3 ms·
From what I've seen, Linus has always been mostly quite reasonable and constrictive, even before his 2018 "refection" that some others mentioned. Most of the ti
by arp242 6y ago
From what I've seen, Linus has always been mostly quite reasonable and constrictive, even before his 2018 "refection" that some others mentioned. Most of the time it was direct, but helpful, polite, and constructive. This is probably a big contributor to Linux's success.
It's just that on occasion he would rant and rave to people and call them retards or whatnot. People get a bit of a skewed perception because only those messages make the news and are famous, but that's not really representative of all the messages.
And when he did rant and rave, it was pretty much always towards established contributors who had screwed up somehow; people who in his opinion ought to know better, and most of the time he did have a good point. I don't approve of his style, but it's not like he would randomly call people idiots. It's not as if you ever ran the risk of being scolded by Linus if you were a new contributor sending a patch or anything.
tl;dr: Linus has always been like this, and was just occasionally an asshole.
- remexre 6y agoYeah, I have https://lkml.org/lkml/2004/12/20/255 https://lkml.org/lkml/2004/12/20/255 bookmarked as an example of great maintainership
- cies 6y agoUnscarcastically. :)
- jiggawatts 6y agoWow, that is an incredibly insightful, "big picture" way of thinking. What a leader!
- flashgordon 6y agoThat's the thing. I am very sure perception was tainted by my own laziness and "falling for" populist PR and it took pure coincidence to see the real side! Sigh.
- arp242 6y ago"News" by definition is biased towards both rare and negative events, because common everyday things don't tend to be news. "New contributor gets a very helpful response from Linus" isn't news, and neither is "man spills someone's pint in a pub, they apologize and everything is okay", "woman walks home at night nothing happened", etc. Quite frankly I consider most of the news to be worse than useless and actively harmful (and news is different from journalism; journalism is great). (also, I see now I misspelled constructive as "constrictive" in my previous comment do'h facepalm)