3 ms·
>Utilitarian ethics require that people inhabit thought experiments like this. Sure, utilitiarian ethics might require this. But moving a level up, utilitaria
by coldtea 6y ago
>Utilitarian ethics require that people inhabit thought experiments like this.
Sure, utilitiarian ethics might require this.
But moving a level up, utilitarian ethics themselves are not required. Especially in this form.
Historical ethics have always been utilitarian - in the sense of serving the preservation/goals of the community (or leaders) that established them.
But precisely for that, they were developed not based on astract utility (based on ill-defined terms like "good", "happiness", etc), but on concrete goals, beliefs, etc, and under the influence of concrete desires and historical feedback and struggles ("emergent/evolutionary" would be a better term).
The modern eponymous "utilitarian ethics", is an ahistorical, naive version of ethics, where everything is reduced to abstract utility discussions and mind games.
- walleeee 6y agoI agree. All that follows is wild speculation, but... Maybe the utilitarianisms of history maintained concrete referents in part because the notion of "utility" worked somewhere in basement brain. When we pulled it shrieking into the light of consciousness it died and we buried the body under a heap of cope born of the hope that ethics could be reduced to a formalism. (Of course clever and unscrupulous people quickly figured out how to weaponize this as well)