3 ms·
More like – FBI wanted to patch affected servers remotely without getting every owner's consent but weren't sure of legality so they asked a judge to sign off o
by paxys 6y ago
More like – FBI wanted to patch affected servers remotely without getting every owner's consent but weren't sure of legality so they asked a judge to sign off on it.
- elliekelly 6y agoWhoa. Has this ever been done before?
- vmception 6y agoAsking a judge for a really broad constructive warrant and pretending that the founding fathers anticipated this use case in their aggregate infinite wisdom is very common
- tony101 6y agoThe warrant is actually quite specific, down to the exact URL paths of the shells to be searched and removed. See pages 20 and 21 of https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1386631/download https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1386631/downl...
- atat7024 6y agoHow many IPs are they allowed to break into to find the webserver behind those domains?
- not2b 6y agoIt's bizarre to think that we should be bound forever more to only do the things that people in 1789 thought appropriate. But it seems to me that they followed the procedure outlined in the 4th amendment; they went to court and got a specific warrant to remove a specific bit of malware from a specified set of servers. Madison deliberately left many provisions in the Constitution and Bill of Rights open-ended because he wasn't an idiot and knew that the founders could not anticipate everything. Had the FBI acted on its own it would be overreach. They went to court, got a warrant, and did pretty much the minimum required to eliminate the threat.
- jamiek88 6y agoGood job those aristocrats from 1790's were omnipotent then.
- IHLayman 6y agoActually, according to the brief they actually didn’t patch the servers, but only removed the web shell: “This operation was successful in copying and removing those web shells. However, it did not patch any Microsoft Exchange Server zero-day vulnerabilities or search for or remove any additional malware or hacking tools that hacking groups may have placed on victim networks by exploiting the web shells.”