3 ms·
Things have been a lot more equitable since pg was running the show. Although to be fair sometimes you come along a bit late and people don't actually see your
by krapp 6y ago
Things have been a lot more equitable since pg was running the show.
Although to be fair sometimes you come along a bit late and people don't actually see your comment. If it's not still on the first page of their threads list they're probably never going to notice it. Maybe there should be a message when someone logs in to let them know what flags are against their account.
- dang 6y agoYeah, that's a problem. I'm often as much as a couple days behind in looking through flagged comments. I think if we build any more software around banning/penalties, it might be some kind of probation system, i.e. a series of temporary bans, maybe with exponential backoff, and with permanent bannage only as an end state. I can think of reasons why it might work better, including: (1) humans tend to do well with feedback loops; (2) it might feel less personal (in the bad sense of the word); (3) it would be easier for moderators to do a lot more of it. In the optimistic scenario, we'd get a better community and less ill feeling about getting moderated, which would be great. The current path is psychologically too hard and leads to burnout.
- krapp 6y agoThe ability to ban people from specific threads might be a good idea.
- tptacek 6y agoThe reason you'd create the ability to ban someone from a thread is so you can more freely apply feedback --- ie, soft ban more people. Which would probably just lead to a lot of litigation on threads about whether people should or shouldn't be banned from them. A virtue of the current system is that it's very rare to come across a comment that suggests someone should be banned instantly --- so nobody has that expectation.
- dang 6y agoI reflected on this a bit after seeing your and tptacek's comments. It's an interesting idea but I think it would land too personally again, because it's so specific. When moderators make a specific judgment like "you can post in other threads but not this one", people feel singled out, and that's really what stings. Also it would leave a lot of surface area for objections, and any changes we make will need to reduce the amount of argument moderators have to get into —it's both time-consuming and psychologically difficult. I think it would probably be cleaner and simpler to say "you've been breaking the site guidelines so you're temporarily banned". The innovation would be the "temporarily" part.