2 ms·
>there are objective definitions for appropriate and inappropriate, based on shared values and context. not necessarily. Taking out the more heated factors for
by johnnyanmac 6y ago
>there are objective definitions for appropriate and inappropriate, based on shared values and context.
not necessarily. Taking out the more heated factors for a moment, think of a concept as simple as spoilers. spoiling others are widely considered to be an impolite move, but a community formed around talking about a work wouldn't want to have to blur every image or paragraph in order to have a conversation on what may be years old points. There's no objectively perfect solution, even if there may be an almost objective factor to address.
In instances like this, leaving options is valuable. Some may want to keep all screenshots unblurred, while others may want to take minimal risks.
>and you leave that up to each individual to decide, what's shared, and what sort of "community" is actually offered?
I don't think anyone is proposing an anarchy. At the end of the day, there may be some rulesets made by consensus, but it is beholden to the sub-community moderator and their personal whims, who is beholden to the community owner and their personal whims, who is beholden to some loose sets of laws based on their country. So this structure is impossible outside of some sort of decentralized p2p server setup (which sounds like a mess to communicate in).
- alex_g 6y agoThis is a great point. When I say based on shared values and contexts, I mean at the community level. So for a community where people discuss Harry Potter books, many members are not going to want to be careful about everything they say for fear of spoiling someone else's experience. But some people might want to experience reading the books for the first time with other people in the same boat as them. If this community was well managed, they might solve this by: - Writing into the community guidelines that spoiler tags only need to be used when discussing something that's NEW. - Users have the ability to have spoiler content hidden/shown by default. The key here is that the definition of what a spoiler is, is still defined by the community, not the individual. - Creating a separate area within their community for new readers to chat about the books, where discussion about events in future books is not allowed. By joining the community, and agreeing to the community guidelines, you are agreeing to abide by an objective definition for what's appropriate within that community. If you don't agree with those guidelines, you probably don't want to join that community. But without any shared guidelines, you do trend towards anarchy. Certain topic/niches will approach it faster than others.