11 ms·
SiFive Tapes Out First 5nm TSMC 32-bit RISC-V Chip with 7.2 Gbps HBM3
- klelatti 6y agoHow did SiFive get anywhere near 5nm TSMC?
- baq 6y agoperhaps paid some money when the process wasn't booked till the end of time
- RicoElectrico 6y agoFor test chips there is something called shuttle. Other than that, foundries are known to sponsor IP development on their processes.
- snypher 6y ago"The tape out means that the documentation for the chip has been submitted for manufacturing to TSMC, which essentially means that the SoC has been successfully simulated. The silicon is expected to be obtained in Q2 2021." Would this mean the actual chip delivery may still be delayed?
- StringyBob 6y agoChip manufacturing has many steps. For a new leading edge process it may take 3-6 months to get silicon back after submitting the design to a silicon foundry for manufacturing. For a small volume ‘shuttle’ run hopefully there won’t be delays, but this is not the same as having working chips! The foundry will do initial checks it is manufacturable at ‘tapeout’ when you submit your design, but you don’t know for sure if your chip works with intended functionality until you get it back! You are relying on lots and lots of simulations up front before your ‘tape-out’. Sometimes issues are found and a chip requires a re-spin - basically another go with the bugs fixed. You want to do this as few times as possible (ideally right first time) due to cost and time of these iterations.
- gumby 6y agoIt’s also in TSMC’s marketing interest to product a small number of RISC V parts with their latest process. Plus it’s probably fun for some of the people there.
- lizknope 6y agoThey pay money just like any other customer of TSMC. SiFive has a lot of buzz in the industry. I wouldn't be surprised that TSMC wanted to work with them. But there are other intermediary companies that help startups group multiple chips from multiple companies together into a single mask. This is called a "shuttle" and allows the companies to split the costs of the masks (I've heard up to $30 million for 5nm) SiFive is probably building about 2,000 of these chips for development boards. They aren't trying to order a hundred million like Nvidia.
- klelatti 6y agoThanks that's very interesting. No intention in any way to belittle SiFive - just puzzled as to how they managed to get onto this process when it's obviously so much in demand. Good for them!
- monocasa 6y agoAdding to this, it's in TSMC's interest to have cheaper licenses for high quality processor cores for it's customers, and therefore have strategic reasons to prioritize small runs of RISC-V chips right now. Pretty classic "commoditize your complement".
- gautamcgoel 6y agoCan you list some of these shuttle companies? What are the most popular/reputable ones?
- lizknope 6y agoWhen I have worked at large companies we handled everything ourselves and dealt directly with the fabs. When I worked at startups and smaller companies we have interacted with: Global Unichip Corporation (I believe TSMC owns part of the company) https://www.guc-asic.com/en-global https://www.guc-asic.com/en-global Open Silicon (they literally merged with SiFive to become OpenFive and made this chip in the article) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-Silicon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-Silicon Uniquify https://www.uniquify.com/ https://www.uniquify.com/ Socionext https://www.socionext.com/en/ https://www.socionext.com/en/ There are others but these are the 4 that I have dealt with.
- ohazi 6y agoI know they're separate lines and capacity is sold well in advance and all that, but this chip shortage still baffles me. A startup can tape out a 5 nm chip, but STMicroelectronics can't make any of their 40-130 nm microcontrollers for the next year? Also car companies are supposedly the culprit, even though their volume is only in the low tens of millions per year, and the dustup is apparently over only six months of capacity? What? I get that the auto industry is a nice reliable long-term source of revenue for chip companies, but fabs should barely be sneezing at that sort of volume.
- bravo22 6y agoA lot of chips are made on mature fab lines because they don't need the performance of 5nm lines or can't justify the mask costs. No one is investing in mature fab lines because they're not leading edge and they're being run to amortize the initial investmnet made into them years ago. Therefore not much additional capacity for mature lines. So yes you can see 5nm chips being taped out but the 40-130nm chips are squeezed for capacity. Also this chip is likely not running in the same crazy volumes that ST microcontrollers. It is easier for TSMC to squeeze in a few dozen to a hundred wafers for SiFive on their line.
- variaga 6y agoYour point is valid, but this is almost certainly a shuttle run, so it won't be even one full wafer.
- bravo22 6y agoYou're right. Definitely a "hot" wafer for the engineering samples.
- dragontamer 6y ago> A lot of chips are made on mature fab lines because they don't need the performance of 5nm lines or can't justify the mask costs. Alternatively: they're car-scale products dealing primarily with high electric currents (10s or 100s of milliamps) and/or higher voltages (5V instead of 1.3V). Smaller chips use (and therefore output) less current than larger scale chips. But if your goal is to output 10mA to better drive an IGBT or other transistor anyway, then you really prefer 40nm to 130nm ANYWAY, because those larger sizes are just a lot better at moving those large currents around. Bigger wires mean bigger currents.
- zozbot234 6y agoIIRC, 32-bit RISC-V is only intended for deep embedded workloads, with 64-bit for general purpose compute. So a SoC w/ a single 32-bit core would seem to be a less-than-ideal fit for the cutting-edge 5nm process.
- zibzab 6y agoYeah, this seems like an odd move to me. For this kinda of applications the static leakage of the newer & smaller node will probably hurt rather than help.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tyingq 6y agoThe core is supposed to compete with the Cortex M7. The smallest process M7 I can find is the STM32H7, which is 40nm.
- makapuf 6y agoI rave for stm32 with high end processes (10nm or less), whether that makes sense or not. I just love stm32..
- dragontamer 6y agoRouters / Switches have extremely weird performance characteristics, and I think that's what SiFive is targeting with this chip. * HBM3 for the highest memory bandwidth (10Gbps switches need tons and tons of bandwidth. That's 10Gbps per direction per connection, 8x ports is 160Gbps, and then that's multiplied multiple times over by every memcpy / operation your chip actually does. You need to DELIVER 160Gbps, which means your physical RAM-bandwidth needs to be an order of magnitude greater than that) * Embedded 32-bit design for low-power usage. * All switches have small, fixed size buffers. Memory capacity is not a problem, its feasible to imagine useful switches and routers (even 10Gbps, 40Gbps, or 100Gbps) that only have hundreds-of-MBs of RAM. As such, 32-bit is sufficient and 64-bit is a waste (You'd rather half your pointer memory requirements with 32-bit pointers rather than go beyond 4GB capacity)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- volta83 6y agoHBM2 is like 2Tb/s, how is HBM3 7GB/s ?
- virtuallynathan 6y agoI think that’s per-Pin bandwidth?
- hajile 6y agoHBM3 wasn't just supposed to be about speed. It also offers a 512-bit option that doesn't require a silicon interposer. I'd guess this was added to make cheaper consumer GPU designs possible. I suspect they're using the HBM2 spec for the narrow bus and cheaper interposer while keeping speeds lower and only using a couple stacks instead of the 16 or so HBM2 stacks required for those 2Tb/s speeds you mention. It makes sense given that their chip likely couldn't use a huge amount of bandwidth anyway.
- vmception 6y agoHBM3 was expected to be like 4GB/s per pin which was seen as double HBM2 per pin, so this is therefore almost even double that, which is good news The HBM2 total memory bandwidth is like 2TB/s, just different scale Anyway I could totally be using wrong nomenclature and terminology, feel free to discuss, these aren't assertions or aren’t strongly held assertions
- winter_blue 6y agoHBM might be an interesting idea. I would love to see multiple bandwidth levels of memory becoming a norm, with computers a very fast small amount of memory, and a larger set of DRR4 or DRR5. We already have multiple levels of cache, why not having multiple levels of RAM? Operating systems and software would need to accommodate a new reality where NUMA is the norm though. But it’s good that we even have the concept of NUMA, so this is not entirely uncharted/unfamiliar territory.
- wmf 6y agoYou would love to see computers become harder to program?
- makapuf 6y agoIt canbe nice to have the opportunity to program something harder but faster. Counter example: Itanium, which was too hard to program (compilers) for.
- sanxiyn 6y agoIt is kind of ironic that compiler theory has advanced and now we can target Itanium no problem. It was a bit (well, a lot) ahead of its time.
- winter_blue 6y agoI would try to build a new compiler (or a LLVM intermediary processing layer) that does NUMA optimizations.
- throwaway4good 6y agoWhat is the use case of this chip? I have the feeling it is some way away from a general purpose CPU / SOC like the Apple M1?
- 01100011 6y agoRTFA? > The SoC can be used for AI and HPC applications and can be further customized by SiFive customers to meet their needs. Meanwhile, elements from this SoC can be licensed and used for other N5 designs without any significant effort. > The SoC contains the SiFive E76 32-bit CPU core(s) for AI, microcontrollers, edge-computing, and other relatively simplistic applications that do not require full precision.
- throwaway4good 6y agoSo it is a proof of concept / demo of subcomponents someone else may license? Is that a correct interpretation?
- sanxiyn 6y agoYes.
- person_of_color 6y agoGood work Chris Lattner and co.