6 ms·
This decision seems illogical to many commenters here, but I assume the decision was made by professionals with all the data in front of them. Which then raise
by londons_explore 6y ago
This decision seems illogical to many commenters here, but I assume the decision was made by professionals with all the data in front of them.
Which then raises the question, why did these professionals make a decision so different than the "obvious" opinion here?
- Tenoke 6y agoProfessionals make wrong decisions all the time, often because the wrong professionals are the ones making them. Are people already forgetting how masks were actively disrecommended by 'professionals' at the start of the pandemic while plenty here and in other places were similarly saying that masks are obviously good?
- AndrewUnmuted 6y ago> Are people already forgetting how masks were actively disrecommended by 'professionals' at the start of the pandemic while plenty here and in other places were similarly saying that masks are obviously good? We are talking about science, I thought. Phrases like "obviously good," really are not in the scientific spirit. Professionals also said that double-masking is even more obviously, obviously good. But that obvious obviousness was, quite obviously, wrong. [0] [0] https://dossier.substack.com/p/the-cdcs-double-mask-mannequin-study https://dossier.substack.com/p/the-cdcs-double-mask-mannequi...
- rhn_mk1 6y agoNothing in the article states that double masking is not good. It merely states that the study doesn't give any reliable conclusions.
- SiempreViernes 6y agoAre you saying it's obviously good, but you can't tell it helps?
- Tenoke 6y agoAs far as I can tell nobody but you is using the phrase 'obviously good' for that particular claim and is simply the case of a specific study being touted and then turning out it has flaws which does happen all the time and isn't what we were talking about.
- jonathanstrange 6y agoYou must have listened to the wrong "experts" then. There was a bit of an initial, politically influenced confusion in the US at the beginning up until about June. However, where I live all experts recommended wearing masks from the start. They did say that people should not rush to buy FFP2 masks and chirurgical masks at a time when there was a shortage of those for health professionals, which was definitely the right recommendation at the time. The most drastic "disrecommendation" I've ever heard by an expert was to point out that you don't need to wear a mask if you keep proper distance and follow all other hygiene measures. In a nutshell, they did recommend not to wear masks for a short time during the beginning of the pandemic but at least the experts I've heard always provided the right justification - to prevent shortage.
- Tenoke 6y ago>There was a bit of an initial, politically influenced confusion in the US at the beginning up until about June You are downplaying it - they were actively taking a stance against them in the US and June was already quite late into the pandemic. The WHO themselves were advising people NOT to wear a mask and that it might be even more dangerous to wear one than not to wear it months into the pandemic.. They also only revised this in June. https://twitter.com/whowpro/status/1243171683067777024 https://twitter.com/whowpro/status/1243171683067777024
- jonathanstrange 6y agoFirst, we'll have to ignore the US because the government interference and rampant irrationality there caused hundreds of thousands of lives lost. Regarding the EU: I feel a certain irony, because I was among those who complained that experts give the wrong advice for noble reasons (partly due to good information from HN, btw), called it a "King's Lie" and was heavily downvoted for it on various social media. So I'll be the first to admit that some officials were not as clear about it as they should have been. However, many people fail to correctly interpret official statements, especially those made by WHO at the time. You only ever officially recommend something in evidence-based medicine if there is evidence of its beneficial effects, never out of a gut feeling. They should have said "we are using masks because we believe they work but we're short of them and so you shouldn't buy them" and instead said "there is no evidence that wearing masks is beneficial and it could even be dangerous" to prevent shortage. The WHO's statement lacked transparency but if they had stated that everybody should wear masks in March 2020, the effects would have been disastrous for health authorities all over the world. National health authorities did the very same at the time, and I used to point out that a "King's Lie" like this, no matter how noble the motives, will likely backfire - as evidenced by your statements. Still, if you listened closely, no expert I know of has ever said in any interview that masks don't help. That's all I wanted to point out.
- hntroll666 6y agoI appreciate this gentle style of cult deprogramming.
- dTal 6y agoPlease take your political crusade somewhere else, "hntroll666".
- schattschneider 6y agoPeople on this platform, I assume, are familiar with the scientific consensus on these topics and generally side with the science. But one has to understand, that these decisions are not made directly by scientists but by politicians who have scientific advisors. And as politicians, they will factor in a lot more than just the hard science on a topic, which can result in seemingly unscientific decisions that go against the "obvious" findings.
- Svip 6y agoExcept this decision was made by the relevant authorities and not by politicians. If anything, Danish politicians are probably not keen on this decision, but have chosen to respect it. It should also be noted that Denmark has a relatively low infection rate, which is probably why politicians has decided not to interfere in the decision.
- corty 6y agoIt should also be noted that public health officials are usually the lowest rungs of the ladder when it comes to ability in medicine. Running your own practice, running a research institute or chair or even just working in a hospital is far more interesting financially as well as for the challenge. Becoming a public servant as a doctor is a way out when your marks are just above passing or your motivation is insufficient for anything with even minimal amounts of stress (of course not atm, but that is an exception).
- stinkytaco 6y agoI'd really like to see some data on this, because that's a giant assumption to make. There's many reasons an able person would choose to work in public health beyond that they are apparently too bad at medicine to do anything else.
- dennis_jeeves 6y agoAgreed the competent are most likely to run their own practice. This is true of virtually any field.
- 0-_-0 6y agoBecause it's a kind of a trolley-problem that makes people make wrong decisions because of how society assigns blame. If the vaccine kills 1 person, they can be held directly responsible for that death. However, if the lack of vaccine kills 100 people, their deaths are the result of COVID, and would not be considered the result of the decision. In trolley problem terms, they would be blamed for pushing someone in front of the train to save others, but not for their inaction leading to a larger number of deaths. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem
- mamon 6y agoBut they are not stopping vaccinations, they will simply switch to Pfizer/Moderna vaccines. So I guess no one will die because of that decision.
- londons_explore 6y agoAnd someone has already updated the wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem#Example_with_COVID-19_vaccinations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem#Example_with_C...
- throwawayboise 6y agoAnd I think in general people are inherently equipped to handle the idea of getting sick and dying. It happens to everyone eventually; it's unavoidable. Death from something another person's actions can be blamed for is much less tolerable.
- marvin 6y agoFrom Norway, where I wouldn't be surprised if authorities arrive at the same conclusion in next few days, it can be summarized pretty quickly: -Risk of death from side effects in <65 patients is estimated at 3x higher than the international consensus, based on local observations. Unknown why this is the case, but seems unlikely to just be a statistical anomaly. - >65 population is largely vaccinated already -Vaccines from other manufacturers are expected to be available for everyone shortly -Covid is under control and new cases are few. Risk of dying from infection in a given month is extremely low. When risk of death from vaccine is estimated at the order of 1 in 50.000, (ballpark figure based on memory), the vaccination risk outweighs Covid risk by far. Would be a tough call if other vaccines wouldn't be available, but they will be. It's not a long delay. -Given the above, it's crucial to make sound ethical decisions to maintain public's trust in vaccinations and health authorities. This is not the last time we need to trust health authorities with our wellbeing. In closing, summarized very briefly: there is a lot of orthodoxy regarding vaccination strategy in the community of science-interested folks. It's very fascinating to watch part of this consensus being challenged with good scientific arguments.
- neilwilson 6y agoBecause 'professionals' have no more clue than the rest of us. "Science is the belief in the ignorance of experts. When someone says ‘science teaches such and such’, he is using the word incorrectly. Science doesn’t teach it; experience teaches it" - Feynman. What you have here is the European "precautionary principle" in action. Whatever you do, don't get blamed for anything - whether you make any forward progress or not. At 60 you have a 1 in 100 chance of being dead in the next year anyway. A 1 in a million extra risk on top of that is a rounding error. The zero extra risk option is no longer available. I've had the AZ jab. It's perfectly fine and does the job. And those downvoting this post are saying that I should be dead instead.
- devit 6y agoNot sure it's that illogical. mRNA vaccines are apparently better and don't seem to have serious side effects, so only using those is correct if it doesn't delay immunity too long. According to the article, this might cause a 4 weeks delay: currently Denmark has around 2 deaths per day, thus possibly causing 60 additional deaths, which would match a vaccine death rate of 1/100000. Denmark has a 6 million population, and it seems AstraZeneca kills around 1/1000000 so it seems COVID is only 10x more lethal than the vaccine in the general population. However death rates for COVID are much higher in the elderly while vaccine clot rates are much higher in young people, so the AstraZeneca vaccine might be more lethal in present day Denmark for young people. Even among elderly people they can eliminate their COVID risk by isolating but they would be forced to take the vaccine risk if the government only offers the AstraZeneca vaccine. Finally any vaccine deaths can be more easily attributed to the person who made the decision to continue using the vaccine thon COVID deaths.
- joakleaf 6y ago+ most elderly have already been vaccinated or are in between shots.
- erk__ 6y agoThe note [0] (in Danish) published by the danish health authority with the reasoning for this puts the number a bit higher at around 5 to 10 per 1,000,000 [1], another thing that the note points out is if they start the vaccine program up with the AZ vaccine again, it may delay it in the older population even more as they think many people would say no to it. [0]: https://www.sst.dk/-/media/Udgivelser/2021/Corona/Vaccination/Notater/Notat-vedr-fortsat-udrulning-af-COVID-19-vaccine-i-Danmark-uden-Vaxzevria140421.ashx https://www.sst.dk/-/media/Udgivelser/2021/Corona/Vaccinatio... [1]: 1/40000 chance of serious complication with a around 20-40% chance of death, source: [0].
- trjordan 6y agoBecause they may see that reducing the J&J supply to zero doesn’t meaningfully change the time to fully vaccinated. Because they may see that clotting worries would harm public trust in vaccines, delaying or preventing us from getting to herd immunity. Because they may see the number of people tested for blood clots, indicating the number is much higher than 1 in a million. Because they may see that trading a week of paused administration at this point is a reasonable price to pay to ensure we get to herd immunity.
- FlyingAvatar 6y agoTo me the problem with these kind of blanket decisions is: (a) The reasoning is often either not communicated, or is poorly communicated. (b) It takes away a risk/benefit decision from people that are mostly capable of making on their own. Don't want to take the risk of a rare side effect? Wait for an mRNA vaccine. Think the risk of COVID for your particular scenario is higher? Let me accept the risk. There isn't a way that a single model of the scenario produces the 'correct' or 'safest' decision for everyone. Also, there is no good reason that a person of sound reasoning cannot make this decision for themselves.
- michaelt 6y ago0. It's not like the vaccines get discarded or the factory slows down - every dose that isn't purchased by rich western countries is one that will go elsewhere, possibly saving even more lives. 1. Professionals might have data we don't have - maybe they've used up their stock of AZ but have plenty of other vaccines. 2. They might be making more nuanced calculations. For example, if they've already vaccinated all their high-risk groups, the risk-to-reward trade off for younger groups might be worse. 3. Alternately, they might be being more conservative than you and I. I'm expecting the end of vaccine roll-outs to mean lockdowns and masks end permanently and the entire economy comes out of hibernation, which is a big pay-off. But between the vaccine's less-than-100% success rate, the risk of new variants, people who can't be vaccinated, international travel and so on, they might feel my benefits are too speculative to have a place in their calculations. 4. Healthcare ethics can be a complicated matter, and they've probably spent longer agonising about it than we have. After all, you and I are talking about pulling a hypothetical lever - they're the ones who'll actually be pulling it and cleaning up the splattered blood. 5. They might be particularly worried about the vaccine-hesitant, feeling hesitancy is a bigger risk than the deaths caused by vaccine rollouts taking a few months longer. They might feel the best way to reassure the vaccine-hesitant is to be demonstrably extra-vigilant, rather than providing reassurance that might sound like denial or cover-up. 6. Public health comms has to be inclusive of even the dumbest people in the population. Nuanced, complex messages might get lost in the mix. With this, the message is "WE NOT GIVE YOU BAD VACCINE. YOU GET VACCINE WE GIVE YOU GOOD VACCINE." - very simple!
- slver 6y ago> This decision seems illogical to many commenters here, but I assume the decision was made by professionals with all the data in front of them. The decision was made by politicians who only consider public reaction. Public reaction which is decidedly uninformed, and without all data in front of them. I wish you were right. What you say should have been the case. All over the world though, we see the true nature of high-level decisions.
- henrikeh 6y agoWhat do you have to back up that it is a decision made by “politicians”? Sundhedsstyrelsen (the Danish Health Authority) makes that recommendation to not use it, not the government. Some parties are discussing giving a choice of AZ, but Sundhedsstyrelsen has then said that _that_ is a decision outside of their realm. But the recommendation is made outside of the government and parliament.
- baggy_trough 6y agoPeople are different and have different interests. There is no reason to believe that a highly insulated public health bureaucrat will make an optimal choice for any particular individual or for society as a whole.
- Symmetry 6y agoMedical professionals tend to be overly cautious when evaluating threats. The CDC says a woman should never have two glasses of wine in a single meal (or any if she's fertile and sexually active) but we laugh this off as the CDC being the CDC and ignore it. It's their job to be concerned about health risks and so they are. Doubtless they'd ban downhill skiing, driving over 35 mph, and parachuting if they could but thankfully we don't give them that power. But we do give them the power to ban medicines and that's where actual trouble can start. And it's understandable. If every time a Japansese person stole something you heard about it sooner or later your intuition would be convinced that they're all a bunch of thieves. If you heard about every bicycle accident you'd be scared to ever ride. US cops do hear about it every time one of their number is killed and we can see the resulting paranoia with which they treat the public. And the people at health regulatory agencies get fed a constant stream of medical mishaps. To counteract this bias any organization really needs to make explicit cost benefit analyses with real numbers if they're going to make sensible decisions. We force highway safety and toxicology regulators to do this. We really ought to have the medical regulator do it as well but for some reason we don't.