3 ms·
Maybe I misunderstood but seems to me that even if you bite and accept their assumption that happiness can be quantified, it's still nonsense. In particular, t
by xg15 6y ago
Maybe I misunderstood but seems to me that even if you bite and accept their assumption that happiness can be quantified, it's still nonsense.
In particular, they quantified happiness, but they conveniently seemed to have forgotten to quantify unhappiness. Sure, if you add more people, the total amount of happiness grows, but it's not clear at all how much the total amount of unhappiness would grow in comparision. (And the note that each newly added life is "barely worth living" suggests each individual contributes a lot more unhappiness than happiness to the total)
Alternatively, you could stick with a single number and use positive values for overall happiness and negative values for overall unhappiness. This still won't work:
Let's assume N is the total number of people and h(i) is the happyness of person #i in "hedons" (don't ask me...)
N is a natural number > 0 and h(i) is... some number.
Than their conjecture says in effect that:
lim(N -> +infinity) sum(i = 0 to N) h(i) = +Infinity.
As every math student can explain to you, that's not how this works. Even if each h(i) was a real strictly > 0, the sum wouldn't necesserily grow to infinity. If elements keep having negative values - not a chance.
The whole thing only works if you constrain that each h(i) must be > some positive number - or if you define h(i) as a count of descrete "hedons" of which most people have at least one. But that's picking a model to support your conclusion.