4 ms·
A few thoughts: - Defamation or slander is also illegal in the U.K. upon which the Singapore system is based. It’s much easier to be convicted of that in the
by refurb 6y ago
A few thoughts:
- Defamation or slander is also illegal in the U.K. upon which the Singapore system is based. It’s much easier to be convicted of that in the U.K. than the US
- That said, I would agree that this is a pretty weak case with the convicted simply sharing a link to an article that contained false statements about the PM
- Having spent considerable time in Singapore I’m not sure I’d label them authoritarian - at least not in the way it’s commonly used.
- Legitimate elections are held although the ruling party has set up a system that is favorable to them holding power (though not impossible for them to lose)
- There is an underlying sense by the ruling party that Singapore as a system is not that stable so the govt actually works quite hard to stay on the people’s good side. Recently the govt admitted that Covid tracing data could be used for police investigations which contradicted prior statements and it did not go over well. The govt basically apologized for mishandling it and added additional protections (though didn’t back down entirely). It’s a bizarre system where the govt holds a lot of power but is very concerned about not having support.
So not excusing the lawsuit (because I think it’s a net harm) but adding some context.
- weswpg 6y agoGood comparison to Western restrictions on slander or libel because Singapore is one few countries to actually have a an "anti-fake news law" which many in the West desire and it absolutely proves the fear that it can very easily be abused