4 ms·
Consider the case of returning the shopping cart. It is a simple thing you can do for the society. It doesn't inconvenience you in any significant way. And yo
by scotty79 6y ago
Consider the case of returning the shopping cart.
It is a simple thing you can do for the society. It doesn't inconvenience you in any significant way.
And you might have philosophers telling you how you need to adopt a world view that being good requires of you to always return the shopping cart.
Or you might just take a political decision to enforce returning the cart by keeping carts locked until you put a coin in them. You can't get your coin back until you return the cart.
This way you take the moral choice out of this situation. If you don't think returning the cart is worth 1 euro to you, then go ahead, leave it wherever and let someone else put in the work.
This system virtually ensures that there are always carts available, they don't litter the parking lot and has no necessity for any moral component.
Why some stores don't use this system? Because they think their customers wouldn't shop with them if they even once happened to not be able to get the cart because they don't have a coin on them... even though it's very easy to get a coin or ask the shop to give you the plastic coin shaped token to unlock the cart.
So basically the store, for their own benefit of making themselves more attractive by making shopping easier to access for even the most absent minded customers chooses to not introduce the policy that would ensure that necessary work is done, but instead appeals to their customers morality to guilt trip them into doing the work.
For me it perfectly illustrates how solutions based on individual morality are only fake solutions promoted to avoid the real cost of actually getting things done thoroughly.
- kqr 6y agoMany stores in my area have used the coin-in-cart thing for decades -- and only recently stopped doing that. I have yet to ask them why, but I am curious. Maybe maintaining the locking mechanism costs more than paying people to collect carts?
- adamrezich 6y agocan't argue with your logic aside from (as someone who pushed carts for months at various Walmarts across South Dakota) the part where implementing coin-for-cart setups in thousands of retail locations across large geographical areas, where there previously weren't any, and customers weren't used to the situation, seems like a negligible corporate profit incentive, when you can always hire more cheap(ish)-labor cart-pushers (and/or enlist cashiers to push carts part-time as needed...) I will say though that when I travelled to Sweden a few years ago, the coin-for-cart system was truly something to behold.
- duckerude 6y agoBut the question remains: if you're a customer at a store that doesn't use a coin system, should you return your cart? It might be a fake solution in the sense that someone else has the power to solve it in a better way, but does that mean you shouldn't do it?
- scotty79 6y agoIf you return the cart, then on one hand you do what's best for the individuals that might have been inconvenienced by your not returning of that cart. But at the same time you enable the decision makers to keep avoiding introducing the policy that will make the carts be always returned. So what should you do? Be the person that is kind to individuals and labeled as "good" by policy makers that are exploiting your morals to keep sub-optimal solution that is cheaper for them? Or not return it and be the asshole, but make it a little bit more obvious that the current solution isn't really working? Good and evil are not one number on the axis. Good and evil are separate concepts, and both are multidimensional.