8 ms·
Teenage Engineering is a frustrating company. On the one hand, they set out to create some of the most fun music equipment you can own: their Pocket Operator li
by smoldesu 6y ago
Teenage Engineering is a frustrating company. On the one hand, they set out to create some of the most fun music equipment you can own: their Pocket Operator line is awesome for beginners of the hardware world, and they've consistently innovated with their grooveboxes. The problem? They have absolutely no respect for their pricing model. The OP-1 used to cost $800, which was already a big ask for a microprocessor, OLED screen and plastic enclosure. A great machine, but a hard to swallow price to be sure. Once YouTubers started picking up on them, they chose to increase the price (blaming it on a supply shortage, since we all know how hard it is to find ARM cores and OLEDs /s), leaving the OP-1 at a bewildering $1100 total.
If you, the reader, has $1100, pick up an Octatrack. Elektron is one of the few companies that pushes the envelope of digital sequencing and hardware production, and the Octatrack is the pinnacle of their work. At $900-1000, you'll definitely get more mileage out of it than an OP-1, and you don't have to support Teenage Engineering's shitty pricing schema. Even at $600, you can buy an Elektron Digitakt/Digitone, which will probably serve you better in the long run.
- thenewwazoo 6y agoSorry for the meta-discussion (which I know is against the guidelines), but I'm finding it really hard to respond kindly to your comment, given the overarching tone ("no respect", "hard to swallow", sarcasm about parts, "shitty pricing"). I'd love to engage with you on the merits of pricing for what the market will bear, CoGS including software and craftsmanship, etc, but I am not able. Perhaps that's my failing, but I'd like to encourage you to be less acerbic in the future.
- smoldesu 6y agoIf my tone comes off as "acerbic", I guess I'm a little surprised. I love Teenage Engineering (and own a few Pocket Operators too), but I gotta call them out on the pricing issue here. When the price of the OP-1 did start to skyrocket in 2012, Teenage Engineering said absolutely nothing, and then discontinued it in 2013, sending the secondhand market soaring again. Of course, their response is to put it back into production at a higher cost, for more customers. You can slice this any way you want, but there's not really an excuse for an all-digital synth to increase in price like that. I have no doubts that a simple redesign could bring the BOM down to sub-$200, even in 2015. Failing that, they could have taken the re-release as an opportunity to fix some of the issues in the original model: give it a sensible charging port, improve the microphone quality, or even improving the sample transfer software. None of these issues were ever addressed. The insult added to injury is the OP-Z, a "successor" that was designed to be inferior to it's predecessor, as not to cannibalize it's market. Maybe I am hateful, but Teenage Engineering has definitely had a fall from grace. Even their recent modular kits left a bad taste in my mouth...
- zokier 6y agoWhy do you think the BOM cost should have any relation to the selling price? > You can slice this any way you want, but there's not really an excuse for an all-digital synth to increase in price like that Adjusting to market bearing price seems like a good excuse to me.
- smoldesu 6y agoWhatever justifies it for you. For every extra dollar they eke out of bougie hipster, they ostracize people like me who would definitely buy one if it was $500 or $600
- blairbeckwith 6y agoCompanies are under no obligation to not ostracize potential customers. Do you also think that luxury car companies are shitty and ridiculous because they charge more than cars that "do the same thing"?
- monkmartinez 6y agoI do, but I am admittedly a small sample. A case can certainly be made that luxury cars, in general, are not very "good" cars in most metrics as by which the industry measures what a "good" car should be. I think OP has a valid point, if the synth Teenage is selling is inferior and more expensive but sells because "status" and signaling.
- blairbeckwith 6y agoBut they do sell, and Lamborghini or Porsche are not under any obligation to make a cheap car so that everyone who wants one can afford one, nor should they.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- Marazan 6y agoI've no problem with a company pricing a product to be what the market will bear. However, Teenage Engineering claiming they were jacking the price due to "supply issues" is just insulting.
- mwfunk 6y agoI haven't heard about this. Were they busted lying about supply chain issues as an excuse to raise prices? Their stuff is pricey but cool, but if it's documented that they lied about that, that would be hard to get past.
- voxrumor 6y agoThey have talked about it some, seemed reasonable. Also understand why it would not be a popular decision though. Think running a business, and understanding success can be very temporary if you are not careful helps. "We have had to face other costs than the actual components’ costs of course. The currency conversion, inflation, sourcing of the new component, re-coding the display, re-designing the mounting, new tools etc. are just a few of the “why”. When Teenage Engineering faced the reality of the OP-1’s future, there were only 2 choices: kill or save. We decided to save it. I understand that the new price is a disappointment to many of our fans. But I do hope some are happy that we did not kill it." https://www.gearnews.com/teenage-engineering-open-up-about-the-op-1-price-hike/ https://www.gearnews.com/teenage-engineering-open-up-about-t...
- mwfunk 6y agoThat seems unfortunate but reasonable. I don’t begrudge anyone making that choice, and I don’t begrudge anyone thinking their prices are too high (and I don’t begrudge anyone buying their stuff anyway because they think something’s cool). I was way more concerned about the claim that they lied about it and were scamming their customers somehow, but so far there’s no evidence of that.
- bsder 6y agoI would have agreed with you, but sourcing OLED displays is a pain in the ass. I've been personally bitten by this. So, if they bought a 1000 obsolete displays and burned through them, it may actually take an act of God to get more. And you'll probably have to redesign your circuits.
- coldtea 6y ago>I'd love to engage with you on the merits of pricing for what the market will bear Well, there's also the level of pricing and milking it that poorer consumers will tolerate without hating the company, so there's that...
- fedorareis 6y agoI don’t feel that an Octatrack/Digitakt/Digitone is quite a replacement for an OP-1. They may be better sequencers (I don’t have the relevant knowledge to claim whether or not they are), but I’ve always gotten the impression from professional musicians and composers that the appeal of the OP-1 is a combination of form factor and portability. It has keys in a piano layout which makes it easy to play on and it is in a small enough size that you can throw it in your backpack when traveling.
- girvo 6y agoIndeed. A closer comparison would be something like the Korg Electribe, which while quite fun in it's own right, is nowhere near as capable as the OP-1. Though it is quite a bit cheaper (about $600 AUD or so)
- vernie 6y agoMaybe you are just cheap?
- gehsty 6y agoA music instrument is worth more than the sum of its components? Maybe high pricing makes it a sustainable business?
- musicalynejd 6y agoYou don't understand their pricing because you don't understand what they are actually selling. They don't sell musical devices, they sell status symbols. You buy an OP-1 to look cool, not to actually make music with it. It's a bit like with the iPhone, but on a whole different level. Some buy fancy sneakers, others buy fancy pens and Moleskine, others buy an OP-1. And you can't have a cheap status symbol. This is also why they look so clean and minimalistic, like a MacBook, to the point of sacrificing ergonomy, since the aesthetic is what they are selling, so they can't look gnarly, black and full of ports and cables like an actual musical device.
- toiletfuneral 6y agooh hell yeah, we're back to the era "no one does REAL work on Macs / iPhones" but now its the OP-1 you seem mad bro
- smoldesu 6y agoI'm fully aware that's why they sell them, and it's why I'm not criticizing them for something they've obviously done quite well.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- devin 6y agoThis is simply not true. I own a lot of synths, and the OP-1 is a very capable (and extremely portable) 4 track studio. I sketch a lot of music on it, and it sees regular use in the studio.
- musicalynejd 6y agoSure. But that's not why most people buy it. Just like most people don't buy a Rolex Submariner because they regularly do deep dives in the ocean.
- dag11 6y agoDive watches aren't for diving, divers use dive computers. But lots of musicians seem to use OP-1s...
- jaxwerk 6y agoI bought my OP-1 at a steal for $600 two years back. I'd pay $1200 for it today, maybe $1600. There's a lot of more technically capable stand-alone gear that can be had for less of course. My MPC Live is what my finished (not good compared to others, I'm just an amateur making video game soundtracks for kids I teach game dev to) songs ultimately come out of, and the Octatrack is something I've really enjoyed playing with. None of these are going to be something that lives in my backpack and comes out in the park on a sunny day when I've got that perfect boss battle intro sequence drop popping into my head though. Size considerations aside, I can slam down a decent prototype of a song that's actually listenable in just a couple of minutes on the OP-1 before the idea fades away, and have a blast doing it. I think their pricing is sensible. The thing fills a niche no other piece of gear I've found can. That seems worth paying for.
- mmastrac 6y agoI paid about the same... I am considering listing it. It's just collecting dust unfortunately.
- singingfish 6y agoI bought a used one a little while back - because I wanted to try it out and I found one at a price where I knew I could re-sell it easily. I fiddled around with it periodically, and it was fun, and with my limited skills I could do something that sounded reasonably musical with it. But - a. No proper MIDI implementation and b. I found the synth engines very frustrating. On the other hand, using it as a way to add backing to my sax playing, and record my sax onto the device was fun. But I got rid of it, and bought a used organellem and plenty of change left over (with which I might buy a proper sequencer at some point, but maybe not). I've currently got a Novation Circuit which I bought on the same idea. Because I play a lot of acoustic music the circuit seems definitely not for me, but again it's kind of fun and has a nice shallow learning curve.
- arvinsim 6y agoFor $1100, I would rather get an iPad Pro and go the software synth route.
- brandonmenc 6y agoI've owned an OP-1, Octatrack, and Digitone at various points. They aren't comparable to the OP-1, which is more of a quirky, fun, expensive toy, and there's nothing else like it really. I wasn't getting anything done with it, so I sold it. But, I can definitely see how someone could have a lot of fun making songs with it. Is it worth a thousand bucks? Nowadays you're probably better off spending half that on a Roland MC-101 or Novation Circuit Tracks. But I always kind of wish I never got rid of my OP-1 - it was definitely the most fun I've had on a self-contained hardware device - the tape interface for recording was just awesome. But as for the price increases, I never understood why people complain about this. They can charge whatever they want. This not a necessary item. > Elektron is one of the few companies that pushes the envelope of digital sequencing I think the Elektron sequencer workflow is overrated. Software is better. I understand thinking the restrictions encourage creativity (I don't personally subscribe to this idea), but the sequencer isn't "pushing the envelope" compared to what you can whip up in software. So I guess I kind of think some of the Elektron machines are also quirky, expensive toys.
- cush 6y agoHave you ever used an OP1? It was underpriced at $800
- golergka 6y agoYou can't determine a synth's value based on it's components, or it's sounds. A PC with completely free plugins and VST will be always be much more customisable and "powerful" than any hardware device, and have better sound, too. That's not what you're paying for. You're paying for UX that creates the pit of success for your music-making process. You pay for the fact that you use knobs, not mouse — although you would be able to draw an infinitely detailed automation with it. You pay for the limited choices you have, and where these limitations lead you. You pay for the touch & feel. You pay for purely subjective, aesthetic factors, like look and smell — because music-making is a completely subjective, intuitive process and your psychological state is more important for it having a Turing-complete LFO system. I like OP-1 and I like Octatrack, but there's just no way you could have any objective "measurement" for which one is better of has better value — because any value that these devices have is subjective. If you want to decide which one to buy, forget everything about specs, and just spend an hour or two playing with them, feeling them with your hands while you make music.
- deeblering4 6y agoHonestly the octatrack is just as old and overpriced. Elektron has left it behind in terms of features like “overbridge” and after learning the ins and outs of my I much prefer separate sampler, sequencer and looper. Don’t get me wrong, the OT is an amazing box. I just think that for the money a person can make much more interesting jams on a digitakt or midel:samples and an rc505, for instance.
- bzzzt 6y agoComparing the Octatrack which just had it's 10 year anniversary with newer devices seems a bit unfair. I think it was a nice machine for it's time (and at second hand going rate around 500-600 euro still a good deal). There's an advantage to not having to connect and configure multiple boxes if you just want to make some music.
- hbosch 6y agoBuy a Deluge. :-)
- SN76477 6y agoMy analog 4 mk1 was about $600 As valuable as gold.
- tomc1985 6y agoAt that price I expected some actual analog hardware under that pretty case, not just an ARM chip and some OLEDs But then again, back in the day I paid out the ass for a Virus TI, which is largely the same setup. Though for virtual analog it did sound fantastic. I miss that thing...
- Dramatize 6y agoI first purchased an OP-1 because of the YouTube demos, but end up selling after a few weeks. I've now got a Digiton/Digitakt setup that's much better. Elektron's workflow just clicked with my brain.
- diogenescynic 6y agoPeople have been making the same argument about Apple for years. Execution matters. I'll pay a premium for a product that works and has a high quality product design.
- evidencepi 6y agoObviously TE is a company for profit. I don't feel it's a bad thing for them to do so. This proves there is a market for such product, and the competitors should see the opportunities and try to make some great design products that would catch everyone's eye. As a result, it should benefit the consumers. Sure, you have to wait for a while if you don't want to throw cash to TE, but such cool-kids-toys are not expected to be cheap anyway.
- seabird 6y agoThis is top down pricing. Multiple engineers clocked a considerable amount of time on this project. The number of OP-1s sold probably numbers only in the low tens of thousands. It's priced appropriately considering how many they're going to sell and the value the device provides (and not just the raw material cost). We do a lot of computer programming using free or cheap (and billed monthly) tools on this site, so it's really easy to forget that professionals in other fields will pay a premium for something that works with minimal fiddling. Watching electrical engineering managers dump tens of thousands into single pieces of test equipment to not have to fuck around with patchwork solutions is enlightening, and I think software developers would do that a lot more if the FOSS route wasn't the only thing they knew.
- bmitc 6y agoThe OP-1 was very popular and well known well before the shortage and subsequent price hike.
- nemothekid 6y ago>The OP-1 used to cost $800, which was already a big ask for a microprocessor, OLED screen and plastic enclosure I'm not sure it makes sense to price a hardware product on it's BOM. This kind of thinking is what leads to most hardware being absolutely crappy. Good product designers need to be paid, and design choices don't show up in the BOM. The same goes to hardware. When I see an ARM chip and an OLED screen going for $$$, the calculus in my mind is I'm actually paying for engineering and design labor, not a BOM.
- baby 6y agoBom?
- sandermvanvliet 6y agoBill of materials: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_of_materials https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_of_materials
- wayvey 6y ago> The OP-1 used to cost $800, which was already a big ask for a microprocessor, OLED screen and plastic enclosure. A great machine, but a hard to swallow price to be sure. Once YouTubers started picking up on them, they chose to increase the price (blaming it on a supply shortage, since we all know how hard it is to find ARM cores and OLEDs /s), leaving the OP-1 at a bewildering $1100 total. I gotta point out that the price increase was because the original OLED screen went out of production and they had to use a different one which required major changes to the hardware and probably software (at least that's what they say). Also the enclosure is actually a solid block of CNC machined aluminium which is quite nice and robust.
- tomduncalf 6y ago> Octatrack Depending on your musical tastes and tolerance for UI complexity, you may be better served by other Elektron devices as your first purchase. The Octatrack is very powerful but pretty complex to wrap your head around. Personally I’d go for the Analog Rytm mk2, especially if you like drum-based electronic music... it sounds fantastic, is a great analog drum machine but each track can also be used as a synth or sampler track, which makes it much more than just a drum machine, you can really quickly make great sounding full tracks on it. It also has a really fun interface with far fewer button combos to remember etc. than the Octatrack. Of course, it doesn’t matter too much because once you buy one you’ll eventually end up buying them all ;) I agree that Elektron are making some of the most fun and exciting music gear out there, I love all their stuff. Quite a strong tracker influence to their sequencer which I like too!
- capableweb 6y agoI think the complexity of the Octatrack is a bit overstated and probably scares people more than necessary. Only confusing part is the whole track/machine/part/pattern/banks thing, but other Elektron machines have similar complexity. Or maybe it's the sequencer people are scared of? But it's a easy one with just a lot of depth. But I'd agree with you, as a owner of both a Rytm and Octatrack, to go for the Rytm before the Octatrack as it's simply a nicer standalone machine, the Octatrack really needs companions to be fully useful. > I agree that Elektron are making some of the most fun and exciting music gear out there, I love all their stuff Hear hear! My wallet likes Elektron less though.
- tomduncalf 6y agoYeah it is probably overstated, but it is definitely a slightly confusing machine compared to other modern Elektrons (I have the Machinedrum, which you can clearly see how it inspired the Octatrack). I don't use my OT that often and whenever I pull it out it takes me a while to reorient myself with how I load a sample, why is that track muted, etc. etc. Of course out of this architecture comes great flexibility too, unmatched by anything else hardware based really, and when I listen to the patterns I've made, they do sound unlike anything I make with other gear (in a cool way). I am going to try to integrate it as a live looper for "live" performances (to an audience of one, myself, in the bedroom, but everyone has to start somewhere!). And yeah, I'm hooked too. Got most of the boxes now, just missing Monomachine (never really grabbed me and definitely not at the second hand prices!) and Analog Heat (which I bet I'd love but it feels expensive for "just an effect"). Don't regret it all though, I love how each one is a self-contained groovebox that I can make a full track on on the sofa, but also they integrate really well for a more advanced setup. And they're just super fun!
- atoav 6y agoI design and build modules for the eurorack modular synthesizer system. And I can vividly remember that in the beginning, still being a student my one thought was: Why is this stuff so expensive. Five years later, I find myself arguing the opposite in many cases. Most modular synth stuff is not too expensive, but has just the price you'd expect it to have given the number of units sold and the BOM. Yet when I was starting out my comparison were e.g. guitar pedals, which is a much much bigger market. Electronics scale like that. Whether you sell a hundred, a thousand or ten thousand units really makes a difference in terms of pricing. And quite frankly, if you worked 2 years on development it is a bit bold to expect from you that you did this for free. That doesn't mean there are overprized things in synth bussiness. The OP-1 definitly seems pricier than one would expect, but I don't know enough about it to say thia with confidence.
- ollifi 6y agoI like high profit margins. It makes possible (but doesn’t guarantee) better design, better working conditions, smaller volumes, healthy second hand market etc. I love OP-1 but in the end it’s going to be waste. We are in huge trouble optimizing for ever cheaper everything on this planet. If we would be talking about healthcare, food, housing, education I would be more on consumers side, but teenage engineering makes toys for people who have maslows lower levels covered.
- ChrisLomont 6y ago>and plastic enclosure The OP-1 is machined aluminum, not plastic.