11 ms·
> AFAICT it should be a net positive for society to completely subsidize home tests for everyone, but that is probably an uphill battle against conservative pre
by rayiner 6y ago
> AFAICT it should be a net positive for society to completely subsidize home tests for everyone, but that is probably an uphill battle against conservative prejudices even in Germany.
Great, now we’re “prejudiced” for not wanting to subsidize other people’s risky sexual behavior.
Did it ever occur to you that if there is, as you suggest, a large health burden associated with casual sex culture (and, according to the article, drug use culture), that maybe the “conservatives” are correct to be “prejudiced” against it?
- thesuitonym 6y agoA prejudice is just a pre-conceived notion about something. So yes, if you have decided that casual sex is bad, you are prejudiced against it. Don't be so upset, it's not a problem.
- m-s 6y agoTreating STIs is more expensive than testing, and also paid for through statutory insurance.
- stryan 6y agoMoral argument: functioning society's don't expect their member to act perfectly and always make the right choices. Would you expect a hospital not to treat you because you got injured while committing risky behavior (e.g. extreme sports, trying strange foods, or arguably driving a car)? Treatments like this support "repeat offenders" and the poor bastards who make a wrong choice once alike. Pragmatic argument: It's better economically and for productivity for people to not have HIV, Syphilis, etc. It's far easier to provide treatment and testing then to tell people to stop having sex.
- leetcrew 6y agoI think it's actually fine to charge higher premiums to people who take significantly greater risks than the average person. we already do this with car insurance for people who drive certain models, have been in at-fault collisions, have traffic infractions on record, etc. no one "needs" to go skiing or drive a fast car, but a.) we should let them and b.) they ought to pay a bit more into the pool.
- stryan 6y agoI can see the argument for that, however from my reading OP was arguing that people who take greater risks shouldn't get treatment at all or be "subsidized" by people who don't. You seem to be arguing (and correct me if I'm wrong) that people making riskier choices pay more for themselves to make up for that.
- leetcrew 6y agoyes, that is exactly what I'm arguing. if everyone pays into a pool without any risk adjustment, that is effectively a subsidy to the risk-takers. I think that is a more fair way to understand rayiner's objection to "subsidies". I don't think he is seriously arguing that risk-takers should be denied care/testing/whatever altogether. of course this is all hypothetical with the current state of US healthcare. step one has to be a reasonable cost baseline for people who don't elect a bunch of extra risk.
- bradlys 6y agoHow is this different from healthcare as it is set out now or in the past? (Pre existing condition? Too bad. Too expensive to keep you around. Pay out of pocket.) Hypothetically, you don’t need healthcare if you live/lived a near fundamentally perfect lifestyle. Accidents happen but then maybe don’t use knives or ever leave your home too. Be a bubble boy.
- leetcrew 6y agoyou are strawmanning me a bit. > people who don't elect a bunch of extra risk I'm not talking about preexisting conditions. I'm talking about conscious choices people make that increase their risk level. I'm not telling you how to live your life, but if our care is funded from the same pool and you live a riskier life by choice, I don't think it's unfair for me to ask that you pay proportionally more.
- bradlys 6y ago
- lodi 6y agoIf we're just handing out everything for free then I'd argue it's also better economically for people (and particularly kids) to have free eye care, free dental care, and a million other things I'd rather see subsidized over free Syphilis tests.
- stryan 6y agoEconomically, I absolutely agree and fortunately we have the power to do both. Plus Syphilis testing is very cheap, relative to most testing (about $20-$50 for early infections) and testing costs are only going down. Rapid testing is even cheaper, down to something like $5 per test.
- fao_ 6y agoWhy does it have to be either/or?
- Perseids 6y agoI 100% agree with you and I'm sorry this is not the case in the country you live in. I keep forgetting how bad the health care system is in some parts of the rich and developed world. I agree with my sibling comments that fortunately you can have all of those for free, for affordable prices for society, if the right policies are implemented.
- blacktriangle 6y agoMoral argument: functioning societies don't move the burden of the consequences of known risky behavior from those doing such behavior to those who are not. In fact, that's a recepie for a civilizational death spiral.
- stryan 6y agoI think I'd need to see a better argument that we're moving the burden of consequences. Riding a bike with no helmet is known risky behavior; if they get hit by a car or fall or their bike and have to go to the hospital, would you say that's shifting the burden of consequence? People with Syphilis who get tested and help for it still pay their taxes, which helped fund their treatment. They still have consequences such as having to see a doctor, take medicine which may be unpleasant (ever have GI side-effects from an anti-biotic?), and of course they experience the side-effects of, you know, having Syphilis. The government isn't taking $20 out of your wallet to bribe the bacteria to not infect someone.
- maximente 6y agostrange: drunk driving continues to cause grave personal, public health and economic harm to non-participants and has for, what, well over 50 years? yet the US seems to be largely "functioning".
- emodendroket 6y agoBy this standard we’re arguably at greater risk of civilizational death spiral, e.g., helping homeowners to rebuild in natural disaster-prone areas than trying to treat venereal disease.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dysrend 6y agoIt's better economically and for productivity for people to not have HIV, Syphilis, etc. Stop this. It isn't an economics issue. This is a moral issue. Your tract of reasoning is precisely why the world is growing so untenable for the human element. There needn't exist laws or programs or any other edifice by which regulation is effected. People need to be made to realize that they're being wholly indiscretionate and their disposition to do so comes at a cost, and it should be personal to make the point manifest.
- stryan 6y agoWith all due respect, the first half of comment is literally prefaced with "the moral argument". Personally I believe that argument should be enough, but you gotta play to the audience.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoYou yourself are making the distinction between the casual sex culture and STD testing. Diseases have a way of spreading and not testing for STD is a piss-poor way to change hookup culture for the better.
- ohazi 6y agoYou can yell about it, concoct vindictive policies to punish people whose behavior you don't like, dress up these policies by describing them in purportedly scientific economic terms like "subsidizing," "externality," "free rider," etc., but ultimately, this is a futile position to take. People are going to do what they want. If the effect of peoples' real aggregate behavior creates a negative effect that you might suffer from in the future, e.g. breeding antibiotic resistant bacteria, then the more effective position is to STFU with all of the moralizing and support policies that actually work, even if you have to pony up a bit to pay for them. It's cheaper for you in the long run -- you're not just paying to support risky behavior, you're paying so that behavior that is going to happen anyway doesn't put you at risk in the future. Your options are to be angry today and sick or dead tomorrow, or to let it go, support effective policies today, and get a better shot at a successful tomorrow. Yelling at people doesn't work.
- tryonenow 6y ago>STFU with all of the moralizing and support policies that actually work, even if you have to pony up a bit to pay for them. It's cheaper for you in the long run >Your options are to be angry today and sick or dead tomorrow, or to let it go, support effective policies today, You're asking for one portion of the populous to take on the burden cause by lack of restraint by another. There is legitimate reason for "moralizing" here. This is the point where what "two people do in the privacy of their bedroom" spills over into affecting everyone else. It's ironic that "yelling at people doesn't work" yet we see just as much yelling and moralizing by the people who want the freedom to do whatever they want even when their actions DO negatively affect others.
- Natsu 6y agoThis is always the hard part with public health policy, you can barely make any demands before people say screw this and ignore you, as we've learned from asking people to wear masks :/
- haberman 6y ago> STFU with all of the moralizing Parent is responding to accusations of "conservative prejudice." That is its own moralizing. You can make the pragmatic argument that it's pointless to try to control the risky behaviors of others, or to expect the people engaged in those risky behaviors to bear the cost of them. But it's pretty insulting to then disparage others as "prejudiced" for not liking this deal, while having no criticism of the behavior itself. "People are going to do what they want" -- well maybe some people want to be upset about subsidizing behavior they don't approve of.
- dghlsakjg 6y agoThe "conservatives" seem to be prejudiced against casual sex behaviors for the wrong reasons: religious dogma, moral panic, personal bias etc... The dollar cost of casual sex culture is not a reason I have heard cited as an argument against casual sex in pop conservatism. If you want to get into what costs society a greater amount, gay men getting syphilis is going to be way farther down the list than people having large numbers of children. We heavily subsidize that form of sexual activity.
- mjburgess 6y agoThe question is whether you want to deal with the STD health problem or not. Moralising doesn't get you anywhere. People are engaged in this behaviour either way, it doesn't require subsidy. What you do by enabling everyone to self-monitor is solve the collective harm of harmful viruses spreading. So do you want to preserve your moral sensibility, or do you want to stop the spread of viruses? I think it is perfectly reasonable to say, of people who choose the former, that they aren't very praiseworthy people.
- Natsu 6y ago> Moralising doesn't get you anywhere. Society is terrible at this, though. Issues like this tend to become proxy wars for other things. I mean, look how mask wearing has become moralized. It should never have become a silly political fight, it should've been people helping people get masks and avoid disease. Instead, we have all sorts of nonsense like idiots burning masks or arresting someone alone on a deserted beach for not having a mask.
- castlecrasher2 6y agoYou're advocating taking money from those who don't participate in these health-risking activities to subsidize those who do, and you're chastising the parent post for moralizing? How absurd.
- mjburgess 6y agoIt's not a subsidy. It's the cost of avoiding public health crises.
- scarmig 6y agoThe people disproportionately getting STDs have short time horizons. Regardless of the incentives in place, they're going to be having risky sex. It's less costly for society to pay for widespread testing and the occasional treatment than it is to pay for widespread treatment and no testing.
- busterarm 6y agoI always love reading your comments... You know, it's interesting that we highlight the health burden of other activities like smoking and some governments want to go as far as banning salt and sugary soda for the same reasons. But on this one topic we treat people like they're monsters for suggesting we should be choosier about our sexual encounters. Not just that sexual freedom is prioritized in our society, but _exercising_ that freedom is treated like a virtue. Despite all of the obvious costs and despite the fact that most people end up being less active than we'd expect and on the other side of that spectrum a lot of people come to regret their choices.
- standardUser 6y agoThere's a huge cost associated with child-rearing as well but that's just part of human civilization, as is lots of sex and, while we're at it, drug use.
- rayiner 6y agoThere are many countries where sex outside of marriage and drug use occur at very low rates. As a result they have escaped the attendant social problems, such as single parent households, the AIDS epidemic, etc.
- bluecurtains 6y agoUhhh you the same guy in your post history defending Bangladeshi marriage culture, which is based on forced child marriage? Big oof to have any moralizing from "conservatives" like you.
- Perseids 6y ago"prejudices" was a bad wording. I'm sorry to have ignited that much emotional heat which deters from good discussion culture. My usage of "prejudice" was the best kind of correct: technically correct. I was thinking about how nearly everyone that I had a personal discussion with lost their view point about how subsidizing STI tests was a bad idea after I told them about personal experiences of some acquaintances of mine. So those people were (technically) prejudiced, as a close inspection of such cases changed their judgement. Nonetheless, the word itself has strong connotations and it's mostly neither nice nor effective to tell someone to their face that they are prejudiced. And I can't assume it to be the case about a potential reader of my post. Regarding whether it is good policy, even with a conservative value system, my sibling comments have already presented most of the points I would make.
- haberman 6y agoThis is a really gracious comment, thanks for being so understanding.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> that maybe the “conservatives” are correct to be “prejudiced” against it? Because the most vocal "conservatives" are often the ones that, in private, are the most casual about sex. Not a day goes by without a news story about a conservative politician caught in some sexual scandal/coverup/fiasco. It is to the point that if I see any powerful man advocating abstinence I just assume he has a couple girlfriends stashed somewhere. Thou doth protest too much.
- lowbloodsugar 6y agoDo you drive a car? Do you eat red meat? Do you burn fossil fuels or rely on any kind of electricity? Well done. We are all subsidizing your risky lifestyle. When you are willing to retire to a plot of land and live entirely upon it, including starving each winter, then you may throw stones at "subsidizing" other people's risky behavior. Until then, you don't get to pick and choose which behavior we subsidize and which we do not. Alternatively, we can pass a law that says citizens can choose which kinds of risky behavior they are willing so subsidize with their taxes.
- gnull 6y agoOther people's risky sexual behaviour can harm you even if you (normally) don't engage in it yourself; it's not like skiing where people can break only their own necks. You can do two things to minimize the harm: (a) try to reduce the number of people who engage in risky sex—through changing people's views, different upbringing and whatnot; (b) try to mitigate the consequences of their behaviour—by subsidizing testing for infections and treatment. Note that there's no dichotomy here. I don't know if there's a good, reliable way to do (a); also, some people can be against it for ideological reasons. But (b) in the meantime is straightforward to implement and is known to be efficient. Why not implement (b) and make it work it while we are arguing about (a)? > maybe the “conservatives” are correct to be “prejudiced” against it? Conservatives should not be stigmatized for supporting (a), this is not prejudice, they can have the view they have on sex. But I don't see a single reason, except prejudice, that can make you go against (b), which is simply practical.