3 ms·
The Middle Ages were bad. They were a period of enforced authoritarian ignorance dominated by the Roman Church, a period which was "dark" because of the distinc
by pessimizer 6y ago
The Middle Ages were bad. They were a period of enforced authoritarian ignorance dominated by the Roman Church, a period which was "dark" because of the distinct lack of written material in Europe after a Greek and Roman period of oceans of insightful written works.
I haven't been exposed to a mythical Renaissance where poor and working people were comfortable, so I don't really need that refuted. I went to school in the 80s, so maybe it was taught that way before or after.
What the Renaissance marked was the beginning of good times through the breaking of the Church in Europe, which allowed proto-atheism and atheist methods to spread. The Plague brought proto-atheism in that, if not actual open disbelief in the Christian God, there was at least a belief that the Roman Church wasn't a good steward of Europe if God had sent something as terrible and universal as plague. This ended up expressed in the Reformation (a movement against the Church citing its selling of indulgences and its tolerance of Jews as reasons it had lost its legitimacy.) The Reformation created a quasi-personal relationship with God (your monarch chose your worship) which in the hands of the lower-middle class preachers of Protestant areas became actual encouragement of a personal relationship with God.
The Peace (of Westphalia) between Protestants and Catholics created a space where atheism could flourish, because as long as it wasn't blatant, it would easily be mistaken for a weird Protestantism (or in Spinoza's case, a weird Judaism.) When the question again became "Why does this happen?" rather than "Why would God make this happen?", something not seen since polytheism, technology lurched, then raced forward.
Of course the sense of ownership and obligation toward the poor dropped with the rise of atheism, along with a middle-class and courtier expansion created by those in the economic position to take advantage of those new tools. A drop in life-expectancy seems as as inevitable as the new philosophers of a secular ethics of the time are impenetrable.
Life expectancy also dropped along with the industrial revolution. But the technological thought introduced with European atheism, and its quick advancement, made it so that even authoritarian societies run by elites could by accident (and a bit of imperialism) raise the living conditions of the Western working class and poor simply through an excess of resources.
Now after 500 years, our working class and poor are more comfortable than peasants in the Middle Ages. That's the good times. Marx and others eventually came up with few decent stabs at a secular ethics. That's good. If we can figure out a way to combine atheism and obligation to others, we've solved civilization.
-----
Edit: we haven't yet had the sort of disaster that would break liberalism (not in the American sense), although 2008 certainly got us in the ballpark in a way we hadn't been since the early 20th century. The big question is whether a break with liberalism would lead to a new dark age, or if some secular ethics has gained enough consistency and legitimacy to ultimately take over.