3 ms·
The factor missing with a SO style "meritocracy" is that it needs to be hard to rise up, but very easy to fall down from misconduct: in other words, a built in
by johnnyanmac 6y ago
The factor missing with a SO style "meritocracy" is that it needs to be hard to rise up, but very easy to fall down from misconduct: in other words, a built in accountability mechanism to ensure they don't abuse their power and become arrogant over it. Not necessarily ban worthy offenses (lest, they simply be banned), but ones that make a less welcome community.
I'm lost on how to do this within an internet community, however. You don't want burners being made to report over a disagreement in opinion and impact them. Or worse, power users tearing each other down in retaliation. I don't think "election periods" would work well either because few people really care to be a moderator to begin with. I can only see it being done by having professional moderators and having a manager review any potential user complaints. Which I'm sure has other problems.