4 ms·
Are ethnic minorities extended the "right of return" in Israel? Last I checked this was not the case.
by whimsicalism 6y ago
Are ethnic minorities extended the "right of return" in Israel? Last I checked this was not the case.
- hoka-one-one 6y agoYes, if they convert to Judaism. Seems reasonable, Judaism doesn't ban any ethnic minorities.
- whimsicalism 6y agoSorry, what was this about "not being governed by religious law"? > full rights for women, minorities, and LGBTQ So not full rights for religious minorities. Moreover, conversion is quite difficult and the process is made much easier if you have a parent who is Jewish (which generally forms an ethnic group). Only recently were non-Orthodox conversions recognized for this purpose: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/01/world/middleeast/israel-jewish-converts-citizenship.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/01/world/middleeast/israel-j... Also, if you are from Palestine or Iran, you are excluded from citizenship via https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizenship_and_Entry_into_Israel_Law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizenship_and_Entry_into_Isr... ie. specifically on the basis of your ethnicity &/or national origin. I find it hard to take seriously claims of equal & full rights for minorities when those rights require converting to a different religion or being of a different ethnicity in order to apply to you.
- hoka-one-one 6y agoIt's important for people to understand that Judaism is a minority religion that has been historically persecuted. There is nothing wrong with working to preserve the tradition and culture, and if it ends in a small amount of ethnic homogeneity then it has to be accepted as necessary, especially since "Jewish" is both a religion and an ethnicity, so in the current historical context failing to preserve Judaism means failing to preserve Jews. Empowering BIPOC isn't about expecting all the same things. It's about giving BIPOC the resources they need for their ethnic and cultural self-determination.
- whimsicalism 6y agoHow does denying citizenship to minorities help preserve Jewish culture? I'm glad you've backed away from the "equal rights for all rhetoric" though. It's too bad Afrikaners didn't try harder to "preserve the traditional and culture" of minority rule in South Africa as well. Historical persecution doesn't justify enthnostates in my mind, I didn't realize this was a controversial opinion. e: Since you've now edited your comment to include the statement about "BIPOC", Jewishness is orthogonal to "BIPOC" and most Jewish people are white. I say that as someone of Sephardic descent.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cwkoss 6y ago> There is nothing wrong with working to preserve the tradition and culture, and if it ends in a small amount of ethnic homogeneity then it has to be accepted as necessary "a small amount of ethnic homogeneity" seems like a deliberate minimization. Israel is an apartheid state that has been persecuting based on ethnicity and religion for decades.
- monocasa 6y agoThat's actually not as clear as you might think. https://www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2020/10/15/the-jews-from-ethiopia-who-confound-israels-law-of-return https://www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2020/10/15/...
- sharikous 6y agoWhat do you mean? Can a Senegalese become a citizen of the USA (or of almost any country on Earth) without a lengthy naturalization? If not, is the USA discriminatory. Of course the right of return is just for Jews. Every country gets to set its own rules for citizenship. But Israeli citizens enjoy a reasonable democracy, with advanced civil rights, and respect human rights of others, too. Of course not at 100% but way better then all of their neighbors
- whimsicalism 6y agoThe United States doesn't grant you privileges for being a Christian or being white. The United States doesn't label itself as a "white country." Israel grants privileges for being Jewish and denies citizenship if you are from Palestine.
- jkkorn 6y agoThink of judaism as ethnicity. You can be an atheist jew and be granted Israeli citizenship. Israel is the historic homeland of the jewish culture/people. I'd liken it to something like Country X giving special immigration privileges if you have ancestry from country X. They don't deny citizenship if you're palestinian, granted it's as difficult if you were trying to get citizenship coming from any other country
- whimsicalism 6y agoI have a solid conception of judaism, I've lived in places with thriving jewish communities my entire life, and am sephardic-descended myself. > it's as difficult if you were trying to get citizenship coming from any other country Nope, it's more so. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizenship_and_Entry_into_Israel_Law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizenship_and_Entry_into_Isr... In general, I am opposed to ethnostates and granting nationality based on what bloodline you come from. I think it is ironic that there is a right of "return" for Jewish people, but no such right of return for people who were displaced during the Nakba.
- 6y ago