8 ms·
Black Girls Code
- UShouldBWorking 6y agoWow, that's incredibly raciest.
- dang 6y agoTrolling HN like this will get your main account banned as well, so please don't. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- silsosil 6y agocool but who asked?
- NietTim 6y agoNobody. But that shouldn't be a reason to not do things because a lot of times people don't even know what to ask for.
- silsosil 6y agoI dont want to get racial but who cares what skin or gender you are if you're coding
- dang 6y agoHN is for curious, thoughtful conversation, not flamewar. I've banned this account. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- vark_vekernes 6y agoyea, thanks but no. I will keep thinking my way
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dang 6y agoAll: this thread started to fill up almost immediately with internet dreck. We don't want that here—it's predictable, which is boring, and leads to flamewars, which are nasty. We ban accounts that do that kind of thing, so please don't do it here. What to do instead: have curious conversation [1, 2]. Be reflective, not reflexive [3]. If you're unsure whether you're doing those things, wait for it to become clear before you post [4]. [1] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=curiosity%20optimiz%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor... [2] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=curiosity%20repetition%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so... [3] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=reflective%20reflex%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor... [4] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=%22no%20harm%20in%20waiting%22%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...
- INTPenis 6y agoIf you want to support the movement there are also mens versions of all the clothes they sell but they're in the size drop-down on the product page: https://blackgirlscode.bigcartel.com/product/black-girls-code-t-shirt-design-1 https://blackgirlscode.bigcartel.com/product/black-girls-cod... Personally I like donating by getting something in return, like a sticker or a t-shirt. Also helps spread the word.
- yuppie_scum 6y agoThey are a 503B as well. I donated quite a bit to them last year. I didn’t come from much but I did have access to computers via relatives and my school district. That’s something not everyone has. The interest I developed at a young age led me to a very lucrative career. It does not threaten my white male ego to think that other people from more disadvantaged backgrounds deserve a chance to at least learn a little about the field.
- mvzvm 6y agoI think this is not an interesting link drop. And I'll go one step further - I went out of my way to try to volunteer here. I emailed them, I added some of them on linkedin, I tried (pre-covid) various different methods of reaching out, and all were ignored. For all intents and purposes, this seems to have been abandoned.
- mvzvm 6y agoOh! Afterthought - If anyone reading this actually knows how I can get in touch with them, LMK! I am still interested.
- eprparadox 6y agoi volunteered for a weekend activity with this organization just by using the links on the site. i am not a POC and indicated that i'd be willing to offer technical or just logistical help. i ended up being a classroom assistant for a robotics camp. overall good experience.
- KingMob 6y agoI think some packets were dropped...I've volunteered a few times, and they're very much alive.
- reilly3000 6y agoThis is great to see. The tech industry suffers for lack of diverse voices. Its sad to see nothing but banned comments in this section so far; if that doesn't indicate the need for proactive programs like this I don't know what does.
- woofster 6y agoSorry, not my fetish
- hinkley 6y agoIf memory serves I heard about this group a year or so ago when NK Jemisin did a fundraiser event.
- ivan888 6y agoThe answer to "why does this need to involve race?" and many similar questions can be found on the about page [0]. It does a very good job of succinctly describing why we need campaigns and organizations like this to break down the racial, gender, and cultural barriers that prevent so many people from feeling comfortable or accepted in STEM careers or academic settings. [0]: https://www.blackgirlscode.com/about-bgc.html https://www.blackgirlscode.com/about-bgc.html
- ojagodzinski 6y ago> Much has changed since my college days, but there’s still a dearth of African-American women in science, technology, engineering and math professions, an absence that cannot be explained by, say, a lack of interest in these fields. XD yeah, because racism is always the answer. Also there is no enough black people hiking because forests in US are racist as fuck. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/jul/13/hiking-african-american-racism-nature https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/jul/13/hiking-a...
- dolni 6y ago> But I also recall, as I pursued my studies, feeling culturally isolated: few of my classmates looked like me. This statement feels a bit yucky to me. Like the whole premise of this movement is that diversity is valuable, but then there's this feeling of discontent about a lot of people not looking like you. It kind of reeks of hypocrisy, if I'm being honest. Even if black women were represented in programming in a way that reflects America's demographics, "few of my classmates looked like me" would still be true. > Much has changed since my college days, but there’s still a dearth of African-American women in science, technology, engineering and math professions In agreement so far... > an absence that cannot be explained by, say, a lack of interest in these fields. This is where it falls apart for me. This is an assertion without evidence. I haven't yet heard a convincing argument (or really any argument) that people of different cultural, racial, gender backgrounds will gravitate towards similar professions, on average. To me, the better question (and harder to address) is "_why_ do you feel so utterly disconnected from white and Asian men on a person-to-person level that you would be pushed out of a dream job?" We're all human beings, and there is plenty of common ground to be found in that. The long-term goal should not be to have your Netflixes, Amazons, and Googles of the world full of black, Asian, latino, and white men and women all sitting at their own lunch tables. Unfortunately, it feels a lot like that's where it's going to me.
- ojagodzinski 6y agoYeah, because They ask me about my gender and race every time I open any github repository or read tech doc... Happily providing any type of education only to specific gender is illegal in my country as per constitution (Poland). https://arslege.pl/zasada-rownosci-kobiet-i-mezczyzn/k15/a5264/ https://arslege.pl/zasada-rownosci-kobiet-i-mezczyzn/k15/a52...
- tehwebguy 6y agoThat's great! Sadly, our constitution did not outlaw the extremely common practice of enslaving Black people until the 13th amendment, which was only ratified in 1865. In the hundreds of years prior to that most everyone else in the country was allowed to acquire land, wealth and an education while the enslaved folks were legally blocked from doing the same. It took nearly another ~100 years for their right to vote to be marginally protected and to finally end legal segregation, that was less than one generation ago so you can imagine that the inequity here won't match that of every other country.
- culot 6y agoYour snarky, condescending post most definitely goes against HN rules. You did not attempt engage the parent, you did not address the content of their post whatsoever, instead, in a sarcastic tone, resorted to preaching a total aside.
- tehwebguy 6y agoYou have it exactly backwards, the post I replied to started with a sarcastic sentence but mine contained none and wasn’t meant to have any snark or condescension. My assumption is that they are not aware of the tragic, race-based history here (they said they live in Poland, I doubt the curriculum there has years and years of US history) so I gave them a brief overview of the history behind the current inequity that this group aims to help correct (including specifically talking about some related differences between their statement about the Polish constitution and how the US constitution started and changed over the centuries)
- usbline 6y agoI really hate these faux-grassroots programs. I've never seen these people host any events near me, and I live in a fairly large inner city area. If individual nerds can consistently have meetups every month there isn't any excuse especially with how much money they seem to be getting. The past events page is also...depressingly barren. But they're getting that sweet sweet investor $$$ from Nike and AT&T!
- tryonenow 6y agoThe real issue is constantly swept under the rug. The only real barrier to POC in STEM in 2021 is POC culture. It's hard to host events for inner city denizens when the vast majority are simply uninterested in such pursuits, or worse, shun each other for having such interests. Lack of representation will not be solved so long as we continue to ignore this inconvenient truth. And it's similar for lack of female representation. Edit: in anticipation of controversy, it is not my attempt to troll or start any flamewars with this comment. It's a perspective that is sorely lacking in discussions addressing diversity in tech, and dangerously so, because if we refuse to question the role of the choices of those who are underrepresented, then the only alternative is to blame people and systems who are not responsible for the issues, which makes the interventions ineffective at best, counterproductive and destabilizing at worst.
- usbline 6y agoI'm a little sad this comment was dead and I couldn't respond earlier... ANYWAY: >the vast majority are simply uninterested in such pursuits I really think this is an "image" problem. I'd say the majority of people are uninterested in technology, so the numbers are already low. But it also has a huge connotation of the people who DO like it being white/asian nerds, or affluent people who can afford to go to college for computer science. People want to fit in, no one wants to be alone. And if you're just some black kid, you're going to feel really out of place. Even if no one is being racist to you, you're still going to FEEL alone (even if you're not). And that's not fun. This isn't just a tech problem. Think about welders or metalworkers. I think about bearded, husky white guys. But I'm sure there's plenty of girls who think swords kick ass but don't want to feel like an outsider. It's understandable for people to feel this way. It's like the complete opposite of the Utopian Hacker idea where just your contributions matter, nothing else. About how good or enthusiastic you are, not about WHO you are. I don't think any single group or initiative can get rid of stereotypes with careers or subcultures. I'm not even sure if it CAN be done.
- tomas_nort 6y agoHow cute
- Grieving 6y agoDespite my extreme objections to the race/gender preference, I enjoy teaching and accepted the invitation to help out at a program like this (not this one in particular). I didn't get the idea that they were highly effective. Sessions consisted of walking them through an insanely long list of terminal commands and code snippets that were to be copied without any real understanding of what was happening. By the end the girls just looked overwhelmed and discouraged at the amount of garbage needed to create a "modern web app", which is certainly the most stupid place to start with programming. I left feeling as though I'd thoroughly destroyed what interest they may have had in the field, and never accepted another invitation.
- renewiltord 6y agoThat is unfortunate. I wonder if perhaps undirected learning is where the magic is in this sort of thing and the lack is in tool availability. Certainly it's how lots of us learned.
- floren 6y agoI agree that undirected learning is huge. I don't know how I'd go about reproducing it... you need both availability of resources (software and hardware), and you need plenty of relaxed time spent with those resources to find the particular angle you end up taking into the environment. That doesn't seem compatible with a bootcamp-ish weekend program where you get hand-held through "making a web app" because the point is to Make You A Coder. If I was trying to figure out how to actually give kids the opportunity to get interested in coding, well, I'd start off trying to go for an open-ended after-school program, where you can drop in and mess around with computer stuff with access to knowledgeable adults if needed. I'd try to get the adults to propose interesting little projects that might capture the imagination of the kids. I'd try to get donated VPS time, not so we can force the kids to make cookie-cutter web apps but so they can put together their own janky terrible stuff, and if they screw up we just kill the VPS and start over. Personally, I think trying to focus on games too much is also a mistake--either you end up with the Logo turtle (educational but incredibly boring) or you have 9 kids just playing Minecraft while the tenth actually learns to script it.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cashewchoo 6y agoConfession: For a long time I didn't really think movements like these were necessary. "Why does it have to be for group X? Why not just have it open to everyone?" I still see a lot of sentiment like that on the internet. I felt like they were themselves racist. I've slowly come around. I understand now why things like this program aren't racist, why they exist, and why the people they target can uniquely benefit from outreach. Moreover, I don't think I understand enough the struggles that underrepresented groups go through, and the fact that I'm oblivious to them is part of my own privileged upbringing (white, male, middle class, suburbs, nuclear family, single income, etc). I think I still have a long ways to go, and one thing I've been thinking about is how I can try to capture the worldview that I used to have while I was in the "this isn't a problem, stop posting about it/i'm tired of reading about it" camp and thus use it to explain to people who are still stuck in it. The only reason I think I came to understand is because a dear friend of mine gradually explained it to me in a way that I understood. Anyway, while I was writing this, lots of low-quality comments have come and been deleted, so I feel like it's worth hitting post. I can't eloquently and convincingly articulate why things like this are needed yet, especially to an already-convinced-otherwise audience, but maybe someone else can.
- marsven_422 6y agoWho is paying you to post this?
- tpoacher 6y agoI feel the same, but with an added caveat. Just because some movements/concepts are 'A Good Thing™' doesn't mean that they are not amenable to abuse by 'Not So Good Things™'. E.g., whenever a company lobbies for stuff, it's never "for the profits of our stakeholders"; it's always "for the sake of the children". Therefore while I applaud positive movements, I'm also always weary to note the timing and subtext in which they are presented, and very often it feels like there is a disingenuous agenda behind them, that sours the apple for me.
- bennysomething 6y agoI can sympathize with feeling of needing this. But I can't help thinking, what if my daughter wanted to go to this with say a black friend, she wouldn't be allowed. It sort of feels like it will ultimately create division rather than heal it. I'd prefer kids were taught that they can try anything they dam well please. They just need to try. Btw this is all hypothetical, my daughter is two and we live in the UK.
- sdfsjdgljg 6y agoẛûϲĸ ὴįɡǧēӷԑ That is about six minutes, or one percent, longer than the radio rotational period measured by the Voyager 1 and Voyager 2 spacecraft, which flew by Saturn in 1980 and 1981.
- neilv 6y agoOne reason I like efforts like this is because they say to an underrepresented group "this is for also for you", when otherwise the implicit message often is that it's not. That's not the only reason, but (based on frequent comments on this topic) it's a reason that should be articulated, because it isn't necessarily obvious to someone who wasn't told -- so many times, in so many ways -- "this isn't for you".
- yarg 6y agoWell that seems unnecessarily specific. Rather than whittling down subgroup after subgroup, why not try to help out the underexposed in general? The differences between what the sexes are interested in is distinct enough that figuring out how to get girls interested and prevent them from being discouraged needs to be considered. However, I don't belief the racial differences are enough to justify efforts to encourage black people specifically - there's use in shared culture from an outreach perspective, but here I think that the most ground can be gained from efforts to engage with marginalised children in general; regardless of race. I just don't think that focusing on intersections of the disadvantaged yields useful results. For example, efforts to help blind kids learn to code could be very useful - but a specific effort to help only blind black females with gimpy legs would be a waste of time and resources (and good luck finding teachers at all, let alone any that meet your increasingly exclusionary criteria).
- hackerrrnews 6y agoSurely you could have taken the time to research why the creators of this program thought being this specific was necessary?
- yarg 6y agoI simply don't think that this can work the way that it's intended to - do what you can to break down barriers to entry, but as far as I'm concerned once those barriers are broken there's not much value in segregation. I can't imagine that once those barriers have been broken and a well supported kid gets into code that the impact of race and sex will be significant when compared to motivation and aptitude. I also think that if your trying to break down barriers you're not going to do a very good job with class rooms defined by anti-diversity. Anyway, what's with the month old throwaway account?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anm89 6y agoI overall think programs like this are more of a good thing than a bad thing. I however could see them having negative psychological effects on participants that do more to widen gaps than close them. For instance it gives an impression that black girls need to do programming in a protected separated environment because the environment at large is not safe for them or accepting of them. I think this might even be true in some cases but regardless I don't think it's beneficial to anyone to promote the idea, and I think it is certainly sending the signal that that is the way things are to these young girls which I think can be self perpetuating. I hope I am wrong.
- KingMob 6y ago> it gives an impression that black girls need to do programming in a protected separated environment because the environment at large is not safe for them or accepting of them That's a pretty accurate impression. And it's not groups like BGC perpetuating that idea, it's the culture at large. We're nowhere near the utopian ideal where black groups are overly cautious about American society.
- anm89 6y agoIt's certainly not actively encouraging them to go exist out in the broader ecosystem. Again, I'm not arguing that a black girl of color wouldnt face challenges in that system that others wouldn't. But self segregate at your own risk.
- benjohnson 6y agoIn my HR hat, I would be reluctant to hire anybody that had recent training that was explicitly given exclusively to one race or excluding other federally protected classes like religion, gender, or handicap.
- tzekid 6y agoI don't get why this gets downvoted, it's a fair comment. A group for emigrants in a foreign country would be reasonable, but just segregating by gender and race like this where there is no language or cultural barrier is unnecessary and could be harmful.
- tehwebguy 6y agoProbably because it misses the point entirely and in an almost comical way uses “HR” as an excuse to exclude from the hiring process someone for a reason other than merit or ability? Maybe OP would also exclude folks from religious institutions as well, people who learned to code at BYU or a Catholic college, or one of the like 30,000 Christian high schools, but I would probably downvote that sentiment too.