4 ms·
> I'm glad that you enjoy your heavily subsidized new lifestyle. It's really hard to argue against receiving far more in public benefits than you pay in taxes.
by echelon 6y ago
> I'm glad that you enjoy your heavily subsidized new lifestyle. It's really hard to argue against receiving far more in public benefits than you pay in taxes.
> That's the point of Strong Towns: not that there's anything wrong with single family houses in and of themselves, but that the way our economy is structured right now, they usually don't pay for themselves.
You know what else is subsidized? Farms. Should we stop paying for them?
Sports facilities, community centers for youth and elderly, hospitals, homeless shelters. Lots of subsidization to go around.
There are 50 states, and most of them have single family dwellings. Some not even near a city. It turns out a lot of people like to live this way. They're not leeching off of the economy - they're contributing to it.
Single family homes are a pattern of American life. They're not going away anytime soon.
Don't force everyone to live in a city. It's not unlike the bicyclists trying to tell everyone they should bike instead of drive, which simply isn't going to work for most of the people in this country.
Edit: I was downvoted faster than it was even possible to read my comment. I spotted a typo as I submitted and immediately went to edit it,
"0 points by echelon 0 minutes ago"
Wow, HN.
- burlesona 6y agoNobody is talking about forcing anyone to do anything. You know something I really like? Lobster. You know what would be great for me? If the government made a program to subsidize lobster farming and distribution, so that lobster cost $3/meal instead of $20. If it cost that I would probably have Lobster 5 times a week! But, it doesn't, so... I don't eat that much Lobster. I still love it though, and there's nothing wrong with that! Nobody should force me to stop eating Lobster.
- covidthrow 6y agoWhen you stop subsidizing suburbs, will you also stop subsidizing the flyover states? How about the impoverished? Medicare for unhealthy people? Education? Fire departments? Like, what is your "I don't care for subsidies" threshold?
- GeneralMayhem 6y agoYou might think this is a gotcha, but in reality this is a question with a very easy answer: we should subsidize things with positive externalities, and not things with negative externalities. Suburbs have negative externalities (pollution, infrastructure cost, social isolation). Caring for the poor and sick, educating the young, and putting out fires all have positive externalities.
- covidthrow 6y agoI don't think this is a "gotcha". I asked for a threshold, accepting that there are varying costs and benefits. I think that your justification is lacking, however. As though there are no positive externalities for suburban living (there are), or even negative externalities for the other items (there are). I'm not sure I trust your assessment when you identify only negative externalities to suburban living, frankly.
- flukus 6y ago> Like, what is your "I don't care for subsidies" threshold? People that have a higher standard of living than me seems to be a reasonable cutoff, why should I live in a small apartment but pay for your gluttonous lifestyle in a McMansion? I'm all for a bit of wealth redistribution, but from poor to rich is the wrong direction.
- echelon 6y ago> McMansion This is a mock term from detractors. Many large homes cost less than a condo. A mortgage on a home you own is sometimes less than rent in the city. For something you'll never own. I don't get what your gripe is. You can even build a large home with your own hands if you have the skill and time. It's not like it's some unnatural thing that is going to lead to the collapse of civilization. > People that have a higher standard of living than me seems to be a reasonable cutoff > why should I live in a small apartment but pay for your gluttonous lifestyle in a McMansion This strikes me as jealousy. I'm glad you're not making decisions for the rest of us. This planet is a stochastic mix of people trying lots of different things. Most of it is harmless. Live and let be. You're not going to solve the world's problems by pointing fingers. Humanity isn't going anywhere.
- GeneralMayhem 6y agoWith the exception of sports facilities, all of the things you mentioned have positive externalities. Even the most staunch (good-faith) libertarian should be in favor of public funding for hospitals because of the common welfare effects that the market is otherwise blind to. Suburbs are exactly the opposite. It's not just that they're expensive, it's that everyone on planet Earth is worse off for them existing. There is absolutely no rational reason for the government to subsidize things that have negative externalities.
- echelon 6y ago> everyone on planet Earth is worse off for them existing This is hyperbole. Suburbs are not negative externalities. They work to the benefit of the massive communities living within them. People can raise their kids with large, private lawns. Have pools, cook outs, outdoor activities. Lots of private space to relax. Hasn't Covid taught us that suburbs have tremendous merit? Cities are cramped and lonely hellscapes during the pandemic. Beyond that, the objective function for society is not to cram as many humans into a sardine can as possible. If we were trying to optimize life on earth, life would be rigid and unpalatable.
- flukus 6y ago> Hasn't Covid taught us that suburbs have tremendous merit? Cities are cramped and lonely hellscapes during the pandemic. I thought we learned the opposite. With offices closed city centres weren't quite so cramped and living in the inner city during a harsh lockdown gave me quite a few more social options than those in the suburbs. I could go for a walk (leisure or shopping) and catch up with most of my social circle, we could meet in parks and at times had larger groups gathering for drinks. In the suburbs there was much less overlap between people due to the lower density. > the objective function for society is not to cram as many humans into a sardine can as possible One of the major points Strong Towns tries to get across is about zoning, there's no need to be crammed in like sardines, this is just an artifact of strange zoning laws that don't allow much more ideal densities like 3-6 story brick buildings that are reasonably spacious.
- GeneralMayhem 6y ago
- covidthrow 6y agoThese here city folk don't much care for our kind. Nevermind the shirk for the value of diversity—both geographically and functionally—they've optimized the life out of life and gosh darn it, so can you. Sure, subsidize things they like—green tech, social reeducation, space travel, even their subscription streaming movie platforms—but those backwards folks out in the boondocks really gotta go. All 125 million of em. I'll be honest, I've lived all over the country in some of the most diverse, varied places. And despite the trope of the knuckle dragging country folk, I've never met a more bigoted bunch than city dwellers.
- imgabe 6y agoRemember Kozmo.com? I do. For those who were too young for the first Internet bubble, Kozmo.com was a company that was a delivery service for convenience stores. It was great! You want a candy bar at 3am, just order one and someone will bike it right over. Rental VHS tapes? (this was long before Netflix even mailed DVDs) No problem. Pack of cigarettes? No need to leave the house. It was fantastic and convenient and everyone loved it. Unfortunately, it was also wildly unprofitable so it went out of business. Yes, it can be very nice to enjoy things that burn through more money than they generate, but those things simply are not going to last, no matter how much you like them. No matter how much they are a "pattern of life". That which cannot sustain itself, dies. > You know what else is subsidized? Farms. Should we stop paying for them? Not a valid comparison. Farms get subsidized to prevent supply and demand swings from creating price shocks and people starving to death. Not because growing food for people to eat is a fundamentally unprofitable endeavor.
- drewcoo 6y agoThe Heritage Foundation claims that farm subsidies are not for national security.[1] From this we can conclude that the purpose of farm subsidies is almost certainly national security. Which is a good thing, because farm subsidies fail to prevent hunger as you claim.[2] Om the other hand, it seems to be less for security than as "socialism for the rich"[3] given how the money is funneled.[4] [1] https://www.heritage.org/taxes/commentary/farm-subsidies-vs-national-security https://www.heritage.org/taxes/commentary/farm-subsidies-vs-... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunger_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunger_in_the_United_States [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism_for_the_rich_and_capitalism_for_the_poor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism_for_the_rich_and_cap... [4] https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2019/12/31/790261705/farmers-got-billions-from-taxpayers-in-2019-and-hardly-anyone-objected https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2019/12/31/790261705/fa...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throw0101a 6y ago> You know what else is subsidized? Farms. Should we stop paying for them? […] > Don't force everyone to live in a city. It's not unlike the bicyclists trying to tell everyone they should bike instead of drive, which simply isn't going to work for most of the people in this country. What practical benefit(s) do the suburbs bring to society? Why should society pay the costs of them when they are so wasteful from land use, health (due to all the driving), climate change, etc? Farms have been subsidized for years, even before the modern car-based suburbs were invented: urban dwellers paid higher prices for telephones and electricity to build out the infrastructure in rural areas in the early 1900s. But there is no practical reason to subsidize car-based suburbs when you can have (detached) single-family homes, with backyards (with garages/lanes), that are built at densities that can support walkable neighbourhoods and sustain transit. Especially since lot sizes have been shrinking for years and many modern suburban homes are no bigger many urban ones; see this 2019 Cheddar video: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKwOyA-pOTY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKwOyA-pOTY