3 ms·
Im not sure what exactly the criticism of UPenn is here. Is the criticism that the university mistreated Karikó or set unrealistic expectations? IS the critic
by s1artibartfast 6y ago
Im not sure what exactly the criticism of UPenn is here.
Is the criticism that the university mistreated Karikó or set unrealistic expectations?
IS the criticism that the university lacked the foresight to know how valuable her contributions would be 30 years later and didn't adequately support or compensate her?
I don’t know where this idea that untenured university faculty should should not be expected to meet the objectives and and milestones of the university comes from. They took the risk and employed her for 16 years (1989-2005) before she published a groundbreaking study, then another 8 years, before leaving to be a VP at BioNTech. 7 years later, the technology was demonstrated to be incredibly valuable.
Does U Penn deserve no credit for the 24 years of work done by university faculty and researchers in university labs?
- guitarbill 6y agoWe know it's hard to predict the future, and how research might be useful - lasers are a famous example. So yeah, research institutions tying research to the value of the contributions, instead of rewarding quality research is maybe worthy of criticism (but sadly common). Personally, I'd guess it's the two-faced-ness of it all is a bigger one. Not being supportive, i.e. demoting/blocking tenure for Karikó, while at the same time being happy to patent the research, trying to use it as PR 7 years later (once it was shown to be useful), and potentially strategically omitting details. Just leaves a bad taste behind when you find out about the background. Probably without the PR, there'd be less criticism.