8 ms·
I'm kind of annoyed by some of the general negative tone of some of the comments here: "Ha! The FBI is guilty of hacking", or "But they didn't patch the root ca
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I'm kind of annoyed by some of the general negative tone of some of the comments here: "Ha! The FBI is guilty of hacking", or "But they didn't patch the root cause!"
In my understanding, the FBI:
1. Applied for and received a lawful court order
2. To make as minimally invasive as change as possible to help the targeted networks
3. While making a best effort to contact the network owners to tell them what they were doing and then
4. Widely publicizing what they did.
Not everything is some big "gotcha" conspiracy. We can just say "thank you" and move on.
- alfiedotwtf 6y ago> We can just say “thank you“ and move on Tl;dr: I’m from the government, and I’m here to help
- zapdrive 6y agoNice try, FBI.
- andrewstuart2 6y agoI don't know that anybody is frustrated about what they did. It's that anybody else who could have benevolently done the same thing, much faster, but without all the process, would be in massively hot water. I think mostly it's just frustrating to want to do the right thing, know that you could, also know that you can't, and then see somebody get to do it officially so much later. Top that all off with the fact that it's really hard to trace who and what were involved, versus a more transparent process where legitimate experts could chime in and prevent any further harm. Instead we have to cross our fingers that they did it right and that the judge understood what he was agreeing to. And I mean it's not a unique problem to this circumstance. Just kinda how institutions tend to be.
- vulcan01 6y ago> It's that anybody else who could have benevolently done the same thing, much faster, but without all the process, would be in massively hot water. Isn't this how it is with a lot of things? The government can tax people. If I tried to tax people, that would be illegal coercion.
- andrewstuart2 6y agoIt's definitely that way with a lot of things, but it can still be super frustrating for anyone who would prefer to use their knowledge for good, but due to scar tissue, we know we can't. Scar tissue being both the laws as understandable and justifiable reactions to misuse by those with less admirable intentions, and from seeing the laws used to unjustly prosecute people trying to do the right thing in the face of authority who won't listen, and assuming wrongly that all they need is a demo to help them understand the severity of the problem.
- dx034 6y agoThat's what police is for. There are enough situations outside of the digital world where it's better to call the police and let them help instead of getting too involved yourself. I believe it's good that not everyone can apply their own judgement in what needs fixing but that police/law enforcement applies certain standards there (although obviously not always correctly).
- DangerousPie 6y ago> I don't know that anybody is frustrated about what they did. It's that anybody else who could have benevolently done the same thing, much faster, but without all the process, would be in massively hot water. But the process is the whole point isn't it? If anyone was able to do this whenever they wanted and without oversight that would be a major concern. This is an example how this kind of thing can be done in a safer, legal way. Of course it won't be as fast as just letting anyone do this, but that's a price worth paying.
- ROARosen 6y agoThough their intentions are probably noble, I get a niggling feeling when I hear this. To me the FBI's behavior is the equivalent of "Since there have been several break-ins in our district and our local police dept. has determined that the internal door locks of business offices in our district are faulty, so we have broken into each business, and fixed the locks ourselves, we have attempted to trace you and notify you if you have publicly available contact info". Noble, yet still chilling.
- dx034 6y agoIt's actually not uncommon for police patrols to notify people if they see unsecured property. And that can be hard to do if no one is home and they don't want to alert actual criminals. To enter the property they often need a court order (unless there's an immediate threat), but I've seen efforts by police to drop notes wherever they see unsecured doors or windows that could be targeted for a break-in. Especially if there have been break-ins targeting certain weaknesses (e.g. open windows), police will look for those and alert owners. The problem with a hack is that it can be done within hours on properties everywhere, so just dropping a note won't be fast enough for most. Where there is an equivalent in real-world (i.e. immediate threat of a break-in), police can and will act to secure that property. So I don't see the chilling effect, it's something that (at least in Europe) is common part of preventive policing.
- thombat 6y agoNot unlike glaziers boarding up a broken window to prevent intrusion or weather damage (although that also serves as a good opportunity to advertise the services to a newly-discovered prospective customer)
- jrochkind1 6y ago>To enter the property they often need a court order Exactly, in this case they got the equivalent of a court order to enter every house and check the locks. Which no judge would be likely to approve if it were actual physical houses. But servers... The weird thing is the warrant authorizing entry into pretty much any computer anywhere. Could they get a warrant to enter any computer anywhere to look for child porn? Or "terrorism" or whatever? Probably not, that's not the way warrants work, except now are they going to?
- boomboomsubban 6y agoImagine you were were one of the targets for this exploit, the FBI intervened in the issue, and three months from now damaging information started leaking to the press. How would you show the source was the original hackers and not the FBI?
- tyingq 6y agoThe annoyance for me is precedent. If, for example, part of the mechanism that allowed them to do this involved a search warrant for "all computers in the US"...that's a precedent that has obvious, chilling, future implications. Perhaps that wasn't the mechanism, but it's such a broad action that I'm worried something like that is involved.