12 ms·
Whatever the behind-the-scenes truth, I think the appearance of conflicting interests is a problem regardless. For a lot of elected offices and high public serv
by wpietri 6y ago
Whatever the behind-the-scenes truth, I think the appearance of conflicting interests is a problem regardless. For a lot of elected offices and high public service positions, I think their wealth should be put into a blind trust, one constrained by law to buy broad, boring things like index funds.
That would surely be a problem for some individuals. But I don't think it's a systemic problem. We only need to find 0.00013% of the US population to fill the Senate and House together; surely there are that many people who are both competent and willing to put the public interest ahead of their own.
- sneak 6y agoI think this presupposes the lie that the government is by, of, or for the (majority of the) people. This is a closed system, and most are not allowed anywhere near the control room. It, including these trades, is working as intended.
- smt88 6y agoThe US is explicitly not about the majority. The Senate and Presidency are both anti-democratic institions where land controls votes.
- munk-a 6y ago> It, including these trades, is working as intended. You can view the US in a lot of cynical ways but it was not created as a vehicle to allow the wealthy to continue to gain wealth at the expense of the poor. Insider trading between congressmen using their posts to fleece the public was never an intent of the government.
- jhallenworld 6y agoIt was at least created for them to at least preserve their wealth. In the debates leading up the creation of the Senate, here is a typical argument: "...our government ought to secure the permanent interests of the country against innovation. Landholders ought to have a share in the government, to support these invaluable interests and to balance and check the other. They ought to be so constituted as to protect the minority of the opulent against the majority. The senate, therefore, ought to be this body; and to answer these purposes, they ought to have permanency and stability. Various have been the propositions; but my opinion is, the longer they continue in office, the better will these views be answered" https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-10-02-0044 https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-10-02-004...
- jessaustin 6y agoThat is precisely the reason that Madison and his collaborators wrote the constitution (with debates kept secret from the public). The nation already had popular rule and a federal organization in 1781. The problem for the rich was that state legislatures kept helping out the majority of their voters, changing various rules about repayment of debts and so on. The constitution put an end to all that, as it was intended to do.
- triceratops 6y ago> it was not created as a vehicle to allow the wealthy to continue to gain wealth at the expense of the poor I mean the American revolution was spearheaded by wealthy land and slave owners who were tired of taxes.
- smt88 6y agoI think it's easy to rephrase this as follows: People should not be able to make bets on matters over which they secretly control the outcome. That means any federal official should have their investments behind a blind trust of some sort, no exceptions.
- Jommi 6y agoEdit it to "secret bets" or even "non publicly announced".
- smt88 6y agoI'd have to think it through more, but my gut says that I don't care if the bet is secret. Although I would separately support a law that all elected officials must have extreme transparency into their finances. I think people should give up all of their right to privacy (when it comes to business, finances, travel, and even conversations) when they acquire a large amount of power. In my head, a US senator would have that much power and that little privacy, whereas a US representative in the House would not.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoIsn't this already an illegal conflict of interest? Are federal representatives immune?
- infinite8s 6y agoCongress excluded itself from insider-trading laws. Convenient, eh?
- _underfl0w_ 6y agoCan anyone cite a source for this? I don't doubt the legitimacy, but would like to know more about it.
- vageli 6y ago
- nitrogen 6y agoWe only need to find 0.00013% of the US population Maybe we should use sortition then instead of elections? What could be more democratic than random average people (meeting some criteria) taking a turn at the wheel?
- rootusrootus 6y agoI agree, I have long thought sortition might be the right answer. Right along with leveraging modern technology to reset our representative-to-citizen ratio to something like the constitution originally prescribed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rocqua 6y agoThe thing is, the last few times I recall when some have tried more direct democracy (Brexit, a few referenda in europe, california ballot measures) it seems to lead to decisions that seem rather sub-optimal. I am not sure the random citizen might actually be better at governing that a professional politician.
- rootusrootus 6y agoI think that is a completely fair assumption, you may be right. Partly why I think we should dramatically increase the numbers of representatives is to mitigate this problem somewhat. On average, I think a lot of regular citizens would do just fine. So we limit the damage by limiting the amount of power a single vote has. It's kind of the same reasoning I use for extending the vote to children. In a country of 330 million, each individual vote is nearly meaningless on it's own so I figure the risk is much lower than the benefit of getting people involved at a younger age in a future that they should care deeply about. HN did not collectively appreciate this suggestion when I made it, however :).
- slowmovintarget 6y agoA significant percentage of random average people have no practical understanding of economics, and no ability to think of consequences to policy. Granted, neither do a significant percentage of the currently serving congress if current policy is anything to go by.
- psychlops 6y agoJust require them to announce their trades publicly 24 hours in advance. And let them manage their own finances. All these shenanigan's would disappear.
- somethoughts 6y agoYes - in addition - just have documentation sites like unusual whales which track the trades, holdings and profits of politicians - create infographics prior to every election and distribute them to existing voter information/polling prediction sites like real clear politics. Politicians already long on certain stocks can also profit from legislation that they are passing. Being privy to insider info which leads to continuing to stay long a stock is an advantage that wouldn't be detected by just sharing recent trades. In addition to trying to eradicate insider trading - just shedding light on existing holdings by US office holders will have a huge cleansing effect that will go a long way to showing potential biases/conflicts of interest.
- mikepurvis 6y agoI would love to believe that would make a difference, but in a hyperpartisan world where many vote based on a handful of ideological allegiances, how many would seriously be moved to change sides over something as small as a little corruption? Or is this something that would be more at the primary level, where it really is more about personality and personal qualities than party? In any case, the Trump movement's whole response to this kind of thing was a combination of denial and "lol everyone does it", and it seems like that was enough for many in that camp.
- rocqua 6y agoThere are still voters on the fence / differences in voter turn-out that mean politicians worry about scandal. The main effect is that these politicians will probably be replaced by different ones from the same party. Moreover, other politicians, hoping not to be replaced, might stop doing blatant insider trading.
- somethoughts 6y ago
- throwaway5752 6y agoI speak for a lot of people that while I agree with you in principle, the sudden interest in this idea in Republican circles after the prior administration's absolute mockery of conflict of interest and self-dealing laws seems hypocritical.
- munk-a 6y agoLaws need to come into force sometime - and as long as we're not going to get a ping-pong law that's repealed as soon as republicans get into power then I don't mind it happening while democrats hold the torch. I am well aware of the hypocrisy some folks show on this topic but, honestly, it's a good law no matter who is in power and if we're just trying to be petty we won't get anything done.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jb775 6y agoCan you provide any sources for your claims that prove Trump administration personnel directly profited off any supposed self dealings? Or are you just pulling this out of your ass bc you are a lib? Also, who else specifically do you "speak for"? This article isn't even about self-serving decisions that may benefit politicians down the road...it's about politicians who are actively using politician-privy inside information for short term profit at the expense of their constituents. But hey let's keep crying about orange man bad!
- Swenrekcah 6y agoThe “orange man” was bad. This is getting tired. If you are interested in his cronies’ self dealings just look it up. They did all of these things and more but also did them more explicitly. Which is a bit more honest in a way I guess? But the worst part about 2017-2020 was the way he cozied up to enemies of democracy, undermined democracy himself and made a point of sowing and igniting division. Back to the article, this behaviour is despicable and should be punished for everyone, D or R.
- Avalaxy 6y agoWould it really help? You can't restrict their complete social circles as well. All it takes is 1 willing friend who will happily accept your stock tips ahead of large announcements and who's willing to give you a share of the profits in return.
- Taylor_OD 6y agoIf you took away the politicians way of getting rich then what motivation would people have to be politicians? /s
- unethical_ban 6y agoI'm thinking of running for city council because I actually give a shit about civil service, the importance of good government, and I think I'm a better option than some of the absolute nutcases even running for mayor in my city. Some people actually care.
- Taylor_OD 6y agoThat's awesome. I voted for a person for Mayor of Chicago last year who I know cared. They got ~1000 votes.
- BurningFrog 6y agoPower! I don't like this corruption, but there are many worse things our rulers could do.
- snarf21 6y agoI agree that ALL government employees, their spouses and companies should own no individual stocks until they leave office/job. However, the politicians are just the tip of the iceberg in regards to the rigged game of Wall Street. We have bigger fish to fry but no one seems to like fish anymore.
- hyperpape 6y agoI agree in spirit, but this is overbroad. The various branches of government employ millions of people. A cop, or VHA nurse, or my friend who works a non-managerial role at the EPA can own stock. It's the decision-makers who were should be concerned about. That group extends beyond congress, but doesn't contain literally every government employee.
- delusional 6y agoI don't think normal middle class government workers owning stocks is a real problem. I get where you're coming from (technically they could have inside information), but it's not nearly as impaction as the elected officials having very large swings hinge on their own policies.
- xwolfi 6y agoI work in a bank, at a low level. These trades would have gotten me fired.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jjordan 6y agoThe nature of politics tends to attract the very kind of people that you don't want in politics.
- contradistinct 6y agoPoliticians should take a vow of poverty, agreeing to never spend more in a year than the average American. Great way to weed out all of the sharks and keep only the people who actually care and want to lead the country in the right direction, whatever that takes.
- menomatter 6y agoAre these the rules when you work for a bank to avoid the appearance of conflict of interest? How come congress members don't have similar rules