3 ms·
You can't define the probability of universes existing on frequentist grounds (except for this universe, which has probability 1), and there are no reasonable p
by tsimionescu 6y ago
You can't define the probability of universes existing on frequentist grounds (except for this universe, which has probability 1), and there are no reasonable priors to define this probability in Bayesian terms (and there would be no examples to help update your priors even if you did find reasonable ones), so the concept of 'probability of universes' is completely meaningless in a formal sense. It's like discussing the probability of the real numbers existing.
To put it another way, a priori, without any predefined physical laws, anything is exactly as likely to exist. There's no reason, a priori, to say that a universe with an infinity of dimensions could not appear out of thin air, if you don't first postulate some physical laws. A universe where entropy always decreases is mathematically possible. If you lived in such a universe, your intuition may well be the reverse of ours - you may believe that more complex universes are more likely to appear than simpler ones, since objects with more states are more likely to appear out of thin air in such a universe.
- coliveira 6y agoThat's incorrect. We are discussing here the set of possible models for the universe, not the necessary existence of multiple universes. In that case there is a clear set of candidates that we need to consider, making the probabilistic method meaningful.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThe set of possible models for the universe is infinite, and dominated by complex universes, as by definition there are fewer unique universes with fewer possible states than unique universes with more possible states.
- coliveira 6y ago> possible models for the universe is infinite, and dominated by complex universes How can you even know this? Do you have at least ONE model for the universe? If that model is complex, how can you show that it works? I think you're just operating on figments of your imagination.
- tsimionescu 6y agoSure: there could exist a universe that consists of one elementary particle doing nothing, with no degrees of freedom. There is no law that you could invole that makes this universe any more pobable than our own (except for the observation that our own universe exists, while this one doesn't). There is also the universe described by String Theory in anti-deSitter space - again, possible from a mathematical/logical point of view, maybe simpler than our own universe, impossible to compute the odds for it existing instead of our own. Overall what I'm trying to say is that arguments that 'simpler universes are more likely to exist than complex ones' pre-suppose that there are some laws of physics that apply 'outside' the universe, apart from logic/mathematics. By the way, I'm NOT trying to argue that we shouldn't be looking for a simple set of laws for our own universe - i believe thath is indeed the only option that makes sense, but only from a pragmatic stand-point - it is the only search strategy that guarantees we will arrive at the minimal possible explanation, regardless of how complex or simple that ends up being. Perhaps we'll find a single theory of everything with no physical constants, perhaps we'll end up with 100,000 different fundamental interactions, this part we can't predict.