2 ms·
I think the best way for Startuply to create value is to go through the academic literature and identify hiring best practices from organizational behavior and
by Alex3917 18y ago
I think the best way for Startuply to create value is to go through the academic literature and identify hiring best practices from organizational behavior and other fields. The site should then guide employers to hire using empirically proven best practices without requiring them to understand the theory behind the model or even realize that they are using one of these models. Trying to apply the the methods collaborative news filtering sites to hiring seems like a bad idea. (It sounds like you are trying to write an applicant quality predictor or something similar, unless you are just tracking the quality of applicants from different referral sources to optimize your advertising dollars.) Especially in this case, where showing an evaluator the judgments of previous evaluators creates an information cascade, which Surowiecki writes about in the Wisdom of Crowds.
- LukeG 18y agoThanks Alex. I think this latest feature is much more basic than that; we're not implementing a collaborative filtering algorithm for applicants. We let startups rate everyone who applies for their job. We think this helps, as everytime they log in, they can see who their preferred applicants are. The "collaborative" part of this just refers to the fact that we make it easy for multiple people on their team to rate a resume. A positive side effect of this is that we get data about how good our candidates are (or how good startups think they are, which is generally what counts here). This will let us focus our very limited resources much more accurately. "Empirically proven best practices" are tough in HR, especially for small companies, because every startup has such a distinct personality. This idea of "fit" is huge, and it's something we're working to address, but we also think it's important for our process to be as transparent as possible in such murky territory.
- Alex3917 18y agoThanks, I think I see what you're getting at now.
- joshwa 18y agoSee http://www.path101.com/explore/ http://www.path101.com/explore/
- LukeG 18y agoInntesting...thanks for this.
- lacker 18y agoAre there any "empirically proven best practices" for hiring? In the end it comes down to a personal decision more than any statistical resume analysis can give you.
- LukeG 18y agoAs far as we know, there aren't. Startups are especially hard, too: smarter, crazier people; more pressure and responsibility (the average value of a startup team member is far beyond that of a Fortune 500 employee); long hours with a small team in confined spaces. There are lots of pieces of advice from experienced entrepreneurs (e.g. http://bit.ly/2VMN10 http://bit.ly/2VMN10, http://bit.ly/3mgEBQ http://bit.ly/3mgEBQ), most of which is interesting and valuable but decidedly unscientific. We'll keep adding resources like this to our blog & site, but automating it is another challenge altogether. There is definitely a massive matching problem in the recruiting industry. I think that a big part of why this is so hard is that it takes a gnarly combination of technical & social engineering to fit these pieces (us) together. We like hard problems, though, and we're working on throwing some interesting stuff out there. Stay tuned.
- Alex3917 18y agoI meant more like how does the richness of the interviewing medium affect the hiring outcome. For example, should interviews be conducted on the phone, in person, or via IM? I've read that most hiring decisions are made within a minute of first seeing the person, so the medium in which interviews are conducted almost certainly makes a difference. But how? Similarly, which yields better decisions, group interviews or interviews with multiple individuals? Even though Startuply is upstream of the interviewing phase, the types of collaboration features they choose to implement can potentially affect the way the resumes are evaluated. I'm not sure how much research there is in this area, but it seems like something the company could potentially use to their advantage.
- HeyLaughingBoy 18y agoYes. My employer requires us to take a course in how to interview candidates and there are practices that make a considerable difference in the interviewing process vs. how most people do it. It seemed like a total waste of time until I actually took the course and realized how much room for improvement there was.