9 ms·
The video [1] has much more explanation. 3:2 screen ratio, I really wish the whole PC industry including Mac moves towards it. Even 16:10 is not enough when we
by ksec 6y ago
The video [1] has much more explanation.
3:2 screen ratio, I really wish the whole PC industry including Mac moves towards it. Even 16:10 is not enough when we increasingly clutter the vertical space with OS menus, controls, dock. And then Browsers address bar, tab bar, then we have the WebSite layout which is also taking vertical space at the top for navigation.
1.3mm Key Travel. Which is the same as the old perfect MacBook Scissors Keyboard. Instead Apple went to 1.0mm Key travel in their magic keyboard just to save face.
Sane size precision trackpad, no more absurdly large trackpad that has easy false positive when you are typing on it.
Replaceable SSD, Keyboard, and Monitor for easy repair. Wow.
Surface Connect - Is that Microsoft version of MagSafe?
Larger sensor for better quality HD Video Call. They even compare it to MacBook Air 2020 LoL.
I haven't looked at PC Laptop hardware for quite some time, but in mid 2010, Dell or HP's motherboard and Laptop layout just aren't anywhere near as good as Apple. But this Surface Laptop definitely took lots of clues from the old MacBook ( I am wondering if they have ex-Apple MacBook Engineers on their team ).
Ignoring the Software, this Laptop looks exceptionally good!
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z3N3u6NyWSY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z3N3u6NyWSY
- saboot 6y ago> Replaceable SSD, Keyboard, and Monitor for easy repair. Wow. By far the biggest selling point for me! I wouldn't even consider apple products for this reason.
- rvz 6y agoExactly. At least Microsoft has courage. Unlike Apple who seems to like to solder everything onto the board, such that to fix the SSD would require an entirely new logic board and a trip to the Apple Store. That alone makes the Surface 4 'look' like a good deal, but at the price of $1000? No thanks and no deal (For now).
- klodolph 6y agoIt's super weird to see this phrased as "courage". I can understand the desiderata--"I want a user-servicable laptop" is entirely a reasonable position--but framing this narrative as "courageous" is bizarre. It's all a mix of branding and utility.
- CoolGuySteve 6y agoIf anything, Apple's environmental impact and their advertising around it is a staggeringly courageous amount of bullshit considering how hard they make it to service, upgrade, and repurpose old devices.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI use my Apple devices for a substantially longer time than the alternative, so I would say I’ve probably consumed less.
- edaemon 6y agoI'm pretty sure they're referencing Apple saying it took "courage" to remove the iPhone's headphone jack.
- CrazyCatDog 6y agoAnd for my generation: the courage to ditch CD-ROM drives!
- drusepth 6y agoAFAIK, companies "having courage" has been a meme for a few years after Apple said it took great courage (or similar) to remove the headphone jack.
- 6y ago
- bsd44 6y agoSoldering "everything" is not specific to Apple.
- NetOpWibby 6y agoBut boy, the crowd here loves to harp on it though.
- wil421 6y agoReally hoping that Jony Ive leaving will have a positive impact in regards to serviceability. Hopefully the blowback for their obsession with thinness was due to Ive.
- swordsmith 6y agoCompared to the pricetag of Macbooks, $1000 is a great deal, no?
- FearlessNebula 6y agoThe $999 Air will outperform this most likely. Build quality will be similar
- ValentineC 6y ago> At least Microsoft has courage. I see what you did there: https://www.theverge.com/2016/9/7/12838024/apple-iphone-7-plus-headphone-jack-removal-courage https://www.theverge.com/2016/9/7/12838024/apple-iphone-7-pl...
- crossroadsguy 6y agoAre you kidding me? SSD? In 2012, 4-5 days after the purchase of my first and last MacBook Air, they gave me a quote that was half the price of the new MBA when a key cap just popped out. I literally was using it and it popped out. Their reasoning: physical damage + (this is the kicker) in Air there’s no provision to repair the key or key cap, entire lower board/chassis needs to be replaced. Yes just a key cap! I shouted to customer support. It was replaced. I decided I am not paying for another fruit company laptop. (In their defence they tried to pull this off in a country with pretty much no or no accessible consumer protection)
- Toutouxc 6y agoI'm having a hard time believing that. The 2012 Air keyboard is a normal scissor keyboard, there's only the keycap and the scissor plastic thingy beneath it, you can literally repair it with a bit of superglue if you're lucky. Was it Apple who told you this? Or a 3rd party service center? A reseller? What country did they try to pull this off in?
- GeekyBear 6y ago>At least Microsoft has courage. Is this the same Microsoft whose original Surface Laptop got the lowest repairability score that iFixit has ever given? >According to iFixit, the Surface Laptop isn’t repairable at all. In fact, it got a 0 out of 10 for repairability and was labeled a “glue-filled monstrosity.” Ouch. That’s never happened before. The lowest scores previously were a 1 out of 10 for all previous iterations of the Surface Pro https://www.extremetech.com/computing/251046-ifixit-labels-surface-laptop-glue-filled-monstrosity https://www.extremetech.com/computing/251046-ifixit-labels-s...
- NotPractical 6y agoIs the battery replaceable, though? The Surface Laptop 3 also had some repairable parts, but the big disappointment in my mind was the glued-in battery.[1] Batteries are consumable and are guaranteed to start wearing down within a few years, whereas the SSD, keyboard, monitor, etc. are likely to last a long time, so it was surprising that they advertised its repairability even with this significant omission. I feel weird using my MacBook Pro, knowing it's essentially a ticking time bomb, with its slowly degrading battery that can't be replaced. [1] https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Microsoft+Surface+Laptop+3+(15-inch)+Teardown/127277#s246879 https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Microsoft+Surface+Laptop+3+(...
- penagwin 6y agoI worked in computer/phone repair and a bit of design, You can see [1] that they are using multiple cells essentially taped together to make their "battery". This isn't uncommon, especially recently in smaller devices, as it lets them fit unusual shapes and other size issues, and saves space because you don't need a shell around them. The biggest (only?) issue is that you have a very delicate batteries taped together, if ripped/torn they may explode. To add to this, because they aren't riggedly attached, they are more prone to movement (and thus tearing). Their solution was to use adhesive across the bottom to make sure they are all firmly in place [0]. From a repair perspective this isn't great. It's not hard to remove if you have a heated plate, isopropyl, and patience, but not very user friendly. The best thing they could do to fix this would be to give the battery a rigid enclosure, but that will of course eat up valuable space, and I have no idea how that would affect the rest of their design. They could also use different tape that's easier to remove, but they may see the taped-together battery as something they don't want to be liable for people replacing (in case they tear it), so I really think the best solution is a rigid shell for the batteries. tldr; This appears to mostly be a design limitation instead of a purposeful decision. I wish they'd change their design instead though.... [0] https://guide-images.cdn.ifixit.com/igi/FkZHQOAv2sPqKSBE.medium https://guide-images.cdn.ifixit.com/igi/FkZHQOAv2sPqKSBE.med... [1] https://guide-images.cdn.ifixit.com/igi/VJBBLeHLWsRBQeIS.medium https://guide-images.cdn.ifixit.com/igi/VJBBLeHLWsRBQeIS.med...
- deleted 6y ago
- robertoandred 6y ago3:2 and 16:10 are very very close.
- Synaesthesia 6y ago3:2 is 15:10. It’s a pretty big deal, almost as big as going from 16:9 to 16:10 More vertical space is a win in my book.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoIf only they hadn't done away with 4:3: >>> 4/3 1.3333333333333333 >>> 3/2 1.5 >>> 16/10 1.6 >>> 16/9 1.7777777777777777 I use an external portrait monitor for this reason, and it is quite luxurious. So much less scrolling. Also, if one is complaining about the dock, move it to the side.
- cheschire 6y agoI (literally) went the opposite direction with a 32:9 monitor. I guess everyone's got their preferences!
- mixmastamyk 6y agoIf big enough and hi-res enough, it could be doable. Also if you often do multiple things at once. I find most of the time, I'm looking at one or two long documents (web page, source code) and running shells on my landscape laptop monitor so the combo works perfectly for me.
- cheschire 6y agoI'm usually gaming (immersion is better in superwide) or I'm writing code (more real estate for uncollapsed visual studio windows) or browsing the web with netflix etc snapped to the side. However I must note that superwide monitors are absolutely unusable in windows without PowerToys FancyZones functionality.
- smoldesu 6y agoI had a Surface Pro for a few years, it ran GNOME like a champ. These Windows laptops also have pretty good Linux support afaik, so the software issue isn't that big of a deal!
- withinboredom 6y agoI remember those kernel patches fondly.
- jll29 6y agoIs there a Ubuntu image that supports SL4? (Microsoft has still not yet released one for SL3, to the best of my knowledge.)
- the__alchemist 6y agoI was never happy with this. It's fine if you use it as a laptop, but the pen input was laggy, the OSK was finnicky, and there's no OneNote equivalent on Linux.
- floatboth 6y agoIt's the other way around: Linux has some extra support for these laptops. And of course the place where extra support is required is the input devices. Despite Microsoft kinda pushing the industry to standardize on HID over I2C, they themselves now do HID over… uh… a custom protocol that runs over UART of all things. https://www.kernel.org/doc/html/latest/driver-api/surface_aggregator/ssh.html https://www.kernel.org/doc/html/latest/driver-api/surface_ag... https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/hid/hid.git/commit/?h=for-next&id=b05ff1002a5c19f2fd511c6eada6f475ff701841 https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/hid/hid.git/... Well at least it is HID inside I guess. Meanwhile Apple used a custom simple protocol over SPI for the Broadwell-Kaby Lake generations (and now Apple Silicon), but the few "T2" generations went back to USB… over some truly cursed custom T2 USB host controller https://github.com/MCMrARM/mbp2018-bridge-drv https://github.com/MCMrARM/mbp2018-bridge-drv (WTF) --- Also many Surface devices used awful Marvell Wi-Fi :/ At least the "Laptop 3" generation switched to Intel on Intel models and Qualcomm (seems like ath10k) on AMD ones.
- johncessna 6y ago> Surface Connect - Is that Microsoft version of MagSafe? Basically. I was disappointed to see it on my 2nd or 3rd generation. I thought we were past the days of proprietary connectors.
- dygd 6y agoThe video mentions that the Surface 4 USB-C port allows charging, which is great.
- Arainach 6y agoThe Surface Laptop 3 supports it as well. The proprietary Surface connector needs to go away. I've had Surface devices for years, so I have plenty of the chargers around - and I hate them. They fall out, they break, they die. My Surface Dock lasted less than a year before its connector wouldn't connect again. I'm disappointed they've still stuck with it. I'd MUCH rather have another USB-C port on the other side so I could charge it from either direction. I carry around a USB-C charger that charges all of my devices. I never want to have to carry around a proprietary brick again.
- 908B64B197 6y agoThey kept this one for a few generations now/across a few models. I wish they made it open.
- ziml77 6y agoA bad proprietary connector at that. The device side has failed on me a few times, requiring replacements. After about a year the connector needs to be pulled at just the right angle to charge the device. It would slowly get worse until I couldn't get it to make a connection at all. I'm sure the issue is that I have it plugged in while it's on my lap a lot of the time, but barrel plugs and USB-C have not given me any issues under the same conditions.
- withinboredom 6y agoJust wipe it down with a bit of alcohol (while unplugged from the wall of course). I’ve found the connector tends to wear from “sparking” when connecting and disconnecting and gets a thin layer of carbon on it.
- ziml77 6y agoI actually feel cramped on 3:2. It's great if I maximize one window, but as soon as I try to split the width between two windows, everything is too narrow. It's especially bad when the windows are Firefox with Tree Style Tab and an IDE with a project navigation pane.
- kitsunesoba 6y agoWouldn't this depend on how the ratio is achieved? For example, with 16:9 → 16:10, you're often just gaining some vertical pixels (like 1920x1080 vs 1920x1200), so everything that was comfortable on 16:9 is equally workable on 16:10.
- ziml77 6y agoYes it does depend on that, but usually there's some width lost for the gained height. You don't even need to measure it against another display to know that's the case. If you only add pixels to the top of a display, the diagonal size will increase. So if the display isn't any larger then it means that the horizontal size of the screen was reduced. That of course also means that each pixel is smaller. Depending on how much smaller, you might need to scale everything on the display up which has the same effect on fitting things in as having fewer pixels.
- twobitshifter 6y agoYeah I’ve maximized my use of a wide screen. Dock on the side and tree style tabs is the way to go IMO.
- ansible 6y ago> Replaceable SSD, Keyboard, and Monitor for easy repair. Wow. I realize that making a replaceable battery is not easy this days, but I would like to see manufacturers at least not make it absurdly hard to replace. Here's hoping MS didn't use too much glue and tape to secure the battery in place on the Surface Laptop 4...
- nfoz 6y agoIn what sense is it "not easy these days"? The Panasonic "Let's Note" series (Japan only) has had models with two batteries -- one internal, and one removable (hot-swappable) that you could charge with USB while the laptop keeps running on the main battery. I'm not sure why our imagination for laptops is so limited.
- jolux 6y agoLenovo did that for a while. I believe they called it Power Bridge.
- dntrkv 6y agoHave you seen the internals of a Macbook? There is no single battery, it's a few batteries (wired in series I believe)[0] Making the battery removable would compromise on other parts of the design. Personally, a replaceable battery is very low on my list of wants. [0] https://www.ifixit.com/Store/Mac/MacBook-Pro-15-Inch-Retina-Mid-2018-2019-Battery/IF117-115 https://www.ifixit.com/Store/Mac/MacBook-Pro-15-Inch-Retina-...
- nightowl_games 6y agoHaving irreplaceable batteries makes your device have a very short lifespan. This is horrible for the environment. I'm typing this on a pixel 1 that I've replaced the battery in, and have used for 4+ years. Laptops should have replaceable batteries. Period. If you get a new laptop every 2 years and don't know what it's like to have a perfectly good MacBook with 30minutes of battery life, then maybe you can just imagine being in that position and consider how globally impactful this anti consumer practice is.
- bosswipe 6y agoLaptop vertical space is why I always setup my docks on the left or right. And one of the reasons I still use Firefox Tree Style Tab even though Mozilla keeps making it harder and harder to use.
- 015a 6y ago> Surface Connect - Is that Microsoft version of MagSafe? Yes & No; its Microsoft's proprietary version of Thunderbolt 3, which does have magnetic connect/disconnect.
- pwthornton 6y agoOn the dock front, I recommend putting it on the left for a 16:10 display. I almost never use the dock on the bottom anymore. I find this a lot more useful, and it fits with the aspect ratio of the screens that are being shipped.
- addison-lee 6y agoBest solution is to just have the dock hidden.
- dylan604 6y agoI've been playing with the option in macOS to hide the menu bar as well. The extra screen space is significant to me. The one draw back is that I have a habit of glancing up at the clock from time to time. Now, that's hidden, and I find myself totally losing track of time. Not such a big deal now for WFH, but I do spend more time on things than I would if the clock were still in view. Other than that, I don't miss the menu bar either.
- robotresearcher 6y agoOn the left and hidden. Code and English documents are top-left biased, so this position means as well as being near the menu bar it's typically closer to your pointer position than the bottom is. Also, I like to add my Application folder to the dock as a more-compact replacement for Launchpad.
- nailer 6y ago> Ignoring the Software, this Laptop looks exceptionally good! Paying attention to the software, WSL2 is one of the most convenient ways to run nix. No more messing with homebrew, you get real apt-get (and the breadth of packages and speed of updates that come from running real Ubuntu or Debian) or whatever else you want.
- dylan604 6y agoI really need to read up more on WSL2, but I'm on a windows box so rarely I haven't spent the cycles on it. However, every single time I am on a windows box, I really wish I had it setup for WSL2. Every other box I connect to has essentially the same CLI features, until those rare times I hit a windows box. <shudder>
- usaphp 6y ago> no more absurdly large trackpad that has easy false positive when you are typing on it. What are you doing to get those? I've never had issues with that, and I absolutely love the large trackpad on my MacBook
- ngokevin 6y agoYeah, I love it as well. Zero false positives ever. If there's one thing Apple does right, it's a killer trackpad.
- nikau 6y agoI have that issue, I managed to make it a lot better by disabling almost every touchpad gesture on my mac.
- lenkite 6y agoHow big are your hands ? A significant number of people have issues and have had to change their typing style.
- ksec 6y agoI think it is the wrong trade off. >I’d still prefer a smaller trackpad to avoid accidental input. And it looks like the edges and indentation in front of the trackpad remain sharp, as if you aren’t supposed to put your hands near there [1] . You are trading absolute best for some people at the expense or annoyance for some people. The older trackpad isn't small either. Which is exactly the same thing with TouchBar and Keyboard. Some loves the butterfly keyboard, but they dont hate the old scissors keyboard. There are lots of people who hated the butterfly. [1] https://mjtsai.com/blog/2019/11/14/the-16-inch-macbook-pro/ https://mjtsai.com/blog/2019/11/14/the-16-inch-macbook-pro/
- agloeregrets 6y agoHard agree. OP seems a bit pedantic looking for bullet points. Personally the trackpad on this is pure downside.
- stormbeta 6y ago
- dylan604 6y ago> 3:2 screen ratio, I really wish the whole PC industry including Mac moves towards it. Even 16:10 is not enough when we increasingly clutter the vertical space with OS menus, controls, dock. And then Browsers address bar, tab bar, then we have the WebSite layout which is also taking vertical space at the top for navigation. I hated the 16:9 popularity of computer flat screens. Definitely agree about needing lots of vertical space. I was content with 1600x1200 for years, and then 1920x1200 (1.6 vs 1.5 ratio) was available that was acceptable. Amazing how much smaller 1920x1080 felt, and is just a joke for anything other than watching videos (maybe games? i'm not a gamer) in my daily usage. Never tried one of those rotated 90, but it might be more useful as 9:16.
- k__ 6y agoHaha, same here. Last week I watched a review of the LG gram and the reviewer said he liked the new 16:10 screens more, because they are higher and this new [sic] trend was promising. Meanwhile I'm using one of the last reasonably priced 16:10 screens I could get 10 years ago before the whole industry decided people only want 16:9. Same goes with glare and non-glare It's like display creators lost their minds in 2005.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoFor laptops/smaller desktop screens, the taller ratio definitely makes sense, although for laptops it makes for some form factor challenges in terms of overall and perceived size. For larger desktop screens, I definitely prefer the aspect ratio most closely matching full screen video. And for my comically large (43”) monitor, I couldn’t use the extra vertical space if I tried. Reducing the width would just limit my usable horizontal space and shrink video for my dual purpose TV use. > Same goes with glare and non-glare On this I’d also distinguish portable/desktop use cases. And weirdly they’re the opposite of what I’d prefer. It’s almost impossible for me to find large screen glass-front monitors with the contrast and color space benefits that come with that. And portable usage definitely benefits more from glare protection.
- jfim 6y ago
- beaner 6y agoAll of these things are nice, but they're easier to throw in than improving the operating system, and that's the biggest differentiator.
- vmladenov 6y ago> the old perfect MacBook Scissors Keyboard No way, the unibody MacBook Pro (2008-2011) had the perfect keyboard. I still have my 17”. The Retina’s keyboard was a painful downgrade that I never got used to.
- walrus01 6y agoI absolutely abhor 16:9 on laptops, one of the reasons why I'm using a macbook air is for the excellent 16:10 screen. If you go shopping for ordinary PC laptops in the $1000-1300 (USD) price range at a place like Best Buy and take a look at the quality of the LCDs, it's amazing how many absolutely shit 16:9 1920x1080 displays are being sold on machines at the same price as the macbook air's higher-dpi retina display. 16:9 on a desktop seems to be unavoidable these days, and indeed there's the whole popular trend of ultrawide/ultrawide-and-curved monitors now which go way beyond that.
- folkrav 6y agoI'm curious: why do you care about aspect ratio vs. (effective) resolution? Seems like an odd thing to focus on, when it has nothing to do with how much stuff you can display on screen. Do you mean at comparable sizes?
- walrus01 6y agoI care about both simultaneously - in my experience the common 1920x1080 laptop panels also have poor color rendition, poor brightness and overall image quality, in addition to not being a suitable dpi. I can see the blockiness and jagginess in fonts and GUI at 1920x1080 native. And scrolling vertically for anything is painful on a small 16:9 screen. The macbook happens to have both 16:10 aspect ratio and a higher quality LCD.
- diffeomorphism 6y agoBut lower resolution than a 4k 16:9 display (and no oled). So the question is why to prefer lower res 16:10 (lower in both directions) to 16:9? You just have strictly more screen, which seems better.
- walrus01 6y agoI was comparing laptops in the price range mentioned above, MacBook air vs 1080p laptops. If you go up to around $2000, then the windows 10 laptops start to have 4k screens.
- matthewfcarlson 6y agoReplying to the question about the surface connect. Yes, it's a magnetic charger that includes USB, display, and a few other wires. It's awesome. Former surface firmware engineer, opinions are my own.
- rodgerd 6y ago> And then Browsers address bar, tab bar, Edgium now allows the browser tab to be a vertical column, rather than a horizontal row, which is nice. I hope other browsers copy that.
- f6v 6y ago> Instead Apple went to 1.0mm Key travel in their magic keyboard just to save face I never got used to butterfly keyboard, even though I had one for more than 2 years. The new ones might not be the same as the old school, but feel amazing from the get go.
- abraxas 6y agoIs there a Linux distribution for it? Because I'm not putting up with Windows.
- darthrupert 6y agoThis is the most important question. This thing is a toy for me unless it can run Linux on metal.
- Copernicron 6y agoSurface Connect is a lot more than just MagSafe. It’s much more akin to thunderbolt with a magnetic plug. It combines power delivery and data transfer so you can power the laptop or plug in a full docking station using the same port. Sure it’s proprietary but I wish it was more widely adopted.