3 ms·
Monetary constraints are just as binding as fiscal ones. MMT is just a somewhat obscure refactoring of what mainstream economics calls the "fiscal theory of th
by zozbot234 6y ago
Monetary constraints are just as binding as fiscal ones. MMT is just a somewhat obscure refactoring of what mainstream economics calls the "fiscal theory of the price level". It mostly comes up with reference to settings like Weimar Germany, or late-2000s Zimbabwe.
- dools 6y agoNope that’s not correct. MMT describes how currency works, and always has worked.
- zozbot234 6y ago> MMT describes how currency works, and always has worked. So you agree with my parent comment? My reference to Weimar Germany and late-2000s Zimbabwe was intended to point out the broadly-acknowledged normative implications of the descriptive content that's shared by MMT and the FTPL.
- dools 6y agoI don’t know what FTPL is but I certainly don’t agree that an MMT understanding of economics implies that one will create a hyper inflationary economy. Quite the opposite.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Monetary constraints are just as binding as fiscal ones Even if that were the case (and its not; in the metaphor of the fisc, there is a hard advance limit—money must come into the fisc by tax or borrowing to be spent, wasn’t hasn’t come in cannot be spent—whereas monetary constraints are more of the “you can do it, but there will be consequences” type), the key thing is that the (real) monetary constraints are different than the (illusory, stemming from a bad metaphor) fiscal ones.
- zozbot234 6y ago> in the metaphor of the fisc, there is a hard advance limit Not so. A government that's able to borrow can issue debt and roll it over indefinitely under some conditions (viz. so long as economic growth is higher than the return being paid on that debt). It amounts to the exact same thing.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> > in the metaphor of the fisc, there is a hard advance limit > Not so. A government that's able to borrow can issue debt and roll it over indefinitely under some conditions The hard limit is “the amount of debt borrowers are willing to purchase” (plus current revenue plus reserves.) In MMT “spending” is equivalent to money creation and “borrowing”, like “revenue” is money destruction (but, in the case of borrowing, with a promise to create more and use it in a particular way in the future.) And there is no necessary quantitative tie between creation and destruction; a fiscal imbalance need not be bridged by borrowing (requiring a borrower) or additional revenues or additional reserves.