4 ms·
I think this may create asymmetries between risk/reward for those (real) people making the decisions. Think about it with a sports analogy. If I cheat and take
by bumby 6y ago
I think this may create asymmetries between risk/reward for those (real) people making the decisions.
Think about it with a sports analogy. If I cheat and take performance enhancing drugs, there’s huge potential upside: I can drastically increase my salary. If the consequence was spread to the team rather than concentrated on the individual it encourages the individual to take that risk. Maybe the team would be forced out of the playoffs. So the team lost their (smallish) chance at a trophy but I get a (largish) chance to increase my salary. In rare cases maybe the individual becomes a pariah. Regardless, if the individual isn’t held disproportionately accountable it incentivizes bad behavior. I think there’s a reason leagues ban individuals for certain behavior.
- smolder 6y agoIf workers had to worry about the ethics of their employer getting the whole company in trouble, that would be a good thing in the sense of drying up the labor pool for dubiously run companies. On the other hand, the Justice Dept doesn't always land on the side of justice, so smaller companies could end up victims of abuse of the court system in the name of competitive advantage.
- etripe 6y ago> smaller companies could end up victims of abuse of the court system in the name of competitive advantage. The same already goes for things like IP and trademark, so that's a fair bet. Good point.
- etripe 6y ago> I think this may create asymmetries between risk/reward for those (real) people making the decisions. Those asymmetries wouldn't be new, because the corporation as a construct already shields the real people making the decisions, along with the jurisprudence of slaps on the wrist. Are companies held accountable for their "externalities" today, like mass foreclosures in real estate, exploitative labour conditions, poisoning the water supply, oil spills, climate change or destruction of habitats? In keeping with the prison metaphor, would you work for an "ex-con" company? How about one on "probation" when you've got a family to support? Would you invest in one? As I see it, the potential for self-corrective behaviour is greater with my (admittedly, off-the-cuff) suggestions than the status quo.
- bumby 6y agoI think we’re in agreement. The asymmetric risk I was speaking of is the status quo where individuals are not held accountable but rather the corporate “team” is via fines etc. It makes risky decisions more palatable to an executive officer because they have less downside skin in the game.