5 ms·
"Please switch to a browser that supports FLoC to view this page." [Links to Chrome, etc.] "This website requires a browser that supports FLoC. Please install
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago
"Please switch to a browser that supports FLoC to view this page." [Links to Chrome, etc.]
"This website requires a browser that supports FLoC. Please install one of the folllowing compatible browsers: " [Links for Chrome, etc.]
"We've detected you are using a browser that does not support FLoC. Please update your browser to use this website." [Links to Chrome, etc.]
"Your browser is outdated! Please upgrade." [Links to Chrome, etc.]
"Browsehappy" [Links to Chrome, etc.]
As someone who routinely uses a browser that does not support Javascript, I see "warnings" like this once in a while. There are so many. Apologies if I remember the wordings incorrectly. Of course, 99% of the time the lack of a Javascript engine has zero effect on the ability to retrieve the information I need from the site. And I still get the info in the 1% cases anyway, if I really want it.
With FLoC, will web developers be able to make claims that a site "will not work" without FLoC. How will they get users to use Chrome or other browsers that enable FLoC by default.
- mixedCase 6y agoIs FLoC built in a way where you couldn't just feed websites fake data?
- Ajedi32 6y agoYou definitely could. Though apparently in incognito mode it's recommended that browsers just throw an exception rather than provide fake data: https://github.com/WICG/floc/blob/dcd4c042fa6a81b048e04a78b184ea4203a75219/security-and-privacy-self-review.md#14-how-do-the-features-in-this-specification-work-in-the-context-of-a-browsers-private-browsing-or-incognito-mode https://github.com/WICG/floc/blob/dcd4c042fa6a81b048e04a78b1...
- MiddleEndian 6y agoOf course the FLoC team would want browsers to throw an exception, since that wouldn't damage the perceived legitimacy of FLoC. But as a user I'd rather feed them false data if possible.
- nitrogen 6y agoThere are quite a few ways for a site to distinguish private/incognito from normal browsing, and IMO these differences should be treated as bugs. Indeed, these differences often break sites (including a vaccine registration site) that should work fine. We don't need even more ways for sites to break in private/incognito mode.
- MiddleEndian 6y agoTotally agree, browsers should strive to make it so websites cannot tell if users are browsing privately or not.
- sanxiyn 6y agoThrowing an exception in incognito mode allows websites to detect incognito mode, which is not desirable. Incognito mode should provide fake data.
- Jonnax 6y agoGoogle have stated that they are not interested in preventing fingerprinting.
- type0 6y agoSure, but you would have to be careful with that though, if you use any Google services they might ban your account with no recourse.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoCould that be a blessing in disguise.
- Emendo 6y agoAt this point, the only browser that could ignore FLoC without being blocked by website is Safari. If Safari chooses not to implement FLoC, it might be sufficient to prevent web developers from blocking other non-FLoC browsers. All of this rest on Apple standing up for privacy through.. so watch for any announcements from Apple.
- kristofferR 6y agoPrivacy has been Apple's thing the last few years though, very unlike that they implement FLoC.
- drusepth 6y agoWhy wouldn't sites that rely on FLoC block Safari if the browser doesn't implement it?
- galangalalgol 6y agoI'd love to ditch javascript entirely. Is there an android browser that supports that?
- PAGAN_WIZARD 6y agofirefox on android supports noscript
- grishka 6y agoThat same Vivaldi does have a JS toggle.
- munk-a 6y agoI've been using NoScript with block-all by default (on a laptop - not mobile) for about two years now and I really appreciate how many sites I can visit and immediately close due to the sheer number of scripts that would be require enabling to actually render the page. It's a nice way to screen for better browsing experience pages.
- bosswipe 6y agoI use Firefox Android uTorrent's manual Javascript toggle (under "More"). I've found NoScript to be too much work but an easily accessible manual toggle works for me.
- Pick-A-Hill2019 6y agoTry Naked Browser (http://nakedbrowser.com/android/ http://nakedbrowser.com/android/ or Play Store link https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.fevdev.nakedbrowser https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.fevdev.nak...) Despite the somewhat contentious name the naked refers to it being stripped down. Once you get the hang of navigation it is extremely fast and a simple long press enables JS (if a site really needs it).
- cblconfederate 6y agoNah, tbh i dont even add adblocker-blockers. I think many publishers (most, i would say) are disgruntled with the way google totally dominated the market, and we'd rather stop feeding their monopoly this time. I added a referral link to brave browser on all my sites instead. anecdotally i rarely see adblocker-blockers anymore
- hilbert42 6y agoThis would be boring if it weren't so serious. It's damn time that the Googles of this world were brought to heel with legislation that has real teeth — i.e.: the levying of fines worth 20% upward of annual turnover as well as heavy fines levied on employees who concoct, design and or deliberately participate in introducing or maintaining these scams. Once employees are also targeted and held responsible for their actions at law then we stand a chance of getting at least some of our internet back. Google, Facebook and their cohorts are outrageous, they have been stealing our internet with complete impunity for over two decades like a metastasizing cancer. We users really do need to get proactive over this, if not then soon the internet will be effectively dead for many of us—we'll be left ghettoized in some outpost or alternatively we'll be forced to abandon it altogether. We may even need to resort to street demos or marches to convince politicians that the rotten, monopolistic behavior of Big Tech is no longer to be tolerated. It's also time we banned non-human entities (aka corporations) from lobbying politicians in private. Any lobbying by them ought to be done at public hearings specifically held for the purpose (corporate lobbying has probably done more damage to our Democracies since the Civil War or even earlier than any single other factor.) "As someone who routinely uses a browser that does not support Javascript,<...>" Likewise, my browser has JavaScript turned off by default. 1vuio0pswjnm7, what you failed to mention was how much faster webpages render without JavaScript, when it's switched off the speed improvement is enormous, also all that jerkiness and unevenness of presentation disappears. (As I've posted many times, it's not JavaScript that's the main fault-it's the enormous abuse websites commit using it. It's nothing nowadays for a webpage to be anywhere between 2 and 5MB in size, and on inspection a huge percentage of that code is devoted to serving up you private data to surveillance capitalism. Reality check: remember a standard page of text is only 2kB!) "Javascript engine has zero effect on the browser's ability to display the information I need from the site. And I still get the info 100% of the time anyway, if I really want it." Exactly right! Take note website owners who present blank pages when JavaScript is turned off: I used to find it a challenge to get your pages which I then proceed to do anyway. Now I no longer bother, as I've learned that websites that use such scummy lowdown tactics aren't worth visiting anyway. From my observation there's a remarkable correlation between such behavior and the [lack of] quality of the material on the website.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago
- syrrim 6y agoCould spoof it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- carlhjerpe 6y agoCould you not just send a random floc on every request?
- rivn 6y agothat's an instant ctrl+w, unless there's no alternative. and there is alternative for most things. I know that's a minority opinion, but I do hope it's a double-digit % minority - or at least it will be once things get bad enough.