8 ms·
> the supposed point of crypto is to reducing the reliance on, and grifting from, companies like Coinbase That was the pitch of crypto. In practice, people are
by dehrmann 6y ago
> the supposed point of crypto is to reducing the reliance on, and grifting from, companies like Coinbase
That was the pitch of crypto. In practice, people are buying it as a bet that it will go up. I suspect most people are only buying it because the value is going up. If bitcoin actually worked like a currency and traded between $8k and $12 for the past 5 years, no one would care.
- rawtxapp 6y agoExcept currencies have much bigger market caps, it wouldn't have worked as a currency in that range (outside of a very small economy). We are now in the initial phase where it's being used as a store of value, but sooner or later, it's going to reach roughly it's true value at which point, you would expect it to behave more like a currency rather than an asset with a huge upside.
- spiralx 6y agoCurrencies don't have market caps, assets have market caps. The fact that people talk about crypto's "market cap" is as clear an indication that it's not and never will be a currency.
- delaaxe 6y agoCurrencies definitely have total supplies which can be measured in USD. Let's not be finicky with definitions. https://fiatmarketcap.com/ https://fiatmarketcap.com/
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoGlobal wealth is $400T. All crypto currency combined is worth about ~$2T at this point. So to store 0.5% of the world's wealth, we are using 0.6% of the world's energy. Banks obviously don't use anywhere near this much energy. Bitcoin is estimated to use more energy than all other server farms put together. So we are using 0.6% of the world's energy to store 0.5% of the world's wealth. And < 0.6% of the world's energy to store the other 99.5% of the world's wealth. Doesn't seem like the ideal wealth storage technology.
- delaaxe 6y agoI like this reasoning in terms of global wealth
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI would include the energy needed to maintain trust in other currencies including efforts to prevent counterfeits, which I might argue includes some portion of a nation's militaristic might. Trust is an even more ambiguous, yet crucial aspect of maintaining a currency's value, tied up in the "order" or predictability of the society using the currency, which involves various legal systems and at the most basic level, relationships between its peoples. It takes a relatively minuscule amount of energy to maintain a database of numbers associated with certain people and entities, but quite a significant amount to make it mean something.
- abalone 6y agoIf this were actually true, Coinbase would not need to exist with a market cap of $100B.
- g_sch 6y agoI don't really understand this argument. If militaries are part of the embodied infrastructure of a country's banking system, this would imply that replacing the banking system with something decentralized (like cryptocurrency) would cause countries across the world to reduce their military footprint. I find it much more likely that military resources would be diverted to somewhere upstream of mining in the value chain. For example, if we continue relying on carbon-intensive proof-of-work blockchains, why wouldn't armies simply be diverted to secure energy resources?
- svachalek 6y agoSadly this is true other than "no one would care". Many would care, just mostly not in countries with stable fiat. But the success of BNB which is basically just a corporate database on a blockchain shows there is a big part of the community that doesn't care about decentralization at all.