2 ms·
Sure, it's possible that the universe is governed by a few simple mathematical laws. My only point was that sometimes people look at a series of simpel mathemat
by tsimionescu 6y ago
Sure, it's possible that the universe is governed by a few simple mathematical laws. My only point was that sometimes people look at a series of simpel mathematical laws that operate on a series of non-mathematical objects and decide to ignore the objects and focus on the laws, and essentially assume that the objects should somehow derive from the laws.
I have this sensation that people often hope to reduce physics to a few mathematical laws and hope to find they don't even need any constants to measure for those laws - that they'll just pop out of symmetries or other purely mathematical properties, only being left with experiments to confirm that the universe does indeed conform to this mathematical model.
While that would be beautiful, I don't see any reason to expect it to be that way - to be able to prove that the properties of the universe (e.g. The charge of the electron, the mass of the quark) are logically necessary and not mere observations.
- somethingsome 6y agoIf you look at current mathematical and experimental physics, I do not see where people ignore the objects! (and what is a non mathematical object anyway) Physics and mathematics have evolved a lot and current research questions cannot anymore be discovered through simple experiments, one of the reasons is because an experiment would be too costly. But not always, some things are intrinsically difficult to observe or even impossible. In comparison mathematics is a 'cheap' and extremely powerful tool. When a theory is developed enough, we can start to design again experiments to test it. This is simply an example of the scientific method which is applied. In practice, even if a theory is purely mathematical (which is never the case as usually those maths are developed by trained physicists in classical theories) its power is assessed by how much of our reality we can infer with it. People mix frequently how the science make discoveries with what is true, in the case of Wolfram's theory, if it is enough to prove and infer interesting things, it is already worth studying it. If not for the sake of physics, at least for the sake of mathematics :)
- tsimionescu 6y agoAs far as I understand it (and im not in any way claiming to be a physicist) both string theory and Wolfram's theories are tryong to deeive the constants of the Standard Model as properties of mathematical objects, not 'contingent' proeprties of the universe. That is, the Standard Model interpretation is 'the universe just happens to have these particles with these properties and these interactions', while the hope behind String Theory is that we'll be able to say 'the universe consists of this single thing that obeys this mathematical law, and so because of such and such mathematical properties it can look like either an electron or a quark or a tau particle, and when its in the electron state it must have this mass, and when it's in the graviton state it will have that mass/spin/color and no other is possible'. I used the term 'non-mathematical object' for any part of the theory whose properties can't be derived and must fundamentally come from experiment, such as the mass of the fundamental particles in the Standard Model.
- somethingsome 6y agoI make a separate thread to address those comments in particular: > I have this sensation that people often hope to reduce physics to a few mathematical laws and hope to find they don't even need any constants to measure for those laws - that they'll just pop out of symmetries or other purely mathematical properties, only being left with experiments to confirm that the universe does indeed conform to this mathematical model. Why we could not create an abstract system that when we plug in the constants we derive all the rules of our reality? And even better, this system would let us learn more on other universes by plugging different constants! If our abstract system does never contradict our reality when we plug the constants, then it is indiscernable from our reality, so we can accept it as a good model of our universe, even if it has very abstract foundations. > While that would be beautiful, I don't see any reason to expect it to be that way - to be able to prove that the properties of the universe (e.g. The charge of the electron, the mass of the quark) are logically necessary and not mere observations. You can draw the line where you want, some people take those as constants and develop theories from them, other people try to prove that those constants make sense in a greater theory. The same thing happens in maths, you can start with the real numbers, or even only with the naturals, while some other people will construct the numbers from first principles. Why? Why not! And we also have real Incentives : The beauty is when you discover a set of rules where everything we know works without contradiction. If we do not have this kind of system, then the logic would simply collapse and mathematics would have no validity whatsoever.