistance with an investigation (you are not told even 5 minutes in advance WHAT assistance, and there is a default gag order: if you inform a customer or ... that you handed over their info, you go to jail) 2) if you refuse to do something they charge you with a crime, not providing encryption keys is such a crime 3) look like EU "average" sentence is 2 to 5 years prison, plus 50k euros One time pads are obviously encrypted, meaning if you see one you know they're a key to something, so if you refuse to decrypt what is encrypted with them (or can't, let's not pretend these people know or care about what is and isn't possible beyond obvious cases like whatsapp), and a police officer cares, you may very well have a choice: decode or face 2 years prison. JUST for not giving a police officer full access, for example, to your phone, nothing else.
- mullingitover 6y ago> One time pads are obviously encrypted Not obviously - you could have a 1GB blob of encrypted data, or a 1GB blob of random numbers, so there is plausible deniability. You're right that they're vulnerable to a rubber hose attack, but it's not a slam dunk case in court.
- 6y ago
- nness 6y agoIt seems more than a few countries already treat refusing to reveal your password or keys as contempt of the court or a breach in its own right: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law
- Jenk 6y agoIt's not that. You can already be charged with obstruction of justice in many countries if you refuse to provide keys for encrypted drives. This is about prohibiting encrypted messaging in the first place. WhatsApp et al will be denied market access, app/play store entries for all encrypted chat apps will be removed or have versions shipped without encryption etc. The average HNer won't be that affected but the general public will. Access to encryption will be greatly reduced and most people won't even care or notice.
- upofadown 6y agoJust use an email server outside the EU that will not respond to EU warrants. Almost all email transfers are protected by TLS these days. So the authorities won't know you are using encryption in the first place. If they suspect you of something they would have to come to you to get your IMAP password to check if your email is encrypted. PGP is, as before, a technical counterargument to this sort of oppression. Perhaps the powers that be need to be again reminded of its existence. After all, the proposal is to backdoor all encryption software. That is simply impossible.
- mnd999 6y agoIf they make it illegal they can just kick down your front door, arrest you and take your computer and your encryption keys.
- StreamBright 6y agoFirst off PGP is not a great security tool, second of all the EU can just stop the GPG encrypted messages at the service provider level. The ultimate solution against government stupidity like this is a full mesh based “internet” that is based on connections between homes without using an ISP. It is not going to happen for obvious reasons (90% of population is non-technical for starting).
- turnerc 6y ago> service provider level I think the parent comment was going to mail such drives, and good luck getting the EU to agree on blocking anything on their independent providers level.
- Tenoke 6y agoThey've been pretty good at banning things at the provider level. Sites in the UK seemingly get banned by everyone as soon as the government requests it. Similar in Germany, and they go out of their way to analyze most or enough torrent data going through I believe all ISPs to detect what you pirate. Doing the same for detecting encryption doesn't seem farfetched.
- turnerc 6y ago> Sites in the UK seemingly get banned by everyone as soon as the government requests it I live in the UK this is not correct, these are voluntary agreements by ISP's and you can opt out of the default filtering. I think the only time something has been blocked here it was due to a Court Order: https://www.virginmedia.com/help/list-of-court-orders https://www.virginmedia.com/help/list-of-court-orders
- Tenoke 6y agoI mean that's still a fair amount of sites. I recognize and have used plenty of those.
- prepend 6y ago
- dharmab 6y agoA classic: https://xkcd.com/538 https://xkcd.com/538 Replace the drugs with a warrant and the wrench with the threat of criminal punishment and expense of lawyer and court fees.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- st_goliath 6y agoThis kind of response saddens me every time I get it. Every time governments start scaring people about pedo-terrorists behind every corner and start demanding censorship/mass surveillance/back doors, the standard response from fellow people in tech fields seems to be "this doesn't concern me, I will just do $CIRCUMVENTION". It utterly misses the point. The issue here isn't a technical one. If a law is proposed that you can see as morally, ethically flawed and outright dangerous to society, the response definitely shouldn't be to laugh it off and pretend it doesn't concern you.
- yoz-y 6y agoWhat are they going to do anyways? Jail everyone? Ban the browser? Encryption can be developed on top of any communication protocol anyways.
- roywiggins 6y agoRequire backdoors in apps available in the Apple and Google App stores. That will steer loads of people away from using e2ee encryption.
- ajmadesc 6y agoWhat are they gonna do, round up ALL the Jews. C'mon it's 1932, nothing like that could happen in less than 10 years!
- pradn 6y agoIt's ironic how the very expertise that makes us technologists able to solve these problem for laypeople, can blind us to the issues that come with having this technical world-view. We shouldn't expect computing to be at the top of people's minds, because they often, rightly, have more dear things to worry about.
- brokenmachine 6y ago>If a law is proposed that you can see as morally, ethically flawed and outright dangerous to society, the response definitely shouldn't be to laugh it off and pretend it doesn't concern you. Especially when we are the experts who are best equipped to argue against it.
- estaseuropano 6y agoThat future is not going to happen. Read the underlying documents and this lobby article just misrepresents what is in the actual legal/policy documents
- nix23 6y agoFeather-net for the win, no need for mail company. Just buy some pigeons...and train them: https://spectrum.ieee.org/tech-talk/computing/networks/pigeonbased-feathernet-still-wingsdown-fastest-way-of-transferring-lots-of-data https://spectrum.ieee.org/tech-talk/computing/networks/pigeo...
- brokenmachine 6y agoUsing PGP is illegal now. Checkmate.