4 ms·
I got scammed on the App Store a couple of weeks ago. I needed the SmartThings app for some Samsung home automation devices, searched for it, and installed thi
by simonw 6y ago
I got scammed on the App Store a couple of weeks ago.
I needed the SmartThings app for some Samsung home automation devices, searched for it, and installed this one:
https://apps.apple.com/us/app/smart-things-smart-view-app/id1538696472 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/smart-things-smart-view-app/id...
When it charged me a $20/year subscription (now cancelled) I thought "Wow, Samsung charging me for this feels pretty cheap of them, but I guess that's how they do things - after all, I found this on the App Store".
The app I should have installed was this one: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/smartthings/id1222822904 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/smartthings/id1222822904
- brianwawok 6y agoAnd I suspect you are in the top 1% of users. How is a 80 year old granny going to know which one to buy?
- fortran77 6y agoIt's because of this issue I've learned to never search for a manufacturer or company app in the app store. I go to the company's website and see if I can find an app store link to it there. It's nearly impossible for anyone--even the most savvy user--to identify which app is the real one and which one is a deceptive one.
- slobotron 6y agoKind of funny that we trust Google's index of the whole www to take us to manufacturer's legitimate website, but don't trust Apple's own search of their curated store.
- fortran77 6y agoYou don't need to trust Google. If you buy a Samsung phone, for example, their official domain would be printed in their documentation.
- fsckboy 6y agohis point was not about needing to, but that we can trust google, and it seems we can't trust apple, despite apple's promises about safety and vetting
- defaultname 6y agohttps://www.samsung.com/us/support/owners/app/smartthings.html https://www.samsung.com/us/support/owners/app/smartthings.ht... They link directly to the app. They almost certainly have relevant QR codes in the manuals to go directly to the app downloads. You can find the official app listed by "Samsung Electronics", where the "scam" app is by a third party. There are a lot of problems and egregious abuses in the app store (made much worse once recurring subscriptions appeared), however this particular thread is not convincing. Some third party made a control app for Samsung TVs. There is nothing wrong with that (and it does not, contrary to claims, misrepresent itself or even clone the official app, beyond the most superficial of mainstream design choices). There is no reasonable reason to think that the app is by Samsung. I don't see how it's a scam in any way. For someone to miss the Samsung app and download this, then agree to a subscription and pay, is something that I don't think many people would do. And it certainly isn't a fault of the store.
- simonw 6y ago"For someone to miss the Samsung app and download this, then agree to a subscription and pay, is something that I don't think many people would do. And it certainly isn't a fault of the store." I did exactly that, and I'm usually pretty savvy.
- planb 6y agoApart from the subscription scam, I don't see a problem here. Just imagine the comments here if Apple had rejected a legit app just because it has "Smart Things" in the name.
- andai 6y agoThey also copied the style and font of the screenshots from the official app (you know, the one whose name they stole, to trick people into installing it).
- 6510 6y agoThis wouldn't happen to anyone by accident. You always get the wrong app at the top if you search. I tried to find DHL earlier, I got bored so fast looking at non DHL apps I just used their website. Google isn't stuffing the search results with sites that look like DHL[0] [0] - https://www.google.com/about/honestresults/ https://www.google.com/about/honestresults/
- quickthrower2 6y agoSo an App Store full of real apps and 5 fake apps trying to gouge you per real app (some using ads so they are the first result). Sounds like a great future. Do extensive research before installing anything.
- csours 6y agoThe fake one has 4.1 stars and the real one has 4.4 stars, not a very strong signal. I wonder if they are also cheating that.
- flatline 6y agoI have learned to always check the developer name, and if I'm not 100% sure, I don't install it. It's annoying because there are a bunch of them out there like this. I've also seen the "free but not free" apps like in the twitter thread. Usually there is an invisible "X" in the top corner of the payment form that you can click to get past it and use the app's free features after all. My kids run into these all the time: they see an ad for a game, it has good reviews so I let them get it, it prompts them for payment. If you are clever you can sometimes get around it, but I've seen cheap old arcade game knock-offs asking for $30+/mo! This is not by any stretch the only developer making mad bank on a subpar app.
- tartoran 6y agoSomewhat tangential but looking up names is not always safe either, they could be made up. Latest scam on YouTube is to reply to comments with a clone account of the owner of the channel. They copy everything but the scam itself is quite bad, they want you to call a w-h-a-t-s-u-p number or something dumb that I would never bite. Youtube does nothing to stop these even when heavily reported.
- m463 6y agoThere is something about restrictions and subscriptions. Someone I know had a family plan thing with restrictions on their kid, but then got automatically charged for an app subscription somehow. Maybe install free app is ok, but auto-subscription bypasses restrictions?