3 ms·
I agree with you, but feel compelled to point out the (slightly) insightful part is "Customers are tech-savvy enough to articulate basic product requirements."
by gumby 6y ago
I agree with you, but feel compelled to point out the (slightly) insightful part is "Customers are tech-savvy enough to articulate basic product requirements."
There are consulting projects where the customer knows what they need and can spec it. They are similar to "we need a brick wall built here; use a core of breeze blocks and clad it with brick up to four foot high". You can write the needed tasks easily and get to work.
As you point out, user stories (which far precede 20 years ago and come from the advertising world) are a step above (or before) that, to cover "Oh, people need to be able to look in through this fence; if it's solid then it can't be higher than five feet, maybe less".
This essay would have been better as a short, "don't cargo cult things like user stories when you're already past the point"...but instead they cargo-cult it by inverting the sense and advocating throwing them away.
- twic 6y ago> user stories (which far precede 20 years ago and come from the advertising world) Really?
- akiselev 6y agohttps://smallbusiness.chron.com/use-archetypes-advertising-38626.html https://smallbusiness.chron.com/use-archetypes-advertising-3... User stories are just customer archetypes, themselves based on Jungian archetypes, adapted to software development.
- gumby 6y ago> themselves based on Jungian archetypes Which has always amused me, given that Edward L. Bernays was Freud’s nephew.
- akiselev 6y agoFreud and Jung actually became close friends over a decade before Jung coined his archetypes so that might be how Bernard got exposed to the ideas, even though (IIRC) Freud and Jung had a falling out later. Bernard would have been in his 20s or so
- gumby 6y agoProduct marketers and advertisers used to (and as far as I know still do) write "biographies" of target customers to help decide what messages to send, what the packaging should look like, how and where it should appear in the supermarket etc. They'd look like, "Jane, 35, has an undergraduate degree in a technical field, and is married with two kids. She exercises a few times a month but wishes she could do it more..." Then they say, "So would Jane be drawn to this color or is it too opinionated for her?"
- twic 6y agoThis isn't what a user story is. This sounds like a persona, which is a thing in product management. But it is not the same thing as a user story at all. A user story is something like "Customers want to see the items most recently added to the shop". Or, in Connextra form: As a customer I want to see the items most recently added to the shop So that i can stay abreast of developments in fashion